The portions are very small ( appetizer size) and not worth the price. We got the scallops wrapped in bacon and the trio combo and both were good but very small.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Carla Hicklin
What a gem! Cool vibe, awesome staff, and delicious food. Thanks to Fred, Dean, and Peter for a very enjoyable evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin Crockett
Great atmosphere but meal was average at beat, steak was over done my wife’s grouper didn’t have any sauceBad value.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
joseph dyer
Lobster Mac & Cheese to die for -- but sometimes inconsistent. Energetic, friendly, fun server.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Liz Smith
Not worth the price at all. Was expecting a more higher quality meal for the price & how many amazing reviews we’ve seen. The portion sizes are tiny compared to how much the price is. We got the lobster Mac and cheese app. However I would say it did taste fairly good but (Do not share because it’s barely enough for 1 and 28$).We also got the lobster tomato soup with grilled cheese which sounded fun and unique but tasted like a can of tomato sauce and the grilled cheese wasn’t even toasted…The trio of entrees was tiny in portion size, and the strangest flavors mixed together that did not complement well. I would say the quality was low, and the fish was dry.The shrimp we got was good, so if anything you order there I was say that’s your best bet.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Robert
After making our reservation for the wrong day we showed up to no table for us. We were graciously offered bar seating and it actually turned out better than table service. This meal was far and away the best meal we had during our week in Key West. From the appetizer to the entree to the desert to the wine recommendation, everything was spectacular. The atmosphere was cozy and the service was top notch. Just a spectacular and memorable meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin Arnoldi
This place is a must visit in Key West! The food is incredible, the staff amazing, and the wine selection superb. We had the Coconut Shrimp Red Curry and the Three Way Filet Chili. The chocolate adds a dimension to the chili that is unexpectedly and fantastically delicious. The red curry has a kick that's not too hot for my delicate palate and the crusted coconut shrimp is not to be missed. I personally am obsessed with Tempranillo. Theirs does not disappoint. Pick up a bottle with dinner and you're all set. A gem just off Duvall. Do not pass go. Come for the food. Stay for the Star Wars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Bermudez
On of our favorite restaurants on the island - the food is always solid, the prices are fair, the atmosphere is adorable, and the staff is absolutely wonderful. Always a treat to come here ?Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating for our celiac friends - they offer gluten free noodles and substitutes for sides.
Loved the dinner for a second year in a row! This place rocks! One of the best restaurants in KW.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Mac & Cheese
Donald Achord
Not what I expected going by its name, but I was pleasantly surprised. Expected more of an upbeat party style restaurant. I mean, really, the Flaming Buoy?! Lots of great reviews. But no one mentioned it was a low-key, high-end restaurant. However, the atmosphere was great and the food was absolutely amazing.
Phenomenal restaurant… the best meal we’ve had so far in key west! Incredible food, service and amazing atmosphere especially for Star Wars lovers! Don’t know why more people don’t talk about this gem!Dietary restrictions: Allergy friendly!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Mac & Cheese, Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Kyle
Flaming buoy is our absolute favorite place to dine in Key West. Food - amazing. Service - top notch. Biggest thing though - they are completely unpretentious and present a perfectly relaxed spot for a great meal. The atmosphere is just right. Buoy is a can’t miss spot every time we are in KW.
The Flaming Buoy in Key West is a gem – the vibe is chill, perfect for actually enjoying a conversation without turning it into a shouting match. It's got this simple elegance that makes you feel comfortable, not like you're walking on eggshells. Now, let's talk about the food – it's not just tasty, it's a flavor adventure with some out-of-the-box dishes that'll make your taste buds do a happy dance. They've got variety without going too crazy, striking that delicious balance. And the service? Top-notch with a side of humor – a refreshing change that adds an extra sprinkle of fun to your dining experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Entree Trio
J Carrow
Three stars for the balance of portion size to cost.$113 got me the scallop appetizer, the surf and turf daily special and one glass of wine. This cost would have been acceptable had they served even average sized dishes.The scallops used in the appetizer were either small (or more likely a single scallop cut). You received two (one cut scallop).The filet on the surf and turf was three ounces max. I made three bites out of it, and they were small bites.The lobster thermidor had great flavor, but you only got the tail.I'm all for quality food costing a premium, but here they take advantage of premium pricing. I'm all for a nice meal, but not when it feels like you're being taken advantage of.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Alex Vibber
Great themed place and also very friendly staff. Food was great as well and quite upscale.
