Jeremiah's Italian Ice

4355 W Lake Mary Blvd, Lake Mary
(407) 302-9882

Recent Reviews

Gina E.

We love this place. We enjoy eating outside. They give free samples. We always bring our grandkids here for a treat.

Hamood

Had an excellent experience here about a week ago, it has been keeping me coming back, it was in the mid afternoon and I had a short but sweet conversation with morgan, she was very nice and helpful and I hope to see her there more!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies & Cream, Cookie Butter, Soft Ice Cream

Simone Behar

I just swung through to get my kids and their friends a sweet treat for Valentine’s Day, and Lila greeted us with the biggest smile and was so genuinely kind. ❤️ You are so lucky to have someone so special working for you! She made our whole day and we will be back again and again. All the kids say “thank you!” to Lila for their yummy Italian ice. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erika Lambis

I went yesterday with my boyfriend to get a waffle cone with vanilla ice cream and chocolate sprinkles and I haven’t gone there in a while because they have been out of chocolate sprinkles. The girl at the window said they were still out. I mean it’s been months now. Why?Not only that but when she handed my boyfriend my ice cream, she had it tilted and it almost fell. I’ve never experienced this type of customer service and I’ve been living in this community for years. First time ever. I would give it a 5 star but after yesterday’s experience and not having chocolate sprinkles for months, it’s getting a 3!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 1

Sajjad

Nice place to go, especially in the summer. Love their italian ice flavors and very tasty. Kids love this place. They also have outdoor seating with music playing. Friendly

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mango, Passion Fruit, Soft Ice Cream

brandi Jodon

There were fruit flies in my Italian ice gross

A

The best ice cream in the area! So good and love the samples!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Soft Serve Ice Cream, Cotton Candy Gelati, Scoop Froggy Frog with Twist Soft Serve Ice Cream, Cake Batter

Scott Knows

I have yet to have found a Jeremiah's that wasn't great, and this one is no exception.(Keep in mind, I never go when they are busy).The perfect place for a "mid afternoon treat" and they have seasonal flavors too!My go-to are their Gelati's, an affordable option of an Italian Ice and Ice Cream swirl with your choice of flavor.(And there are MANY flavors to choose from!)If you have never been, I recommend you pay a visit. You won't be disappointed. ??Dietary restrictions: Italian Ice is non-dairy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Strawberry Gelati

Denise M.

Pay at the counter or go through the drive thru. Lots of different flavor options to select from. We got vanilla and chocolate swirl. The chocolate flavor was good but wished the vanilla had more flavor. We were asked if we wanted any samples. Came here for a Yelp event. Service was very friendly and quick.

Andrew Stone

Good ice cream and gelato here!

Sylvia G.

Friendly service, great ice cream & cozy atmosphere outside (no inside seating)! A little expensive but worth it IF employees are being decently compensated.

Robert Hobgood

My relatives live over by that place. They brought me there 4 one of those ice treats. It was great! I was visiting from Michigan.

Angel Gabriel

Best ice cream in the world, employees are great and the ice cream is very good, I've never had a problem.Thank you!

Edward Voluntad

Exceptional gelati. Chocolate water ice with chocolate shaving and vanilla custard. Generous size.

Courtney S.

Jeremiah's is the best place for a sweet treat! Gelati is fantastic! So many great flavors of Italian ice to chose from and they are all so good! You can get up to 3 different flavors in one!

Load More