We feel that we discovered this amazing Italian gem! My husband ordered a calzone and had shrimp added to it, his exact words were... "this is the best calzone I've ever had!"Excellent customer service, very clean restaurant and food is exquisite! We will definitely come back soon.
heyKerrieAnn
AVOID!! If negative stars were possible and a call the the local health inspector button available on yelp, then we would have clicked on both. Old chicken served, black bones and easily broken bones... Despite prices on menu for wings at $20 for 20 piece, she waited until time for the bill and charged double. When we asked why the drastic charge of double, she quickly replied it was based on "market price" and as a result changes. I guess their wings should say " market price" rather than an actual price. Despite seeing a fountain soda machine, she brought out cans. The restaurant smelled exactly like their filthy dirty bathroom. So imagine a bad roadside bathroom and trying to have a meal while smelling it. They've got to be involved in all the positive reviews because there is simply no way the reviews are legit, this place is an obvious health violation and racket where they hustle large extra sums of money out of unsuspecting customers. AVOID AT ALL COSTS! We are kind people who do not write bad reviews, but we have seriously been pushed into writing a bad review so that others don't go thru the same....oh and for at least a good laugh in attempt to create something positive out of all this, after being scammed out of extra money, my husband started to ask for a ranch sauce to which they said would be an extra charge. He declined and politely said that was ok and no thank you. They then brought him the ranch in a packet with an expired date on it as a measure of courtesy. I guess it was a good fit to go with the old chicken wings with the nearly crumbling bones. Rather than argue with them, we boxed everything, thanked them, and of course threw food in trash rather than risk illness. $90 literally for a pizza and wings place and $90 literally thrown in trash. Epic and unbelievable to say the least. Also, somehow they keep getting bad reviews deleted.
Teri Taylor
Pizza was good. Place itself was not good. I would never come here to eat inside. I would do a to go order only. Top reason to not eat inside..... no working AC!!!!!! Ants were all in the windows running everywhere. It was clear that the waitress didn't trust the drink machine to work. She switched to can drinks and we ate on paper plates. This was not a great experience. Rated a 3 based on food only.
Timothy Philip
Pizza sucks! Barely any cheese on it and undercooked. Atleast the french fries were hot, they get one-star. First time and last time ordering from here. ? Even the carrot cale was stale.
Haden Newhouse
This is an authentic Italian pizza joint that provides idyllic comfort food. In my opinion, this is one of the best pizza places in the area. Haven't tried much here, but the white pizza they have is to die for! Once you have one piece, it's hard to resist more! Highly recommend!
J MAYHEM THE RECKLESS
Absolutely amazing. Just ordered a cheese calzone from here it arrived hot and tasted absolutely amazing. The cheese stretched more than my wingspan!! The marinara sauce is rich and flavorful. Amazing all around very glad I moved in across the street. Definitely my new favorite pizza spot.
Phebe McKean
We found this gem hidden in a run down shopping center while on vacation. The pizza was delicious and my 3 year old ate all of her ravioli!Hurry, and try them today! With the lack of foot traffic in the area they may not be able to survive much longer.... no matter how good they are.....
Philip T.
Great pizza, closest to NYC pizza in Jacksonville FL. The crust is good could be crispier but i think it was my fault for arriving eaarlier. Overall still good crust holds up to the flop test. I had a plain and vegetarian pies. Both were great. This places doesnt seem to buy by the slice but i could be wrong. I did not see any pies ready for slice order. Its a large location probably seat about 50 to 60 people. So far this is the best in Jacksonville. Serfina, former New Yorkers is good to but their sauces didnt take me over the top.
yini ten
Don't hesitate just go in and order!! The customer service was superb! They treat every customer like family! The food was DELICIOUS af! I left beyond satisfied!! I will definitely be going back! Chef's muthaf*#k!ng kiss, Sheeeesh!!!
Mz G
If you are thinking about eating at Mikey’s… don’t think anymore and JUST DO IT‼️? You will not be disappointed ? The Chicken Piccata was delicious ? The caesar salad was fresh. Mikey and his wife are theee most personable ppl I’ve met in awhile. Plenty of options on the menu you will definitely be satisfied ?
Absolutely love Mikey's. Have been ordering from them for years and they always craft a consistently delicious product. From their pizzas to their subs, everything is yummy. If you're looking for authentic NY pizza, go to Mikey's. You can even order by the slice for a quick lunch.
Ellia P.
Looking for italian food in Yelp I found this restaurant. Nothing fancy inside and out. The food? The best italian in Jacksonville. The chicken florentine us is excellent. My favorite in the menu. The pizzas.... Domino's and Pizza Hut wished to be as half as good. The best pizza in town. Everything is made from scratch, nothing frozen. The pasta is made at home. The staff is very friendly. Mickey and his wife (owners) are friendly and always happy to see you. I give it 5 stars!
Ashley Lynch
One of the best pizzas around our neighborhood! Could not rave more about how great of a pie Mikey’s can make! The sauce is my favorite and the crunch on the crust - I cannot find anywhere else!! We have ordered here a few times but this last pizza we just ordered was to good not to share. No photo because we devoured the whole box!
Elizabeth Kelly
Honestly, this is some of the best pizza I’ve had in FL.. regular cheese is identical to pizza you’ll find in NY & NJ. The white pizza is incredible though. The restaurant is clean and the staff was very friendly too. This is my #1 pizza spot in town!