The portions are very small ( appetizer size) and not worth the price. We got the scallops wrapped in bacon and the trio combo and both were good but very small.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
What a gem! Cool vibe, awesome staff, and delicious food. Thanks to Fred, Dean, and Peter for a very enjoyable evening.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great atmosphere but meal was average at beat, steak was over done my wife’s grouper didn’t have any sauceBad value.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 4
Lobster Mac & Cheese to die for -- but sometimes inconsistent. Energetic, friendly, fun server.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Not worth the price at all. Was expecting a more higher quality meal for the price & how many amazing reviews we’ve seen. The portion sizes are tiny compared to how much the price is. We got the lobster Mac and cheese app. However I would say it did taste fairly good but (Do not share because it’s barely enough for 1 and 28$).We also got the lobster tomato soup with grilled cheese which sounded fun and unique but tasted like a can of tomato sauce and the grilled cheese wasn’t even toasted…The trio of entrees was tiny in portion size, and the strangest flavors mixed together that did not complement well. I would say the quality was low, and the fish was dry.The shrimp we got was good, so if anything you order there I was say that’s your best bet.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
After making our reservation for the wrong day we showed up to no table for us. We were graciously offered bar seating and it actually turned out better than table service. This meal was far and away the best meal we had during our week in Key West. From the appetizer to the entree to the desert to the wine recommendation, everything was spectacular. The atmosphere was cozy and the service was top notch. Just a spectacular and memorable meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a must visit in Key West! The food is incredible, the staff amazing, and the wine selection superb. We had the Coconut Shrimp Red Curry and the Three Way Filet Chili. The chocolate adds a dimension to the chili that is unexpectedly and fantastically delicious. The red curry has a kick that's not too hot for my delicate palate and the crusted coconut shrimp is not to be missed. I personally am obsessed with Tempranillo. Theirs does not disappoint. Pick up a bottle with dinner and you're all set. A gem just off Duvall. Do not pass go. Come for the food. Stay for the Star Wars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
On of our favorite restaurants on the island - the food is always solid, the prices are fair, the atmosphere is adorable, and the staff is absolutely wonderful. Always a treat to come here ?Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating for our celiac friends - they offer gluten free noodles and substitutes for sides.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Corn - - He-Cob, Lime Butter Sauce, Mashed Potatoes, Banana Bread, Noodles, Caesar Salad, Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Loved the dinner for a second year in a row! This place rocks! One of the best restaurants in KW.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Mac & Cheese
Not what I expected going by its name, but I was pleasantly surprised. Expected more of an upbeat party style restaurant. I mean, really, the Flaming Buoy?! Lots of great reviews. But no one mentioned it was a low-key, high-end restaurant. However, the atmosphere was great and the food was absolutely amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Appetizer Trio, Lobster Thermidor, Caprese, Lobster Mac & Cheese, Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Restaurantji Recommends
Phenomenal restaurant… the best meal we’ve had so far in key west! Incredible food, service and amazing atmosphere especially for Star Wars lovers! Don’t know why more people don’t talk about this gem!Dietary restrictions: Allergy friendly!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Mac & Cheese, Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Flaming buoy is our absolute favorite place to dine in Key West. Food - amazing. Service - top notch. Biggest thing though - they are completely unpretentious and present a perfectly relaxed spot for a great meal. The atmosphere is just right. Buoy is a can’t miss spot every time we are in KW.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Entree Trio, Lime Butter Sauce, Mashed Potatoes, Noodles, Caesar Salad, Bacon Wrapped Scallops, Salad
The Flaming Buoy in Key West is a gem – the vibe is chill, perfect for actually enjoying a conversation without turning it into a shouting match. It's got this simple elegance that makes you feel comfortable, not like you're walking on eggshells. Now, let's talk about the food – it's not just tasty, it's a flavor adventure with some out-of-the-box dishes that'll make your taste buds do a happy dance. They've got variety without going too crazy, striking that delicious balance. And the service? Top-notch with a side of humor – a refreshing change that adds an extra sprinkle of fun to your dining experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Entree Trio
Three stars for the balance of portion size to cost.$113 got me the scallop appetizer, the surf and turf daily special and one glass of wine. This cost would have been acceptable had they served even average sized dishes.The scallops used in the appetizer were either small (or more likely a single scallop cut). You received two (one cut scallop).The filet on the surf and turf was three ounces max. I made three bites out of it, and they were small bites.The lobster thermidor had great flavor, but you only got the tail.I'm all for quality food costing a premium, but here they take advantage of premium pricing. I'm all for a nice meal, but not when it feels like you're being taken advantage of.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Great themed place and also very friendly staff. Food was great as well and quite upscale.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5