McGlynns Pub - Pike Creek

8 Polly Drummond Shopping Center, Newark
(302) 738-7814

Recent Reviews

Jason Peters

We love this McGlyns have been going there for 25 plus years. We always love to ordered the crab dip. However tonight it tasted like someone poured an entire salt shaker into the dip I hope by accident. The saltiness was beyond overwhelming. I hope it was just a fluke ? because I don’t want to believe someone would serve something that tasted like this on purpose. Literally had the feeling that I swallowed an entire salt shaker after two bites.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 3

Jim Lenhard

$2 per tiny chicken wing. Unreasonably priced!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Kelly Story

My boyfriend and I stopped here after a day of travel from out of state and we were very hungry. We each ordered a burger and side salad, the salad to come beforehand. They had complimentary popcorn, which was nice but machine needed a refill when I went over to get some. The server, even though she checked in with us, disappeared for long periods of time. I asked a question about a drink on the menu and she didnt know the answer and went to go ask but was gone 20 minutes. She came back with our water and pop refills I asked again and she was like "oh I forgot let me go ask" and she returned much quicker after that but I didn't want it at that point. It took an unusually long time for the salads to arrive, like I wouldn't have ordered it if it was going to take that long because the burgers arrived shortly after. I had ordered my burger medium well and it came out well and had a slightly burnt taste. The burger was supposed to come with fries but mine didn't have them. Before I could say anything the server had already walked away and continued to do so even though I called to them. Our regular server (different from who brought out the food) was apologetic for the misunderstanding..I realized she thought I was getting the salad as my side not an additional item. She offered to get some but I politely declined and my boyfriend shared his fries with me. Fries were cold. No ketchup on table. My boyfriend wanted mayo but server disappeared again. When she finally came back she said she'd go get it but when she returned she didn't have it and we asked for the check. Very disappointing. We switched over to the bar and that service was a lot better!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 2

Daisy

Key lime pie crush is a must!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Roger Chojnacki

Had a less than positive experience with the prime rib it didnt meet expectations , Janna did an amazing job on recovering and the young gentleman that served me had top customer service!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A C

Best service by bartenders and waiters/waitress. WORLDS GUINNESS RECORD FOR SLOWEST KITCHEN. I'm so tired of this. Months and months of slow kitchen and then food cold when you finally get it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

ricardo martir

Best place to watch a game with friends and eat some delicious wings at a reasonable price. Will never visit Hooterz again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

dakota neumann

Been coming here since I was little and I always enjoy it. It’s all good and they’ve got Wednesday wing night.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Popcorn

robin kondzielawa

The bar tenders were personable and efficient. Best screw driver and fries! Lots of friendly folks.

Mary O'Connor

Their hot roast beef sandwich was always my favorite, but since COVID it seemed to not be as tender. Happy to say I had it last night and it was excellent!!! Look forward to coming back!

karimdunn4

Last night was my first and last time going here. I was racially profiled by the bartender as I was getting a drink with my brother (who is a consistent customer there). In order to get in security has to check your ID. My ID was checked and I was cleared to get in. Immediately I went to the bar and he asked for my brothers and I ID. (Note: My brother has said that has never happened before twice.) The Male bartender looks at the ID and proceeds to call me “sketchy.” He then begins to ask me my birthday; I tell him. He tells me I’m wrong and asks me again; I tell him. Come to realize he wasn’t even looking at the right ID, he was looking at my BROTHERS ID and not mine. My brother and I look nothing alike he is of lighter skin tone while I am a darker male. My ID was under my brothers ID which was in the bartenders hand. (Note: Other bartenders was telling him I’m good including the Guards who let me in.) When he realized that he messed up and assumed I was being sketchy, that I indeed said the correct birthday, and he was looking at the wrong ID. He disregarded me, didn’t even apologize and was like “Oh Okay.” No apology or anything. My brother is well known there by EVERYONE including security. We immediately left and many people stopped us asking what was wrong because it wasn’t normal for my brother to leave. It was the first time it happened and a fun night was ruined. As we left many people who knew my brother including security asked why we were leaving so soon and “what was wrong” we told them we will say it next time. My brother goes there all the time and he said that has never happened before. I am a 24 year old black male and I was highly disappointed. The bartender checked no one else’s ID, at all. Until it was my turn to get a drink. I am a teacher who works with all races of children and it was very disappointing to be profiled and called “Sketchy.”

Brian

I went there on St. Patrick's Day. It was very busy and festive. I was very surprised at how efficient the restaurant was being managed on this very busy holiday. I order a reuben and a guiness. Both were excellent. The server was quite attentive and as I could see she had at least 6-8 tables, impressive! I highly recommend this restaurant/pub!

Nick Nichols

Walked in at 7:50pm and waited 20 mins to get waited on, no one came over to get our drink order. The restaurant wasn’t busy at all, 3 guys were chilling by the bar talking not much else was going on.

Nicholas Schmidt

Walked in at 7:50pm and waited 20 mins to get waited on, no one came over to get our drink order. The restaurant wasn’t busy at all, 3 guys were chilling by the bar talking not much else was going on.

Nazarene Watchmen

Ordered fish and chips and a hamburger and for $40.00 I expected much better however the fries tasted old and greasy and the fish was cold and the hamburger was ordered medium and it was raw.

Load More