Best pizza ever! “Supreme” service and atmosphere!Parking: Right in front of the restaurant. Convenient to grab and go or stay in and eat!!Wheelchair accessibility: Great area for wheelchair mobility
I think of myself as a pretty open minded person. When debating with friends about sports, politics, current events- I always try to respect everyone else's opinions, allow myself to possibly have my mind changed, or agree to disagree sometimes. That being said- there is one debate where I will not give an inch, will not back down, will not be dissuaded or told I am wrong: Supreme has the best grinders- full stop. Every aspect of every grinder I've ever had from them (that number is probably nearing four digits, since I've been coming here since the early 90's) has been flawless. The fresh bread, the meat, the cheese, the crisp shredded lettuce- all comes together to form THE perfect grinder, every single time. I can't think of a single other restaurant where I've never thought, "Eh, not their best." A supreme grinder will hit the spot day in and day out. The grinders aren't the only place Supreme shines though- the pizza is out of this world. Living in southeastern Connecticut, I'm well aware that I'm spoiled when it comes to pizza. Within a stones throw, there are a half dozen excellent options. When I get that craving, though, Supreme is always my top choice. As good as the meals are, half the fun is going to pick it up. Tim, Nick, and the rest of the staff create a friendly, fun, and vibrant atmosphere where something as simple as picking up lunch makes you feel like you're visiting family. Oh yeah- Don't forget the rice pudding!
George Morash
They are not skimping on toppings. They are feeding the people. The taste isn't going to be your high end pizza, but you aren't leaving hungry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Steven Csutor
Great food very happy with
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Peppers Grinder, Tuna Grinder, Italian Grinder, Meatball Grinder
J W.
Small little place with limited seating, but the food and service is absolutely worth it.....Hawaiian pizza for lunch was incredible ! Thank you!!
Ryan Nickle
Great cheese steaks and awesome staff. You can really taste the fresh bread and produce.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine Pacheco
The tuna grinder is their specialty and it is so delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rice Pudding, Baked Ziti, Special Pizza, Tuna Grinder
Jamie
Always excellent food. You get your money's worth. Good portions. Highly recommend ?.
I've visiting from Florida and was pumping gas in waterford and asked the attendant where I could get a pizza to take over to my friend's I'm normally over in East Lyme or niantic hands down 1 of the best pizzas I've ever had and it seemed like a nice family restaurant ?
Food: 5
Noah Zuniga
A fantastic, delicious mom and pop or family owned pizza place. They sell by the slice or by the pie, the slices are very big if you buy by the slice. For reference 2 slices filled me up. Aside from pepperoni and sausage pizza being a favorite, the Italian grinder is a huge favorite of mine.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Special Pizza
Dan Rand
Been going to Supreme for the last 30yrs. There pizza is great! There grinders are AWESOME!! My favorite is the Tuna grinder toasted!! If you want good food, at a great price....Supreme is the place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna Grinder
Aaron Ide
New London-style pizza (and yes, that's a thing) with an unmatched level of counter service banter. There are a few tables if you want to stay and eat, but that's not the point. Pizza is darn good too, my wife keeps wondering why the pie always gets home with a slice missing, I tell her it's the delivery fee.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eli P
First time here and you can tell this is a neighborhood gem. Owner in the front knew the names of half the people walking in the door.Oh and the food did not disappoint! Family loved it all!
Best pizza ever! “Supreme” service and atmosphere!Parking: Right in front of the restaurant. Convenient to grab and go or stay in and eat!!Wheelchair accessibility: Great area for wheelchair mobility
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna Salad, Rice Pudding, Chili, Sausage and Peppers Grinder, Grilled Chicken, Baked Ziti, Capicola Grinder, Bacon Pizza, Pepperoni Grinder, Special Pizza, Crispy Chicken Salad, Tuna Grinder, Grilled Chicken Salad, Italian Grinder, Sausage Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Salad Grinder, Meatless Grinder, Meatball Grinder
Best Grinders !! Real nice people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I think of myself as a pretty open minded person. When debating with friends about sports, politics, current events- I always try to respect everyone else's opinions, allow myself to possibly have my mind changed, or agree to disagree sometimes. That being said- there is one debate where I will not give an inch, will not back down, will not be dissuaded or told I am wrong: Supreme has the best grinders- full stop. Every aspect of every grinder I've ever had from them (that number is probably nearing four digits, since I've been coming here since the early 90's) has been flawless. The fresh bread, the meat, the cheese, the crisp shredded lettuce- all comes together to form THE perfect grinder, every single time. I can't think of a single other restaurant where I've never thought, "Eh, not their best." A supreme grinder will hit the spot day in and day out. The grinders aren't the only place Supreme shines though- the pizza is out of this world. Living in southeastern Connecticut, I'm well aware that I'm spoiled when it comes to pizza. Within a stones throw, there are a half dozen excellent options. When I get that craving, though, Supreme is always my top choice. As good as the meals are, half the fun is going to pick it up. Tim, Nick, and the rest of the staff create a friendly, fun, and vibrant atmosphere where something as simple as picking up lunch makes you feel like you're visiting family. Oh yeah- Don't forget the rice pudding!
They are not skimping on toppings. They are feeding the people. The taste isn't going to be your high end pizza, but you aren't leaving hungry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great food very happy with
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Peppers Grinder, Tuna Grinder, Italian Grinder, Meatball Grinder
Small little place with limited seating, but the food and service is absolutely worth it.....Hawaiian pizza for lunch was incredible ! Thank you!!
Great cheese steaks and awesome staff. You can really taste the fresh bread and produce.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The tuna grinder is their specialty and it is so delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rice Pudding, Baked Ziti, Special Pizza, Tuna Grinder
Always excellent food. You get your money's worth. Good portions. Highly recommend ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Ziti, Tuna Grinder, Grilled Chicken Salad
They seemed to have switched to a cheaper & plastic tasting mozzarella & the dough is older & chewy not crispy ,moving
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I've visiting from Florida and was pumping gas in waterford and asked the attendant where I could get a pizza to take over to my friend's I'm normally over in East Lyme or niantic hands down 1 of the best pizzas I've ever had and it seemed like a nice family restaurant ?
Food: 5
A fantastic, delicious mom and pop or family owned pizza place. They sell by the slice or by the pie, the slices are very big if you buy by the slice. For reference 2 slices filled me up. Aside from pepperoni and sausage pizza being a favorite, the Italian grinder is a huge favorite of mine.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Special Pizza
Been going to Supreme for the last 30yrs. There pizza is great! There grinders are AWESOME!! My favorite is the Tuna grinder toasted!! If you want good food, at a great price....Supreme is the place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna Grinder
New London-style pizza (and yes, that's a thing) with an unmatched level of counter service banter. There are a few tables if you want to stay and eat, but that's not the point. Pizza is darn good too, my wife keeps wondering why the pie always gets home with a slice missing, I tell her it's the delivery fee.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time here and you can tell this is a neighborhood gem. Owner in the front knew the names of half the people walking in the door.Oh and the food did not disappoint! Family loved it all!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5