Love the corner office and the people who work here. Ask for the Liz Salad. It's the best!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Todd Venis
Tried to go there for lunch today December 1st, 2023 and sat at the bar. We ordered food and one of us wanted some pizza sauce out inside the calzone along with a cold side of it which he has ordered this form here multiple times with no issues Today the kitchen manager was adamant he would not prepare it that way even though they have in the past. I now see why the restaurant was so empty because the customer service is awful!
Service: 1
Herb
It's mellow mushroom's side bar it's kinda loud and has plenty of the sportz ball on the TVs which they have a few of. Bartenders look out of practice and mediocre at best.Vegetarian options: It's pizza plenty of options for you vegetable & cheese eaters.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Shane Fitzpatrick
All Mello Mushroom's are amazing. This one is a gem. Fantastic drinks expertly made. Food was top notch and quickly brought to the table to boot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Evan Baker
Always delicious pizza and great leftovers.
767conniem
5 out of 5 been here twice, great pizza and staff, had Margherita pizza thin crust, wonderful! Had cheexy bread and Two other pizzas all are good
Natalia Szymanska
Somewhere along the way, this establishment started slipping..... As of recently it has been observed that orders aren't fulfilled properly,service is not up to par with offering an elevated "pie bar",& the floors are so awkwardly sticky,it's disturbing.I really hope you tighten up~
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
baronr2013
I’ve come to Carmine’s on several occasions while visiting Jacksonville. Every time I’ve ordered something different from the menu and each time it’s phenomenal. The Chicago style pizza is amazing and so is the nyc style crust. Literally cannot go wrong with anything here. And the service is excellent. Everyone is personable and friendly. Observing them interact with customers, it’s clear many patrons are regulars and on a first name basis with the staff.
Paul Combs
Great local spot to have a beer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Barbara B
While this is mainly a pizza place, we wanted a dinner with vegetables, so we split the Popeye dinner salad and the creamy chicken pesto dinner. Both were tasty and fresh, but the pasta was a bit mushy. Both plates were very generously sized, so I felt I was getting good value for the price. The atmosphere is kind of local roadhouse meets pizza joint with booths, which is a nice change from the forced vibe of chain restaurants. The service was friendly and timely, though not fast. I would go again if I was in the area and looking for pizza or reasonably priced Italian.
Very cute restaurant. It’s artsy & eclectic, & offers many pizza options as well as other food (mostly Italian). The NY style pizza was very good & close to a NY pizza. The portions of food are huge & the prices are low to average. The staff were friendly. Not sure how we stumbled upon this spot but if I ever came through Jacksonville again, I would want to come back!
Watson Brothers Realtors
Food and atmosphere are always on point!
cherylpd1
After flying into the city, this spot was where three of us had our first meal. The waitress, Ashley, couldn't have been more welcoming and friendly. We found it a great place to relax and wind down, and the abundance of sayings and signs encourage that. We all had individual size pizzas (and the deep dish that my husband ordered was gigantic), and we were all able to take out delicious leftovers for the next day's lunch.
Nitesh Vic Patel - REALTOR
This used to be a great place to go to watch the games. We went here after the Gator Bowl 2022 ended, and service was great. We used to come here often but over time it just seemed like the prices kept increasing, and the food quality was decreasing. This past time our table order the artichoke and that glcame out great. But we also orded the pie and the people I was with said that the bread seemed to be undercooked. I do remember the last time we were here pre covid that we orded a veggie pie and deded up with sausage bits inside. That's why we haven't been back since.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
DonnaKay0312
This was our favorite restaurant that we visited while in town for the Gator Bowl (Go Cocks!). The deep dish pizza was amazing. I enjoyed the buy one/get one half off beer specials on Thursday evening. They were out of the zucchini fries appetizer so we opted for cheesy bread. It was fine, nothing special. I enjoyed the atmosphere-it's a small restaurant and almost every table was full when we arrived at 7:30. Our server, Kristin, was the best! She was so friendly and helpful and even wrote down several places of interest in Jacksonville for us to check out. So nice of her! We were able to get to some of the places she told us about.
