Sally O'Brien's Irish Pub

1900 Flagler Ave, Key West
(305) 295-8880

Recent Reviews

Raluca Muresan

I went here with my hubby and a friend, we wanted to eat something and to have a little drink. The lady who came at us ( short hair and a lil’ old) was rude, she spoke to us in a very harsh tone, I asked her questions about the menu and she answered me about something completely different, I asked her for a pineapple cider and she said they don't have anything like that, I thought she didn't understand what I had said, so I repeated that I wanted a pineapple cider and she said that they had it and would bring it to me. she asked for my ID, I have an international ID, so it was not a problem for her to read it, but my husband has a Romanian ID and she said that it is not good and that it will not serve him because he cannot prove that he is 21+, although my husband explained and showed her where to look to figure out the date and year, 1996. The atmosphere was not pleasant, a smell of a closed, ugly place, agitated people and a lot of noise. I don’t recommend!

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Tom Traynor

Got there around 10 pm and it was crowded at the bar. No tables were occupied. The place was very loud from people yelling while talking. The service was slow, it took about 10 minutes before one of the 3 bartenders came and took our 3 orders, drinks only. They poured a Guinness quite quickly, they need to work on a proper pour. We had 2 drinks each and left. There were about 8 people outside at tables having drinks and food. Will go back to see if service improves.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Carlton Siple

Nice Bar, great wings , cold beer , good choices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Endeavor Transportation

Good prices. Good music. Good atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Ken Obi

Came here for Trivia night (Thursdays). Arrived during happy hour and the staff was wonderful. We placed our orders (dollar happy hour wings were freaking delicious!) and the food was great. The prices are typical for the area and cheaper than some of the fast food joints in town. They're still fixing up the place so it was a little rough in areas, but nothing bad. The acoustics in the back room were crazy loud since the carpet was removed, but that's to be expected with a crowd.7/10, will return for those chili-lime wings!Also, it's a bar/restaurant, if you want fine dining and white tablecloths, go somewhere else and pay through the nose. Come here for good grub and good company!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Patty Melt

Ken Anderson

Super fun place, great atmosphere and great service. The owner has done a great job of making this place simple and they've hired the best staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jacob Clark

Service was great and the food was delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shepherds Pie

Sylvia A

Parking: Has a parking lot and plenty of on street parking. Now called Brady's.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shepherds Pie

Richard

On bicycles, we looked for a lunch spot from Smathers Beach back to the hotel. So glad we stopped. Lunch was great. The bartenders service was spot on. Forgot his name (spoke about football).Not a fancy or trendy spot. More of a traditional neighborhood Irish bar...

Austin

the reuben is really good and they offer take out

a f

Oh my. This was NOT a good tasty experience. This meal was absolutely awful! The waitress was incredibly kind-but i couldn’t stomach the meat at all. It tasted unlike anything I’ve ever experienced??? I love a good special but this is a hard pass from me. The potatoes were good for a couple of bites, but then they just went wrong. I’m not sure what was wrong here. But the taste was off

Dennis Gill

Many favorites are still on the menu. I especially like the shepherd's pie. My wife really likes the pizza. Nice selection of draft beer on tap. The reuben sandwich has gone a little down hill, but is still good (but not great as before). We see a lot of new staff, and the service is great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips, Pizza, Shepherds Pie

Tim Newby

Really delicious food. Friendly staff too.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tomas Constantino

Good attention.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Todd Frerichs

Irish pub, get an irish beer. Enough said. Great place.

Service: 5

Load More