Nick & Stella Pizza Perfecto

15271 McGregor Blvd #14, Fort Myers
(239) 466-9493

Recent Reviews

Stacie Kite

Great afternoon!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Laura Baker

In town on business so it thought I would try the pizza. I placed an order for pickup. Walked into the bar and the bartender pointed me to acpuple that was sitting at a table. When is walked over, he said is that who you were looking for? I was looking for my take out order. Finally got my pizza and was unimpressed. The pizza looked ok until I picked up a piece and found the puddle of grease. Will not be back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Elaine Morton

Placed an online order and took an additional 40 min from pick up time.

Food: 5

Service: 1

Holly Keller

Horrible!!!!!On vacation and was recommended by a local to try this place out. After a very long day ordered food to go. Arrived 5 mins before food was suppose to be done. The lady at the counter let me know it would be a few more minutes that they were behind. I said no problem and step to the side to wait. The customer in front of me was going through her boxes of to go food and some items were missing. The lady behind the counter rolled her eyes and flung open the barn door behind her to get the missing stuff. I took at seat at the counter about 10 mins in. Fast forward about 30 mins later and half my order came out. Part was wrong but at this point I didn't care. The flat bread had toppings on it it wasn't supposed to and it looked like it was just flung into the box. The guy who came in behind me had been waiting a while too, as he opened his boxes his food looked not very appealing. The lady went through her tickets again and then took some of the food out of the bag I already had because she said it belong to the guy behind me. Now we are missing two items. We have now arrived at 48 mins of waiting. I asked for a refund at this point. The lady said she can't give me my money back because I ordered online and I will have to figure that out through the "online order place". I asked for a manager or an owner twice. She just kept running behind the barn door. The waitress standing there at this point said she can't give you cash back, I don't want cash back just refund my card. I asked again who was in charge and they couldn't answer me. They took my phone number down and "someone will call you." Out of towners BEWARE.

Danielle Classetti

Empty bar. Maybe 4 people total. Same bartender for years. Had a bad experience in the past. Gave it another try, nothing has changed. Same grumpy bartender, pissed off at life, one speed. Will never return. If you want service with a smile this is definitely not the place. Didn’t waste our time ordering food, had one drink and bolted!

Service: 1

Kristi K.

'Amantha' was the WORST server We have ever had . PERIOD. We were never asked ( and We did ) would We like another drink .. Never checked on Us.. Thankfully, Another server came to bring Our order, ALSO brought Us one 1/2 of Our order that this amantha had written down. When We asked for Our bill, and a box..,She had the nerve to say.. GO GET YOUR OWN BOX, Which We did. She screamed at Us, Telling Us, We were not the only people that She had to serve. WOW! Horrible and Poor People skills. We will never come to Your Restaurant, As long as She still works there. What a shame. We asked for Our printed receipt , And She stormed off .. Never received it. BEST PIZZA IN TOWN , On a Positive Note

Valerie Nation

A friend invited me for their Tuesday taco deal and I thought sure since I’d never been there. Taco shells were very stale and they charge .60 cents for each extra topping(sour cream, salsa). So we complained and the waitress said we could order something different so we ordered the loaded nachos. Not a fan either and don’t recommend. We ate outside so I don’t know what the inside of the restaurant is like. My friend said the pizza was good but I’m not interested.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Jeffrey Linton

Pizza wasn’t hot and prepared as I asked. My wife’s burger was overcooked as well. Other than that the service was good and the beer was cold. Reasonably priced and friendly staff as well. We would give it another try.

Randy Schultz

The supreme nachos added chicken OMG I can't believe I ate it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jonathan Wilder

I enjoyed our lunch here today. Enjoyed the patio with my puppy. Everyone was welcoming and they even brought a water bowl out. Food was great and our server was very welcoming. Would defintely recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sonia L.

I recently had Nick and Stella's cater my son's 40th Surprise Birthday Party. Joanne one of the family members was a gem to help me plan the menu and it was ready at the requested pick up time. Even though I asked there to be enough food to serve 20 people there were a lot of left overs that we were able to enjoy for several days later! And it was great!!! I highly recommend Nick and Stella's for your next casual catering event. Sonia Lomano

Paul Philabaum

Perfect spot for a drink or some food...Great pizza and sandwichesCatch a game or two on the several T.V'

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sheila DeChantal

Nice menu selection, great prices. We ordered cheesecurds and the basket was overflowing. BIG portions.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Annette Vivona

Great food, Awesome atmosphere, best staff!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cakes, Greek Salad, Fries, Chicken Wings, House Special Calzone

Twy Grant

The golden rush wings are so

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Load More