I ordered delivery, and haven't had the full dining in experience yet, so this review is strictly around the pizza.Although New Haven Apizza will always be my number one, I'm a big fan of Detroit style pizza. They're completely different beasts so I won't even try to compare them.Detroit style, for those who haven't had it, is cooked in a type of sheet pan, with crispy cheese that burns (in a good way) along the edges of the crust where it meets the pan. The sauce is typically in bands across the top of the cheese in a traditional Detroit pie.For my first time, I tried a classic Detroit style pie with pepperoni. The little pepperonis that curl into cups are a critical component of this style of pizza, and Emmy's passed the test there!The pizza was very good, and definitely Detroit style. The crust although thick (which is normal for this style) was nice and light and similar to focaccia as it should be.The sauce was excellent, no complaints there!I do have two minor quibbles that IMO are keeping this pizza from Detroit greatness:There is not enough of the crispy cheese on the outer crust. The edges should be darker with a lot more cheese in the equation. This is easily remedied, so I'm begging you to nail the best part of Detroit pizza!The bottom of the crust is also a bit blonde for this style of pizza. I'm not sure if it's the pans used, the oven temperature, or the cook time, but again IMO, authentic Detroit style should have more color on the bottom.For those of you familiar with Lions, Tigers, and Squares in NYC, I would put Emmy's a bit below them due to the two differences highlighted above.Anyways, it's great to have Detroit style pizza in the area! The pies IMO fall just short of greatness, but could easily get there with a few tweaks.I'm looking forward to checking it out in person when time permits.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pizza
Anonymous P.
Overrated and underwhelmed. No room to wait for a table so you end up on top of diners and waitstaff. Pizza came out undercooked, sent it back, waited 20 mins, came out undercooked again, sent it back again and then never reappeared but was charged for it. Our Italian salad came out missing salami and dressing. Our drinks kept us satiated. What a mess!
Iam Arias
Good food but bad attention, a big boy took care of me he doesn't have a good way to attend and that makes them lose
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Dani Maloney
The vodka pizza and brussel sprout salad are to die for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Dan K.
I love this pizza! Detroit style baby! I ordered it two night in a row when I first tried it because it was so good. It's a thicker fried crust kind of like Greek style, but different. Like of like Pizza Hut's crust (if they used super quality ingredients and made it from scratch) but obviously way better. It's hard to describe. Maybe the simplest is that it's a "fried" pan pizza crust. The toppings are amazing. The sauce is on top and it's super flavorful. I've never been to the Brooklyn locations but I'm not surprised it's too popular.
Brittni Burke
I don’t usually leave reviews, but this pizza is SO GOOD - it deserves a five star review. Their colony pizza is my fave. My husband usually builds his own. The crust is perfection and flavor of everything is top notch. Highly suggest this pizza spot. We’re huge fans!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pizza
Nickolas Juliano
Excellent service. Great pizzas, Detroit style. I preferred the MVP, with the Calabrian chilis. Parking can be tight, even in the back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brit B.
I don't usually leave reviews, but this pizza is SO GOOD - it deserves a five star review. Their colony pizza is my fave. My husband usually builds his own. The crust is perfection and flavor of everything is top notch. Highly suggest this pizza spot. We're huge fans!
Tim Ross
Did not check once if I needed anything. Needed silverware but had to eat with fingers. Would have liked a real napkin but had to keep taking cocktail napkins since I was sitting at the bar. Beer from tap was warm which I mentioned and was told that the 2 inch of head in the beer was normal. At the end of the lunch was asked if I was eating. Sandwich was decent however. Very disappointed
We had a big group of 10 people and we came here after a family outing. The burgers were unbelievably good! Servers were attentive! Too a bit longer to come out with the food but that’s because we were probably a big group. Definitely will be back for that
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Emily Burger
Victoria B
Delicious deep dish vodka pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Pizza 8x10
Rainelys Rodriguez
Dear Emmy Squared Westport Team,I hope this message finds you well. My name is Rainelys, and I had the pleasure of dining at your restaurant today. I wanted to express my sincere appreciation for the outstanding lunch experience provided by your team.Emmy Squared has consistently been my favorite pizzeria, and today's visit reaffirmed its status as my number one choice for both myself and my family. The food was truly exceptional, earning a solid 10/10 rating. The quality and flavors exceeded our expectations, and I am grateful for the culinary delight your establishment consistently offers.I would like to extend my gratitude for the excellent service we received. Your team's commitment to providing a memorable dining experience did not go unnoticed. It is evident that you take great pride in delivering top-notch service to your customers.I am already looking forward to bringing my family for dinner on our next visit. Your restaurant has earned my highest recommendation, and I will continue to spread the word about the exceptional dining experience Emmy Squared Westport provides.Thank you once again for your dedication to excellence. Wishing you continued success and looking forward to our next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin Finegood
Best pizza I have had in a long time. New favorite