Love the corner office and the people who work here. Ask for the Liz Salad. It's the best!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried to go there for lunch today December 1st, 2023 and sat at the bar. We ordered food and one of us wanted some pizza sauce out inside the calzone along with a cold side of it which he has ordered this form here multiple times with no issues Today the kitchen manager was adamant he would not prepare it that way even though they have in the past. I now see why the restaurant was so empty because the customer service is awful!
Service: 1
It's mellow mushroom's side bar it's kinda loud and has plenty of the sportz ball on the TVs which they have a few of. Bartenders look out of practice and mediocre at best.Vegetarian options: It's pizza plenty of options for you vegetable & cheese eaters.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
All Mello Mushroom's are amazing. This one is a gem. Fantastic drinks expertly made. Food was top notch and quickly brought to the table to boot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always delicious pizza and great leftovers.
5 out of 5 been here twice, great pizza and staff, had Margherita pizza thin crust, wonderful! Had cheexy bread and Two other pizzas all are good
Somewhere along the way, this establishment started slipping..... As of recently it has been observed that orders aren't fulfilled properly,service is not up to par with offering an elevated "pie bar",& the floors are so awkwardly sticky,it's disturbing.I really hope you tighten up~
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
I’ve come to Carmine’s on several occasions while visiting Jacksonville. Every time I’ve ordered something different from the menu and each time it’s phenomenal. The Chicago style pizza is amazing and so is the nyc style crust. Literally cannot go wrong with anything here. And the service is excellent. Everyone is personable and friendly. Observing them interact with customers, it’s clear many patrons are regulars and on a first name basis with the staff.
Great local spot to have a beer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
While this is mainly a pizza place, we wanted a dinner with vegetables, so we split the Popeye dinner salad and the creamy chicken pesto dinner. Both were tasty and fresh, but the pasta was a bit mushy. Both plates were very generously sized, so I felt I was getting good value for the price. The atmosphere is kind of local roadhouse meets pizza joint with booths, which is a nice change from the forced vibe of chain restaurants. The service was friendly and timely, though not fast. I would go again if I was in the area and looking for pizza or reasonably priced Italian.
Restaurantji Recommends
Very cute restaurant. It’s artsy & eclectic, & offers many pizza options as well as other food (mostly Italian). The NY style pizza was very good & close to a NY pizza. The portions of food are huge & the prices are low to average. The staff were friendly. Not sure how we stumbled upon this spot but if I ever came through Jacksonville again, I would want to come back!
Food and atmosphere are always on point!
After flying into the city, this spot was where three of us had our first meal. The waitress, Ashley, couldn't have been more welcoming and friendly. We found it a great place to relax and wind down, and the abundance of sayings and signs encourage that. We all had individual size pizzas (and the deep dish that my husband ordered was gigantic), and we were all able to take out delicious leftovers for the next day's lunch.
This used to be a great place to go to watch the games. We went here after the Gator Bowl 2022 ended, and service was great. We used to come here often but over time it just seemed like the prices kept increasing, and the food quality was decreasing. This past time our table order the artichoke and that glcame out great. But we also orded the pie and the people I was with said that the bread seemed to be undercooked. I do remember the last time we were here pre covid that we orded a veggie pie and deded up with sausage bits inside. That's why we haven't been back since.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
This was our favorite restaurant that we visited while in town for the Gator Bowl (Go Cocks!). The deep dish pizza was amazing. I enjoyed the buy one/get one half off beer specials on Thursday evening. They were out of the zucchini fries appetizer so we opted for cheesy bread. It was fine, nothing special. I enjoyed the atmosphere-it's a small restaurant and almost every table was full when we arrived at 7:30. Our server, Kristin, was the best! She was so friendly and helpful and even wrote down several places of interest in Jacksonville for us to check out. So nice of her! We were able to get to some of the places she told us about.