ISLANDS CHOICE

1005 W Peel St, Avon Park
(863) 453-0535

Recent Reviews

Tim Machado

Got to try the oxtail plate awesome food here good ol down home cooking and lovely staff as well warm and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Curry Chicken and Ox Tail

Brianna Bailey

I drove all the way from Arcadia on a Monday.. I arrived at this location 10 minutes til 5. Online it states that they are open until 8pm. So imagine my surprise after driving an hour away with mouth watering OxTails on my mind just to arrive and the establishment is closed! Please update your hours of operations. I'm completely inconvenienced by this trip. Any reason why y'all closed 3 hours early today?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Claude Duhaney

Asum food great personality

Ben

Great food and Great music. %100 recommend stoping by.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Curry Chicken and Ox Tail, Curry Goat

Mary

Great food, delightfully seasoned. Great staff & screened in eating!

gilberto castro

Very good food.I order the oxtail with rice a plantains it was delicious also good portions.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Jerk Pork and Rice and Peas

Steph Elijah

I was feeling for some good Caribbean soup, search and found Islands Choice in Avon Park. Order a Large Chicken soup, paid $7.50.. At first glance, the color seems pale white, a little slimy like it came from a Soup can, with some added Boil chicken wings with a few pieces of roll up dumplings. Wow, I am surprised of the fairly good reviews. Highlands county being such a small-town vs. larger counties. I know your restaurant choices are limited and you have to settle for less. I like to support small business and I don't like leaving negative reviews, but this was an embarrassment to Jamaican food (soup). Where are the carrots, the yam, potatoes, green banana, corn, pumpkins, peas, chocho, vegetable, flesh thyme, the rich flavor, etc. all the good ingredients and flavor you found in a food authentic Jamaican soup dish.?! I didn't buy any other dish, so can't attest to the other dishes. I only hope the owner/chef will take the time out to review these feedbacks and make some positive proactive changes. Islands Choice, You Can Do Better!Parking: limited amount of parking, with the restaurant vehicle taken up the spaces

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Bill Oldham

Good food, and the servings are huge! The oxtail was 10/10.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Curry Chicken and Ox Tail, Curried Goat, Curry Goat

Michelle Tyrney

Price is great for the amount of food you

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mrs Ann

There oxtail was sooooo good my daughter and I kept fighting over it. Ahaha.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DeShawn Gilles

Known for its avant-garde Nordic cuisine, utilizing local and seasonal ingredients. Diners appreciate the unique flavors and artistic presentations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mr P

Normally I would be asked if I want any gravy on my rice, but being a usual I don’t ask for gravy on my rice. I only asked for the sides and I was served jerk chicken with curry gravy on my rice underneath my jerk chicken and it tasted nasty due to it having curry with it. I had this same issue 3 years ago and it seems nothing has changed it felt like it was a call in order and someone did not come pick up their curry chicken order, I had to throw away the food and go to Maryland fry chicken for food

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Layla Stryker (Lucy)

Cute little place, seems to be a local owned and run business. The beef patties are exactly what i needed them to be, not overly spicy (looking at you goldenkrust with a giant scotch bonnet left in whole) and not overly salty. We went around noon and it was about a 15 minute wait to get 2 patties, so don't expect to be in and out quickly during busy times. Cute seating area and don't squish the bread.Coming back for the goat, I love kijan nou fe sos viand cabrit and other goat dishes so curry goat with rice and peas has me in a lock. Can't wait to try this place again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Sondra L.

Me and my auntie wanted to visit island Choice because it's were my mom had taken me when I was 11 before her passing, we came back years later to the same place and it was still the greatest thing a had ever tasted. There ox tails were seasoned right there rice was steamed and there cabbage fresh I've never been so alive to come back here There drinks were cold and fresh as well For new people that visit Florida I Recommend coming here for a good Jamaican food experience. 10/100

Quinnette Jones

As a first time customer, customer service was bad.. Owner did not want to change out my food, due to the fact I was served spoiled cabbage..

Load More