Main Street Pizza Wallingford

368 Main St, Wallingford
(203) 265-5454

Recent Reviews

Tsering C.

They confirmed my delivery order and gave me an estimate wait time and let me wait for 2 hours then cancelled my ordered! Will never order from here again and will never use Grubhub again. Unacceptable

Brenda Buckley

Really enjoyed their large mozzarella pizza! It's a thin crust which we love. We did pick it up mid evening on a sat. 15 min wait. Fresh and hot! Friendly service. We'll be back.

Jennifer Caffrey

I've always liked Main Street Pizza but now that they have got a new owners I don't like your pizza since you don't know what you're doing your pizza was awful it hardly had any sauce too much cheese not enough of the toppings I think you should sell out and let somebody else take over the business because it's obvious you don't know what you guys are doing you don't speak English and people don't understand you I will never order from you again that sauce had no seasoning I don't know where you learned how to make pizza but what appear Italian make the pizza

Tawna Jacobs

I ordered online for delivery. I was quoted 6:59 pm as a delivery time. At 7:10, I called the shop to find out if the pizza was on the way. The woman had to put me on hold for a couple of minutes and she came back to tell me that he would be here any minute, we are really far away. Um. We're 3.9 miles from the shop. So the guy finally gets here and he has the wrong two liter.I called the shop back to let her know that we were NOT that far away (only 3.9 miles), the courteous thing to have done would be call the customer to let them know their order is late and we were given the wrong drink. I did let her know it was our first time ordering from Main St Pizza and we won't be back. Instead of apologizing to me, she hung up. I am so unbelievably dissatisfied and frankly, shocked by her behavior.The pizza is ok. The garlic cheese bread was cooked/melted then folded in half so that didn't work out well. The pizza has a ton of cheese and very little sauce. Eh.

Ryan P

Good pizza. Took forever to make, though.

Tawna J.

I ordered online for delivery. I was quoted 6:59 pm as a delivery time. At 7:10, I called the shop to find out if the pizza was on the way. The woman had to put me on hold for a couple of minutes and she came back to tell me that he would be here any minute, we are really far away. Um. We're 3.9 miles from the shop. So the guy finally gets here and he has the wrong two liter. I called the shop back to let her know that we were NOT that far away (only 3.9 miles), the courteous thing to have done would be call the customer to let them know their order is late and we were given the wrong drink. I did let her know it was our first time ordering from Main St Pizza and we won't be back. Instead of apologizing to me, she hung up. I am so unbelievably dissatisfied and frankly, shocked by her behavior. The pizza is ok. The garlic cheese bread was cooked/melted the. Folded in half so that didn't work out well. The pizza has a ton of cheese and very little sauce. Eh.

Salih S.

the products are fine, pizzas and others. prices are affordable. There is a free package service

Lisa Schafrick

I ate at Main Street Pizza for the first time and I was very impressed. I ordered Pizza, wings, and a chicken parm dinner. Everything was very good and the service was great. I will definitely go back.

Johnny Coraizaca

Great price. Delicious pizza. Amazing people. Will come again.

Mark lindsay

Used to be my go to for delivery pizza. Not sure what happened but it has fallen off big time. Hopefully they get back on track. It will be a while before I try again

James M.

Ordered there before, and the food was good. Today, I ordered a Roast Beef Sub, and a Veal Parmigiana Sub. Both horrible. Inedible, Never again.

Derya Şahin

Delicious pizzas and large portion salads are great

LaceyBozzuto

The food was always good and we had gone during work for lunch at times. We admired the place until yesterday when we ordered 6 boneless buffalo tenders and received three that were ripped in half by hand to make six. This is unbelievable. Coming from someone who has their food certification I wouldn’t recommend such a place.

Ali Sahin

Best pizza ever! I love the crispy crust this place makes.. i have tried many pizza in the area and never had anything similar to Main street.

Stacey Foley Heaslip

Staff was incredibly rude and incompetent last night and hung up on me. They said they were out of large pizzas and I asked how many mediums would be the equivalent of the 3 large I had wanted. He said he had no idea order what you want. When I questioned how he didn’t know since he worked there, he said it was only his 5th day there. Then he hung up. When I called back and asked to speak to his boss, he told me to get my order somewhere else. Unbelievable.

Load More

Main Street Pizza Wallingford

368 Main St, Wallingford, CT 06492
(203) 265-5454