Jennifer gant
Always delicious! The best place to have a pizza. The wraps are amazing! Family owned, I think you should definitely try their food.
We feel that we discovered this amazing Italian gem! My husband ordered a calzone and had shrimp added to it, his exact words were... "this is the best calzone I've ever had!"Excellent customer service, very clean restaurant and food is exquisite! We will definitely come back soon.
AVOID!! If negative stars were possible and a call the the local health inspector button available on yelp, then we would have clicked on both. Old chicken served, black bones and easily broken bones... Despite prices on menu for wings at $20 for 20 piece, she waited until time for the bill and charged double. When we asked why the drastic charge of double, she quickly replied it was based on "market price" and as a result changes. I guess their wings should say " market price" rather than an actual price. Despite seeing a fountain soda machine, she brought out cans. The restaurant smelled exactly like their filthy dirty bathroom. So imagine a bad roadside bathroom and trying to have a meal while smelling it. They've got to be involved in all the positive reviews because there is simply no way the reviews are legit, this place is an obvious health violation and racket where they hustle large extra sums of money out of unsuspecting customers. AVOID AT ALL COSTS! We are kind people who do not write bad reviews, but we have seriously been pushed into writing a bad review so that others don't go thru the same....oh and for at least a good laugh in attempt to create something positive out of all this, after being scammed out of extra money, my husband started to ask for a ranch sauce to which they said would be an extra charge. He declined and politely said that was ok and no thank you. They then brought him the ranch in a packet with an expired date on it as a measure of courtesy. I guess it was a good fit to go with the old chicken wings with the nearly crumbling bones. Rather than argue with them, we boxed everything, thanked them, and of course threw food in trash rather than risk illness. $90 literally for a pizza and wings place and $90 literally thrown in trash. Epic and unbelievable to say the least. Also, somehow they keep getting bad reviews deleted.
Pizza was good. Place itself was not good. I would never come here to eat inside. I would do a to go order only. Top reason to not eat inside..... no working AC!!!!!! Ants were all in the windows running everywhere. It was clear that the waitress didn't trust the drink machine to work. She switched to can drinks and we ate on paper plates. This was not a great experience. Rated a 3 based on food only.
Pizza sucks! Barely any cheese on it and undercooked. Atleast the french fries were hot, they get one-star. First time and last time ordering from here. ? Even the carrot cale was stale.
This is an authentic Italian pizza joint that provides idyllic comfort food. In my opinion, this is one of the best pizza places in the area. Haven't tried much here, but the white pizza they have is to die for! Once you have one piece, it's hard to resist more! Highly recommend!
Absolutely amazing. Just ordered a cheese calzone from here it arrived hot and tasted absolutely amazing. The cheese stretched more than my wingspan!! The marinara sauce is rich and flavorful. Amazing all around very glad I moved in across the street. Definitely my new favorite pizza spot.
We found this gem hidden in a run down shopping center while on vacation. The pizza was delicious and my 3 year old ate all of her ravioli!Hurry, and try them today! With the lack of foot traffic in the area they may not be able to survive much longer.... no matter how good they are.....
Great pizza, closest to NYC pizza in Jacksonville FL. The crust is good could be crispier but i think it was my fault for arriving eaarlier. Overall still good crust holds up to the flop test. I had a plain and vegetarian pies. Both were great. This places doesnt seem to buy by the slice but i could be wrong. I did not see any pies ready for slice order. Its a large location probably seat about 50 to 60 people. So far this is the best in Jacksonville. Serfina, former New Yorkers is good to but their sauces didnt take me over the top.
Don't hesitate just go in and order!! The customer service was superb! They treat every customer like family! The food was DELICIOUS af! I left beyond satisfied!! I will definitely be going back! Chef's muthaf*#k!ng kiss, Sheeeesh!!!
If you are thinking about eating at Mikey’s… don’t think anymore and JUST DO IT‼️? You will not be disappointed ? The Chicken Piccata was delicious ? The caesar salad was fresh. Mikey and his wife are theee most personable ppl I’ve met in awhile. Plenty of options on the menu you will definitely be satisfied ?
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely love Mikey's. Have been ordering from them for years and they always craft a consistently delicious product. From their pizzas to their subs, everything is yummy. If you're looking for authentic NY pizza, go to Mikey's. You can even order by the slice for a quick lunch.
Looking for italian food in Yelp I found this restaurant. Nothing fancy inside and out. The food? The best italian in Jacksonville. The chicken florentine us is excellent. My favorite in the menu. The pizzas.... Domino's and Pizza Hut wished to be as half as good. The best pizza in town. Everything is made from scratch, nothing frozen. The pasta is made at home. The staff is very friendly. Mickey and his wife (owners) are friendly and always happy to see you. I give it 5 stars!
One of the best pizzas around our neighborhood! Could not rave more about how great of a pie Mikey’s can make! The sauce is my favorite and the crunch on the crust - I cannot find anywhere else!! We have ordered here a few times but this last pizza we just ordered was to good not to share. No photo because we devoured the whole box!
Honestly, this is some of the best pizza I’ve had in FL.. regular cheese is identical to pizza you’ll find in NY & NJ. The white pizza is incredible though. The restaurant is clean and the staff was very friendly too. This is my #1 pizza spot in town!
Always delicious! The best place to have a pizza. The wraps are amazing! Family owned, I think you should definitely try their food.