Real New York Pizza

1137 W Columbia Ave, Kissimmee
(407) 847-0333

Recent Reviews

Gio Torres

Took almost 2 hrs for the pizza to be delivered. Cold ordered it well done and it was not. Didnt ask for any refund or anything just wont ever order from here again. They were much better than this.

Diane Asher

Smallest Stromboli and portion of lasagna I have ever had. There are tons of restaurants in this area take your business there and don’t waste your time with this location.

Phyllis C.

They clearly are not from New York. The crust was thin and terrible! I truly believe this was frozen pizza just heated up. Horrible taste. They delivered without a receipt and I'm pretty sure they Overcharged us. Do not do!!

Sdot TheChampion

This business has zero integrity and will rob you of a dollar if they can. Enjoy the $45 dollars you stole from me by refusing to cancel my order. I wonder how much money you lose from bad customer service. I can’t imagine the pizza is very good considering they don’t care about their image. Boo this business. I hope they aren’t around on our next vacation.

Adalberto M.

Made a Order on Christmas Day only place open close to me. Used Huber. Received two pizza's instead of four. Called pizzeria. They charged for four but only sent two. Huber wasn't at fault but was going to charge again if they would have to deliver the other two pizza pies. The pizzeria didn't want to except any wrong doing and was making it difficult to get a refund. I told them this was going on their review and the response from the lady on the phone was the question are you threatening me. Seeing my refund was going to be a nightmare, It was easier to go get the remaining pizza's. The lady made me wait 10 minutes before attending me then another's ten to give me the pizza's. The place is a hole in the wall. Not clean, door to enter had a chair holding it open and employees dressed unprofessional. No effort to address concerns by customers. Avoid this business at all cost.

Rockridge

Chicken tenders were extra extra well done. My wife and my sons order was wrong. They cant eat because of allergies to mushrooms and tomatoes. Order of fries missing. Food was cold.I called them and they told me to call Uber Eats. Ya right. Cause Uber Eats screwed up the order?This place SUX

Angel Snow

Being from the Bronx its hard to impress me with Real NY Pizza here in Fl.. I must say that I am impressed with the Pizza. The service was good and Pizza even Better!! Thumbs up for sure.... Good NY ??

Chase D.

Roman Ruiz Jose 321-746-2323 That's the driver that never showed up and threatened my girlfriend. We ordered and waited 1.5hrs for 2 pizzas a mile away from the shop. We called and they stated he knocked with no answer (I have a ring doorbell). He left a voicemail saying he wasn't going to get out of the car. So he lied to his boss. They said he would deliver it again. When he was on the way he called and told us to meet him in the parking lot of our complex. We told him we couldn't and he said he wasn't coming anymore and hung up. During that phone call he also threatened my girlfriend. I go to the shop and nobody is even there. Don't ever order from here. Better options in the area.

Christina Elliott

Horrible! Ordered door dash. Pizza was ice cold... not even warm and missing sauce. Very disappointed considering it costed $42 for a medium pizza and some boneless wings. Do not recommend!

geordan rolfe

A bit over priced for the level of quality food. Boneless wings were most likely frozen and then smothered in a cheap sauce. Garlic bread with mozzarella was very average, just a sliced loaf with garlic butter and some shredded mozzarella thrown inside. Ranch dressing for salad tastes generic. Calzone seemed freshly made and tasted good, just not at all worth the price. Shorten up your menu and focus on a few key items to go all out on.

Jeramy Potter

BIGG ?SLICES ?

Aprende Inglés con Monique

I ordered a Meat Lover's pizza and I received a plain cheese. I was reimbursed by uber eats but that is not the point. If I wanted a plain cheese pizza, I would have ordered a plain cheese pizza. Very disappointed

Irving Santiago

NOT REAL NEW YORK PIZZA!!!!Pizza was under cooked and doughy. Go somewhere else!!! Wings were decent.

Starr YL

First time ordering from here and will be the last.We don’t live very far , pizza arrived an hour later , which I didn’t mind but it was stale and cold. I should’ve saved my money and ate soup from home. I was craving a nice hot pizza and got a nice cold one instead. Taste very stale and bland ??‍♂️??‍♂️ Had to microwave them. Won’t be getting my money again.

Mia Alejandro

Pizza here is fire ! Everything fresh and very clean, the owner is fantastic, and makes sure his establishment is in order however the big ol lady in the front with no eyebrows the manager is a nut job she makes me want to never step foot in their to get pizza

Load More