There eggplant rollatini dinner is so good. We'll worth the money. 4 slices of eggplant stuffed with ricotta, side salad and bread. I loved it
Heather Dixon-Bouteiller
I love their pizza it's the best around I think. And it is also made quickly so the wait time is minimal. I love that it is close by. I don't think it has delivery but for the price and quality of their pizza it's worth it to just go yourself.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slices
Mike C.
Good food, good people, family business. Friendly Fast. Not fancy. No delivery but worth the drive. Generations of the same family working together. Custom orders, I ordered a steak and cheese sub and added pepperoni. It was amazing.
James Fulton
This is our favorite pizza place. Take out only. You can get a nice thick crust pizza that is not burned like so many other
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Bisighini
Great family run pizzeria. I always get mine a little more well done.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ivan R Vasquez
I have driven past the Salty Tomato a million times and didn’t have them until recently; and I’m glad I did- I ordered a large meat lovers and everything was on point. The cheese pull, the crispy crust and the richness of the ingredients has made this a top rated pie on my book. I can see this pie go toe to toe with any pie in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Kevin D.
This place is very close to my house but I have not been here before. It's a takeout only place across from the beach. The prices here seem pretty reasonable compared to some others. The pizza is kind of what you would call old school I guess and very good. The crust has a really good flavor too. Lots of parking although it can be a busy area. The staff is very friendly and helpful. I think this is a hidden gem, well worth checking out.
James Demetriades
Great West haven tradition. Great carry out pizza!
Lyneisha T.
This pizza is delicious and I like that the have many different variations of toppings! Very nice owners and fast friendly good pizza
Justine Cappetta
I picked up a large half pepperoni pizza for lunch. It was really good! I like the pizza sauce. Will definitely order again.
My favorite pizza place in west haven! The bacon pie never misses! Also, the buffalo sicilian is the best I ever had!!
Abby Straub
Always great service and great food. Our go-to pizza place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexander P.
Great neighborhood pizzeria. Food far above normal pizzerias. Fast and efficient service. Ambiance is naught/ strictly take out. Forget other pizzas spots in the area and go here. Well with it. This place is basically a staple in west haven.
Mario Fusaro
This was my first visit to Salty Tomato. Honestly, neither of the two pizzas (mozzarella & mozzarella with ricotta) had any flavor. I was unable to taste the sauce, the mozzarella and the ricotta were completely bland. The crust was weak and also tasteless. Actually, the pizzas had as much flavor as the boxes I took them home in. So I tried this place and I won't return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Betty B.
Got 2 pounds of dough and they charged me $7.50 which is ridiculous! Lately it's hit or miss on the pizza too, I guess it depends on who's making it, Dom seems a little tipsy so maybe that explains it. Go to Jimmies in Milford instead...always consistent there never wonder before ordering how it's going to be.
There eggplant rollatini dinner is so good. We'll worth the money. 4 slices of eggplant stuffed with ricotta, side salad and bread. I loved it
I love their pizza it's the best around I think. And it is also made quickly so the wait time is minimal. I love that it is close by. I don't think it has delivery but for the price and quality of their pizza it's worth it to just go yourself.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slices
Good food, good people, family business. Friendly Fast. Not fancy. No delivery but worth the drive. Generations of the same family working together. Custom orders, I ordered a steak and cheese sub and added pepperoni. It was amazing.
This is our favorite pizza place. Take out only. You can get a nice thick crust pizza that is not burned like so many other
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great family run pizzeria. I always get mine a little more well done.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have driven past the Salty Tomato a million times and didn’t have them until recently; and I’m glad I did- I ordered a large meat lovers and everything was on point. The cheese pull, the crispy crust and the richness of the ingredients has made this a top rated pie on my book. I can see this pie go toe to toe with any pie in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place is very close to my house but I have not been here before. It's a takeout only place across from the beach. The prices here seem pretty reasonable compared to some others. The pizza is kind of what you would call old school I guess and very good. The crust has a really good flavor too. Lots of parking although it can be a busy area. The staff is very friendly and helpful. I think this is a hidden gem, well worth checking out.
Great West haven tradition. Great carry out pizza!
This pizza is delicious and I like that the have many different variations of toppings! Very nice owners and fast friendly good pizza
I picked up a large half pepperoni pizza for lunch. It was really good! I like the pizza sauce. Will definitely order again.
Restaurantji Recommends
My favorite pizza place in west haven! The bacon pie never misses! Also, the buffalo sicilian is the best I ever had!!
Always great service and great food. Our go-to pizza place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great neighborhood pizzeria. Food far above normal pizzerias. Fast and efficient service. Ambiance is naught/ strictly take out. Forget other pizzas spots in the area and go here. Well with it. This place is basically a staple in west haven.
This was my first visit to Salty Tomato. Honestly, neither of the two pizzas (mozzarella & mozzarella with ricotta) had any flavor. I was unable to taste the sauce, the mozzarella and the ricotta were completely bland. The crust was weak and also tasteless. Actually, the pizzas had as much flavor as the boxes I took them home in. So I tried this place and I won't return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Got 2 pounds of dough and they charged me $7.50 which is ridiculous! Lately it's hit or miss on the pizza too, I guess it depends on who's making it, Dom seems a little tipsy so maybe that explains it. Go to Jimmies in Milford instead...always consistent there never wonder before ordering how it's going to be.