Best pizza in Westport.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pizza
I ordered delivery, and haven't had the full dining in experience yet, so this review is strictly around the pizza.Although New Haven Apizza will always be my number one, I'm a big fan of Detroit style pizza. They're completely different beasts so I won't even try to compare them.Detroit style, for those who haven't had it, is cooked in a type of sheet pan, with crispy cheese that burns (in a good way) along the edges of the crust where it meets the pan. The sauce is typically in bands across the top of the cheese in a traditional Detroit pie.For my first time, I tried a classic Detroit style pie with pepperoni. The little pepperonis that curl into cups are a critical component of this style of pizza, and Emmy's passed the test there!The pizza was very good, and definitely Detroit style. The crust although thick (which is normal for this style) was nice and light and similar to focaccia as it should be.The sauce was excellent, no complaints there!I do have two minor quibbles that IMO are keeping this pizza from Detroit greatness:There is not enough of the crispy cheese on the outer crust. The edges should be darker with a lot more cheese in the equation. This is easily remedied, so I'm begging you to nail the best part of Detroit pizza!The bottom of the crust is also a bit blonde for this style of pizza. I'm not sure if it's the pans used, the oven temperature, or the cook time, but again IMO, authentic Detroit style should have more color on the bottom.For those of you familiar with Lions, Tigers, and Squares in NYC, I would put Emmy's a bit below them due to the two differences highlighted above.Anyways, it's great to have Detroit style pizza in the area! The pies IMO fall just short of greatness, but could easily get there with a few tweaks.I'm looking forward to checking it out in person when time permits.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pizza
Overrated and underwhelmed. No room to wait for a table so you end up on top of diners and waitstaff. Pizza came out undercooked, sent it back, waited 20 mins, came out undercooked again, sent it back again and then never reappeared but was charged for it. Our Italian salad came out missing salami and dressing. Our drinks kept us satiated. What a mess!
Good food but bad attention, a big boy took care of me he doesn't have a good way to attend and that makes them lose
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
The vodka pizza and brussel sprout salad are to die for!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
I love this pizza! Detroit style baby! I ordered it two night in a row when I first tried it because it was so good. It's a thicker fried crust kind of like Greek style, but different. Like of like Pizza Hut's crust (if they used super quality ingredients and made it from scratch) but obviously way better. It's hard to describe. Maybe the simplest is that it's a "fried" pan pizza crust. The toppings are amazing. The sauce is on top and it's super flavorful. I've never been to the Brooklyn locations but I'm not surprised it's too popular.
I don’t usually leave reviews, but this pizza is SO GOOD - it deserves a five star review. Their colony pizza is my fave. My husband usually builds his own. The crust is perfection and flavor of everything is top notch. Highly suggest this pizza spot. We’re huge fans!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pizza
Excellent service. Great pizzas, Detroit style. I preferred the MVP, with the Calabrian chilis. Parking can be tight, even in the back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don't usually leave reviews, but this pizza is SO GOOD - it deserves a five star review. Their colony pizza is my fave. My husband usually builds his own. The crust is perfection and flavor of everything is top notch. Highly suggest this pizza spot. We're huge fans!
Did not check once if I needed anything. Needed silverware but had to eat with fingers. Would have liked a real napkin but had to keep taking cocktail napkins since I was sitting at the bar. Beer from tap was warm which I mentioned and was told that the 2 inch of head in the beer was normal. At the end of the lunch was asked if I was eating. Sandwich was decent however. Very disappointed
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We had a big group of 10 people and we came here after a family outing. The burgers were unbelievably good! Servers were attentive! Too a bit longer to come out with the food but that’s because we were probably a big group. Definitely will be back for that
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Emily Burger
Delicious deep dish vodka pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Pizza 8x10
Dear Emmy Squared Westport Team,I hope this message finds you well. My name is Rainelys, and I had the pleasure of dining at your restaurant today. I wanted to express my sincere appreciation for the outstanding lunch experience provided by your team.Emmy Squared has consistently been my favorite pizzeria, and today's visit reaffirmed its status as my number one choice for both myself and my family. The food was truly exceptional, earning a solid 10/10 rating. The quality and flavors exceeded our expectations, and I am grateful for the culinary delight your establishment consistently offers.I would like to extend my gratitude for the excellent service we received. Your team's commitment to providing a memorable dining experience did not go unnoticed. It is evident that you take great pride in delivering top-notch service to your customers.I am already looking forward to bringing my family for dinner on our next visit. Your restaurant has earned my highest recommendation, and I will continue to spread the word about the exceptional dining experience Emmy Squared Westport provides.Thank you once again for your dedication to excellence. Wishing you continued success and looking forward to our next visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza I have had in a long time. New favorite
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pizza