A great find. The super positive reviews I read were spot on: really excellent pizza! We got cheese with mushroom and sausage. I pride myself on being a good judge of italian sausage, and theirs is top quality and flavor, sliced thin, so the pizza was COVERED. Very fresh tasting sauce too. Very nice staff, including chefs who came out to say hi and ask how we liked our dinner: we simply said "great pizza!"
Matt R.
Great tasting pizza and quick service. You won't regret it. The crust was perfect! You'll likely come back for more.
Emily D.
We ordered the pepperoni and margarita pizzas. Both were delicious. We also enjoyed the salad with lemon dressing. Very refreshing! The service was excellent, and we appreciated the friendly atmosphere.
B L.
I pass this restaurant daily, to and from work. I have wanted to try it for a while. So glad we finally did. The food is so good and the prices are very reasonable which makes it 5 stars all the way around. I had a calzone and I had plenty over. My husband had the Italian and it was also generous in portion. Both were yummy! Also highly recommend the garlic knots. So good. We are going to order the pizza tonight and I am sure that will be outstanding as well. Highly recommend. Please don't change the quality or the prices :-)
Susan Tillander
Cute place with nice, chill staff. Unimpressed with the pizza. The mushrooms on my pizza made the whole this soggy. When I mentioned this, the waiter said the cook saw this. So they both knew the pizza was soggy and they still served it leaving me in a position to have to complain instead of remaking the pizza. That's pretty lame.Pizza would have been okay without the mushrooms but nothing special.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
lori b.
Pepperoni slice had discs of delicious spicy pepperoni covering every spot! With that said, it was a buck more than a cheese slice. I guess it's a fair up charge since the slice was covered inch to inch with really good pepperoni. Window for ordering/paying/recpt of food is quite small and awkward to get out of someone's way. Tastes like NY/NJ slices
Kathy Olwine
Went in for a slice of pizza and knots! It was excellent ? I'll definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Mad Brain
REALLY GREAT True NY style Pizza Great Service. On time. Great. location too from where I start off from. They have other Varieties of pizza you used to see in NY that hardly anyone makes around here. Prices are lower too than other pizza places in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
E P
Just ordered takeout at Little Sicily in Fort Myers. I got a Sicilian Pie (ordered it crispy) this time and wow was it delicious! Also got to try one of the rice balls- amazing! Tasted like a true Sicilian arancini!Last time I was here with my friend, we got the cheese pizza (ordered crispy) and a Sicilian lemon Salad. So good! The pizza was up there with some of the best I've had in NYC. We will definitely go back again! Try it- you will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emilia P.
Just ordered takeout at Little Sicily in Fort Myers. I got a Sicilian Pie (ordered it crispy) this time and wow was it delicious! Also got to try one of the rice balls- amazing! Tasted like a true Sicilian arancini!! Last time I was here with my friend, we got the cheese pizza (ordered crispy) and a Sicilian lemon Salad. So good! The pizza was up there with some of the best I've had in NYC. We will definitely go back again! Try it- you will not be disappointed!
Excellent Italian food. I've had the pizza and top 3 in Fort for sure. Had lasagna tonight and this place is bangin Italian. You need to try it.
Nikolaus G.
Easily one of the best pizza places I have ever been to. Visiting Florida from Virginia, and it was by far the best pizza I have had in Florida.
Diana Busso
Best New York style pizza in the area! Great salads also. Fresh ingredients. Clean well taken care of resturant. Awesome servers. Friendly staff. Great prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Albert Kerr
I haven't had a rice ball this good since I left Jersey. The pie was very good let me apologize first it was for my step daughter she's from San Francisco they don't do Italian out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Jackson
The best pizza I have had in Florida. Just like NY Pizza . Great flavor.
A great find. The super positive reviews I read were spot on: really excellent pizza! We got cheese with mushroom and sausage. I pride myself on being a good judge of italian sausage, and theirs is top quality and flavor, sliced thin, so the pizza was COVERED. Very fresh tasting sauce too. Very nice staff, including chefs who came out to say hi and ask how we liked our dinner: we simply said "great pizza!"
Great tasting pizza and quick service. You won't regret it. The crust was perfect! You'll likely come back for more.
We ordered the pepperoni and margarita pizzas. Both were delicious. We also enjoyed the salad with lemon dressing. Very refreshing! The service was excellent, and we appreciated the friendly atmosphere.
I pass this restaurant daily, to and from work. I have wanted to try it for a while. So glad we finally did. The food is so good and the prices are very reasonable which makes it 5 stars all the way around. I had a calzone and I had plenty over. My husband had the Italian and it was also generous in portion. Both were yummy! Also highly recommend the garlic knots. So good. We are going to order the pizza tonight and I am sure that will be outstanding as well. Highly recommend. Please don't change the quality or the prices :-)
Cute place with nice, chill staff. Unimpressed with the pizza. The mushrooms on my pizza made the whole this soggy. When I mentioned this, the waiter said the cook saw this. So they both knew the pizza was soggy and they still served it leaving me in a position to have to complain instead of remaking the pizza. That's pretty lame.Pizza would have been okay without the mushrooms but nothing special.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Pepperoni slice had discs of delicious spicy pepperoni covering every spot! With that said, it was a buck more than a cheese slice. I guess it's a fair up charge since the slice was covered inch to inch with really good pepperoni. Window for ordering/paying/recpt of food is quite small and awkward to get out of someone's way. Tastes like NY/NJ slices
Went in for a slice of pizza and knots! It was excellent ? I'll definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
REALLY GREAT True NY style Pizza Great Service. On time. Great. location too from where I start off from. They have other Varieties of pizza you used to see in NY that hardly anyone makes around here. Prices are lower too than other pizza places in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just ordered takeout at Little Sicily in Fort Myers. I got a Sicilian Pie (ordered it crispy) this time and wow was it delicious! Also got to try one of the rice balls- amazing! Tasted like a true Sicilian arancini!Last time I was here with my friend, we got the cheese pizza (ordered crispy) and a Sicilian lemon Salad. So good! The pizza was up there with some of the best I've had in NYC. We will definitely go back again! Try it- you will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just ordered takeout at Little Sicily in Fort Myers. I got a Sicilian Pie (ordered it crispy) this time and wow was it delicious! Also got to try one of the rice balls- amazing! Tasted like a true Sicilian arancini!! Last time I was here with my friend, we got the cheese pizza (ordered crispy) and a Sicilian lemon Salad. So good! The pizza was up there with some of the best I've had in NYC. We will definitely go back again! Try it- you will not be disappointed!
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent Italian food. I've had the pizza and top 3 in Fort for sure. Had lasagna tonight and this place is bangin Italian. You need to try it.
Easily one of the best pizza places I have ever been to. Visiting Florida from Virginia, and it was by far the best pizza I have had in Florida.
Best New York style pizza in the area! Great salads also. Fresh ingredients. Clean well taken care of resturant. Awesome servers. Friendly staff. Great prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
I haven't had a rice ball this good since I left Jersey. The pie was very good let me apologize first it was for my step daughter she's from San Francisco they don't do Italian out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza I have had in Florida. Just like NY Pizza . Great flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza