Fernandy's Cafe

1107 Simonton St, Key West
(305) 295-0159

Recent Reviews

Jerod Cazes

The absolute best Cuban sandwiches in Key West. I told you I was going to rate you on Google! Lol. Very good people. If I ever go back to the keys I will definitely go back!

Mike Tarsa

Best tacos I've ever had! Sandwich was amazing! So good and the generous portions are the best value in South Key West.

Mike T.

Ordered the best Pastor tacos I've ever eaten. Grilled sandwich was also amazing. So delicious and generous portions. Best value in South Key West.

Richard B.

Located in a parking lot along with a lot of construction equipment this is a solid option for mostly Cuban specialties between Truman and Duval close to Duval Square. We have eaten here four times in the past two years. Tasty platters of ropa vija and garlic chicken as well as a range of tacos. Other diners praised the Cuban mixed sandwich. It takes about fifteen minutes after you order to get your food. Generous portions. Platters come with plantains, yellow rice and beans. Beans were a bit watery. 4 stars for average rating over two years (2021-2022.)

Scott Falcon

A cool food truck type setup in a permanent location. I enjoyed my Cuban pork with black beans rice and plantains. Very filling and delicious. The pork was very flavorful with a nice citrus bite at the end. The black beans and rice were awesome too. They serve them separate so you can mix as you like. And I can't leave out the nice amount of onions they threw on top. I love onions with both the pork and black beans and rice. Helpful and friendly service. Nice little outside area that is shaded from the sun to enjoy a bite to eat. Will be back

Jill Johnson

Everything we had at Fernandy's was delicious!

Todd Lemihc

Best Cuban food in Key West.... Hands down.

Chris G.

This place is amazing. The food is truly the best in Key West. It is very healthy and nutty tasting which is very hard to find in Key West.

David Speigner

My go to place in Key West for friendly service, post dinner dessert (homemade flan and Key Lime Pie) and amazing Cuban Coffee and Cafe con Leche. Muy bueno!

Jacob Tidwell

Great local food truck. Easy access from most of Duval, Simonton, etc. Quick service. Food was very tasty!

Ryan Q.

Excellent Lunch stop. We got a mariachi burrito and pork sandwich. Super responsive staff and clean seating area.

Brandon Ahler

A food truck where you'd not expect it. A local suggested it and the Cafe con Leches was very, very smooth. The tortas were huge and well worth the price paid. Opens early and stays open late so it's a great place to check out if you want a quick, light bite to eat.

Jess Spagnoli

The services was absolutely terrible. We waited an hour for our food to be delivered, and when they didn’t show up, we called and the guy on the phone acted as though he didn’t know of seamless (which is an option to order their food). Maybe call to order and you will get a better result. There are places with better services in Key West.

Victor S.

The food smells amazing. We shall see how the food tastes. They have a busy menu which makes it hard to read. Of course, with a Mexican/Cuban twist I can see why. Not too busy just before noon. But on the couple of occasions I have passed there were many people lined up to order. Now on a side note. I ordered the churrasco with beans, rice and plantains. After paying and waiting 10 or so minutes I'm told they do not have any churrasco. What a joke. Very disappointed.

S B.

Literally the definition of meh. We had a "Cuban mix" which sounded like a promising Cuban sandwich but actually had some unfortunate additions like salami, lettuce and tomato. Requested those to be removed but the sandwich still came with lettuce and a ton of Mayo. SO MUCH MAYO. Ugh. The pork was good but for a $13 sandwich it did not live up to the expectations . Also had a veggie burrito which was basically ok. My friend said "well I was hungry and after eating this I will not be hungry anymore, so I guess it did it's job.." and that pretty much sums up the experience.

Load More