Arthurs Island Kitchen
CLOSED$$ •
102255 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo
Arthurs Island Kitchen Reviews
Arthur was a great host for my Friday evening meal, I ordered the jalapeño crusted yellow tail, a local catch, and it was tasty, especially the sauce that was drizzled on top. It was fresh, crunchy, a little spicy and the sauce made the dish. The veggies were charred Brussels sprouts and cabbage that were seasoned just right. There's a pool table there, Arthur and I played a couple rounds. It's surprising to see such an authentic friendly spot empty on a weekend night. If you're...read full review
A group of us came in from a charter boat (Play Baby) and had them cook our catch. Chef did an excellent job preparing Mahi and Yellowtail. Server was excellent with our group. The place is pretty small, but seems like they can accommodate larger groups.
Ratings
Menu
People in Key Largo Also Viewed
A great and simple little spot near our hotel, we came in just after opening and they were getting everything all set up for us. I'm not a huge fan of seafood but they changed my mind with the conch fritters! Went and played some pool while we waited for our food and when it came out it was great! Everything on the plate went well together and overall has a great time in there. The two gentlemen we interacted with were kind as well, great little spot!