Italian Gator Pizza

1728A W University Ave, Gainesville
(352) 367-4600

Recent Reviews

Bob Janzen

was spending the night in Gainsville for the Gatornationals and wanted a late night pizza. They have a 20 inch cheese pie that is huge and at avery affordable price.The crew there was nice to interact with and courteous. I recommend if you have a few mouths to feed.Pizza is not bad.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, 20 Giant Cheese Pizza

Logan B

This small little takeout spot has become one of my favorites in midtown and Gainesville as a whole. The slices are absolutely delicious and cater to both sober and non-sober people. Service is quick, professional and quality. If you're a UF student or coming to watch a Gators athletics game, this spot is a must-try when it's open. Love it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Pizza

Fearlessflyer3

Favorite pizza in town! Closest to NY pizza we have found so far.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Arianna R.

Pizza was great and sauce was very tasty! Service was very attentive and fast. If you're on the go I would say it's a great option. They do not offer seating but it definitely gives that "NY corner pizza place" to the establishment. Will definitely be back for more :)

Eitan Holder

Unexpectedly great pizza, has a subtle crunch!

Food: 5

SM239

Fast good pizza. Crust is thin and crunchy. Atmosphere is a bit weird later in the night, because of all the drunk college students. Though I guess that should be expected of the area.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Julian Torres

Easily the best pizza in Gainesville. Try the pepperoni! My only complaint is that they aren't open enough to give them more of my money. The only drawback is the lack of parking, so I find myself DoorDashing my pizza instead of going to pick it up. Of course thats not a probelm when I am hitting the bars...and nothing hits better late at night than one of their slices!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 4

Erich C.

It is what it is! Rolling home on a cool Gainesville winter night, I was told at the restaurant where I work that this place was open til 2:00am!! I was going to see how crowded it was, and make my decision on the za accordingly. NO WAITING!!! I casually rolled up to the window and asked for two slices, he asked pepperoni or cheese, and I said BOTH! I paid and tipped with my card right at the window, he put both Italian dreams in a small box for me, and I happily pedaled away! Unfortunately, I do not have pictures of the slices, as I munched them upon entering my warm apartment! Gotta go back!

Sofia B.

Never tried it sober but when drunk it is my go to. 10/10 drunk pizza and midnight "snack".

John Blackburn

Been coming here for 22 years as of this writing. Best pizza in town!

Food: 5

tha freighttrain

Pizza was great! Reminds me of Papa Gino's up north.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

bob rojapistole

Years of good service I should be nicer. I know for a fact your company is taking the time to help people that needed a good job and help them in the right direction. I'm sad no cash accepted.

Edward D.

Their website says they're open they aren't. I walked all the way here for absolutely nothing.

Galib K.

It's pizza and it's gonna be available when you need it most. This is a game day/tailgate MUSTafter 7-8 drinks you gotta pull Up to that little window and get whatever slice your heart desires before you end up blacked-out on the side of the street. The service is fast and the pizza will be out by the time you order it. No place to sit though so you might have to walk around midtown looking for your friends in the mean time.

Jeremy Farris

Best pizza there is.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Cheese Pizza

Load More