Michael Anthony Cakes

1540 International Pkwy, Lake Mary
(407) 453-2064

Recent Reviews

Tafferlon Russell

IF you need a honset great bakery please give; Michael Anthony a try, I had a very bad experince with bakery hyping their Cake up then when you recieve the cake just be angry for the deceitful product ; because it was not what was presented, But!!!!!! Michael is the real bakery! the cake you see was awsome and beautiful all the flavors was so awesome and exactly what I order. it was not a crumb left everyone was coming back for more, oh this is the best part the baby shower was 3/3/24 I save a slice for my sister and she just recieve it today 3/5/24 and it was still fresh and moist. Now that's a Great Cake!!!!!! and Michael is very polite, caring and professional.Thanks so much .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zharia Kyla Rivera

5 stars! Michael was so deeply sweet. Made us feel so very welcome and kindly shook all our hands. Great professionalism, and a master of his craft. The cake was beautifully done with such attention to detail and precision. The color scheme on point and the taste is impeccable. I highly implore you to book his services. You will NOT regret it! Thank you Michael!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Alexandra Hamilton

Michael is amazing and is so accommodating!! Even though he was fully booked with orders for months out, he was willing to help me with an emergency wedding cake disaster that I needed handled in 24 hours. Such a sweet man and his beautiful, delectable cupcakes are absolutely to die for. All the guests at the wedding were raving about them. I highly recommend working with Michael for your special event bakery needs!!

Elizabeth Butler

I would give a thousand stars if I could! The process of getting the cake ordered was absolutely seamless! Michael really took time to understand what we wanted and delivered exactly that! The cake itself was a work of art! It also had the added benefit of being delicious! We will for sure be ordering more in our future! I recommend everyone else do the same!as well!

Brittany Connor

The cake and cupcakes were delicious! Michael did a great job with presentation of the cake and cupcakes at our wedding! I would highly recommend Michael's cakes for any any special occasion!

SHIRLEY Mayeux

Michael Anthony Cakes IWe are so thankful for the love and care you did with our request for our wedding cake ? ?! Even making a whole cake that you didn't even have on your menu! We are now celebrating our one year anniversary with the same delish amazing cake thank you so much!

Brad Johnson

Exceeded all expectations. We reached out to Michael to make a cake for our daughter’s 1st birthday. We sent him a picture of the backdrop we were using and he made a beautiful cake that was the perfect match. So much more than what we were expecting. I cannot recommend him enough!

Gabrielle Scholle

I have had the privilege of enjoying Michael Anthony's delightful cakes for many years now, and he never fails to impress! The flavors he crafts are truly exceptional, offering a unique richness that remains consistent with each and every creation. What sets Michael apart is his exceptional communication skills throughout the entire process.Most notably, Michael had the honor of designing our wedding cake, a true four-tier masterpiece. It was everything we had envisioned and more. Each tier boasted a different flavor, adding an exciting element to the overall experience. Michael made the entire process effortless by organizing a tasting session where we could provide examples and discuss our preferences in detail. His enthusiasm and attention to detail were truly remarkable.One of the standout aspects of our wedding cake was the intricate gold foil ornate monogram that he flawlessly recreated. It added a touch of elegance and personalization that exceeded our expectations. Additionally, Michael even went above and beyond by creating vegan cupcake versions of each tier, which were just as delectable as their non-vegan counterparts. I'm still amazed at how he manages to achieve such incredible taste and texture in his vegan creations.Without hesitation, I wholeheartedly recommend Michael Anthony for all your cake needs. His talent, professionalism, and dedication to delivering exceptional results are unmatched. Whether it's a small gathering or a grand event like a wedding, you can trust him to create a memorable masterpiece that will leave everyone in awe.

Gabrielle S.

I have had the privilege of enjoying Michael Anthony's delightful cakes for many years now, and he never fails to impress! The flavors he crafts are truly exceptional, offering a unique richness that remains consistent with each and every creation. What sets Michael apart is his exceptional communication skills throughout the entire process. Most notably, Michael had the honor of designing our wedding cake, a true four-tier masterpiece. It was everything we had envisioned and more. Each tier boasted a different flavor, adding an exciting element to the overall experience. Michael made the entire process effortless by organizing a tasting session where we could provide examples and discuss our preferences in detail. His enthusiasm and attention to detail were truly remarkable. One of the standout aspects of our wedding cake was the intricate gold foil ornate monogram that he flawlessly recreated. It added a touch of elegance and personalization that exceeded our expectations. Additionally, Michael even went above and beyond by creating vegan cupcake versions of each tier, which were just as delectable as their non-vegan counterparts. I'm still amazed at how he manages to achieve such incredible taste and texture in his vegan creations. Without hesitation, I wholeheartedly recommend Michael Anthony for all your cake needs. His talent, professionalism, and dedication to delivering exceptional results are unmatched. Whether it's a small gathering or a grand event like a wedding, you can trust him to create a memorable masterpiece that will leave everyone in awe.

aerleen otero

Michael was kind enough to take my order at last minute. He did for my husband an amazing cake! The decoration was better than what I had originally showed him. We got the moonshine chocolate and it was amazing!!!!! I definitely recommend him 100%!

Shalini Sealey

Michael did my 1 year old birthday cake and smash cake and he did not disappoint. He made the ordering process super easy. The cake looked absolutely amazing and the taste was amazing as well. I highly recommend him for cakes.

Marissa C.

Michael Anthony's Cakes spoiled me. I don't think we could ever get a better cake than what he has made for us. He made these cupcakes for my wedding rehearsal, Star Wars groom cake and white chocolate and strawberry bride cake. His cakes are the best, most memorable, stunning and are mouth watering delicious!!! You won't be disappointed one single bit!! Definitely give him a call about his cakes for any occasion!

Victoria Torres

Seriously the BEST CAKES ever! Are made by Michael! I am a coordinator and I only eat cake when the baker is Michael! SO I had to have him for my baby shower and everyone RAVED!

Jamie Lopina

Michael Anthony did our wedding cake and it was absolutely BEAUTIFUL. The flavor was delicious and the design was exactly what we were looking for. Michael was amazing throughout the whole process and we wouldn't have wanted anyone else in charge of our cake! 100% recommend using Michael Anthony Cakes for any cake needs you may have in the future.

CJ W

I am so grateful to have found Michael Anthony Cakes! From the start, Michael was extremely communicative and detailed, responding to my inquiry same day. He made sure he understood my requests and answered all of my questions. Michael created a beautiful 2-tiered main cake and smash cake for my son's 1st birthday party this month, which had a nautical theme. I simply provided a photo of the design I wanted and Michael far exceeded my expectations. Michael offers a delightful variety of cake flavors and fillings to select from. For the main cake, I decided on a vanilla bean cake with lemon curd and fresh strawberries. Oh my gosh, it was phenomenal! I could taste every flavor, which melted in my mouth - the cake extremely moist. All of our family and friends are still raving about this cake, and I recommend Michael Anthony Cakes each time! I cannot wait for our next party. Michael, thank you for helping us create a beautiful and memorable day for our little one!

Load More