Prospero’s pizza

801 Churchmans Rd, New Castle
(302) 322-9085

Recent Reviews

Stefan Durek

Best pizza joint in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Create Pizza

Brenda Malavet

The pizza was great, hot and crunchy, like I like it. The service was great. Thank

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Prospero Pizza

kareem grant

I love the pizza and the one of few places that have beef pepperoni. I love the service and they are all friendly.

shauntae collins

Staff Is friendly, food is good and ALWAYS HOT!

Thaya I.

Customer Service over the phone was unprofessional and rude. The first time we called and ordered (20) wings and a medium cheese pizza, we were being charged 27.99 for 20 piece wings and 11.99 for a medium pizza. We were still ironing out what we definitely wanted and we opted to call back. Upon calling again we were then being charged $30 for wings and I expressed that, that isn't what she proposed the first time we phoned and she just hung up. Very rude and unprofessional.

William R.

First time ordering. The pizza and wings were delivered hot and tasty. This is the pizza Ive been looking for the last 3 years. Spinach rolls was nice warm and fresh tasting. I will be trying other menu items based on our meal tonite. Thank You.

Courtney Red

Food is absolutely amazing! We've been in new castle for 6 months and this has been my goto place everytime my husband and I want to order in and they never disappoint!

Nina Twyman

Overall my food was good. My only issue. I ordered online and tried to follow my order but it kept saying getting order together. I went and it was done for some time. My onion rings luke warm. They need to update the website.

Angela Ward

Ordered stuffed shells delivery they are so ? good

Janay Johnson

Terrible service. Every time I order, my order is incorrect and I got an expired soda today.

Daniel Smith

The Pizza is decent here, nothing flashy, friendly staff and they charge a fair price.I notice that the amount of pizza toppings change based on who's making them. The older guy balances his pizzas better and the younger dude is probably loading pizzas up too much but they're always good. Cheers to the both of ya.

Glen L.

Ive only had the pizza's from here but they are very good. The place in clean and the staff is very friendly. I eat here often and have always been greeted politely. This is my go to place for pizza's.

Nicholas Biondy

Tried this place cause they had good ratings. It was the WORST food I have had in a long time. The pizza was tasteless. The boneless wings were gross, tasted like cheap veiny chicken. The cannolis taste like they were old and taste was rancid. Sorry but for the price it should be good

Ed Hunt

You do not put hot chicken in a Caesar salad . It must be cooled to a safe temperature. Put together like that make salad unsafe. Puts it in the danger zone for serving (40° - 140° )

Jeremy Baranyai

Pizza is phenomenal, along with the wraps, fries, and kids tenders. Food is always hot when it arrives, and all of the wraps, sandwiches, kids meals, etc come with fries.

Load More