I've come here for years. It's definitely some of the best NY pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Ulgonda K.
Huge fan of this place! We have ordered pizza delivery a few times now and every time it has been hot and super tasty! Their spinach roll is surprisingly great! Delivery is fairly quick and without issue. Highly recommend giving them a try.
Jess I.
We always order the pizza (well done) + wings hot garlic extra sauce on the side (well done)+ 2liter deal and it's always very good! Also tried the Stromboli last time and it was great as well!
Todd W.
I eat here often as It's one of two restaurants in the same plaza where I work, just a walk across the parking lot at The Sharing Center. They definitely get a lot of business from us. Interior? It could use an update. Think mom and pop cafe. Nothing fancy. Order at counter, take out or sit and a server will take your order. A small interior with I'd say about 8 tables/ booths. The food? I'd give possibly 3.5 stars. What I've liked? They have great salads. I've tried their antipasto salad and Ceasar salad. Both generous in portion on the lunch special and filled with fresh yummy ingredients. $6.99 for their lunch special on weekdays and includes a soda. Their pizza? I've found ordering their two slice special is reheated and a bit more greasy vs. Ordering a whole pie. Thin N.Y. style crust. It's still pretty good. I ordered a side of marinara as I like to dip my crusts in it. Good. A little sweet, but yum. I've tried their meatball sub a few times and their steak and cheese. I'd go with the meatball. My co workers often order their wings, chicken fingers, and cheesesticks...yet to try, but popular. Service? It's always great. Relaxed and friendly. If you're in the neighborhood and want a non fast food option made with more love. Try here! Not fancy, inexpensive and enough to fill your belly!
Jazz O
Nice pizza joint, kind staff, & I was blown away by their garlic knots!!! Literally the best I’ve had in Florida!!! The pizza is New York certified: crispy & delicious! Nice fresh toppings! Swing by you won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Faith Parkinson
This place is a gem. High quality ingredients, friendly staff, reasonable prices , best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joey Krupnicki
Ordered a 14" Pepperoni, wings, and garlic knots.All three were perfect and price was extremely fair.Will definitely be ordering here again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rosaigna Rodriguez
My son always orders the wings there lower in salt intake than other places. They can use happier people to service the public though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Wings
Ed Ramos
So I've ordered twice asking for the two slice deal for pick up. I have asked for extra cheese with my toppings stating I would like to pay for the extra cheese. I'm told no problem. I get there and the excuse is the pizza already comes with extraa cheese. To the owner of this establishment. If the customer asks for an item and is willing to pay. Give them what they want. Jeez.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Lisa Crismon
This was the WORST PIZZA and salad ever! The salad was just the core of lettace with ham slapped on top. The sausage on the pizza tasted like leather. Threw away the entire $32.00 pizza. DO NOT EAT at this restaurant
We enjoyed the pizza. We give it four stars - tasty, flaky crust, appropriate portioning of cheese and pepperoni. Bonus points for not being greasy - on top of or under the pizza. We ordered a side of marinara to dip our crust in and that was actually really good.Breadsticks only get one star because we asked for the bread pictured on their menu - which was confirmed to be their breadsticks, but what we received was not what was pictured. It was like little Caesar’s crazy bread, but less tasty and did not match the description on the ordering website or the picture on paper menu.Overall, would eat again. You can dine in or take out. Looks like there was someone doing delivery too.
Neal McLain
WOW!!!!!! The best Alfredo I've ever had, and I've had a LOT of Alfredo. It was such a treat to find this place. It has to be the best kept Italian secret in all of Florida. The people were super nice. The food was truly amazing. If I'm ever within an hour of Longwood again I promise you I will be stopping again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Italian
J c
Great little pizza place. Fair pricing. Pizza tastes very good.
geegee herr
Great pizza and pasta plus the prices are very reasonable and the combo options are great as well!!!
Robert Herring
I’ve been ordering take out and deliver from New York Italian Express for about 5 years now about 8-10 times a year or more and I’ve never been disappointed. Unless they are really busy (which they always let you know beforehand if they are very busy) then they’ll tell me my delivery order should arrive in about 45 minutes. Which my delivery usually arrives about 10 to 15 minutes earlier. 30-35 minutes, which is always appreciated. My orders have always been nice and hot (not too hot), just right. Not only is their New York style pizza amazing, but all of the pasta dinners are amazing as well and they are very reasonably priced with sone pretty good deals on discounts for family combos. You absolutely cannot go wrong with the Combo Dinner (lasagna ravioli manicotti and stuffed shells) from the Baked Entrées section and they allow you to switch it up if you’d like. Meaning if you’d like extra manicotti to substitute for having the stuffed shells or any of the other four options (which I usually substitute the stuffed shells with extra manicotti because their manicotti is just so good). Their manicotti really is truly amazing. Sooo good. They’re always very polite about it and extremely helpful. I love that it is a small locally owned family business that does their own delivery and not DoorDash or ubereats that rip people off with all the extra fees. You’re definitely saving money by much lower fees from New York Italian Express using their own employees for delivery. I really hope New York Italian Express sticks around for many years to come and I really hope they don’t cave in to doing delivery’s through grub hub, DoorDash or any of those other rip off huge corporate delivery services that always tack on $10+ or more with a bunch of bullsh*t extra fees. NY Italian Express is perfect the way it is now, please don’t change a thing. Haha ??I plan on staying a loyal customer for a long time as well as referring friends and family to NY Italian Express so they to can enjoy some amazing Italian pasta and baked dinners as well as their amazing New York style pizza. Next time I’ll snap some photos before eating. Until then, I look forward to enjoying another amazing meal via delivery or pickup after a long stressful day and I’m not in the mood to cook. Always fast, efficient and I’ve never been disappointed in the least bit by their amazing food.
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Specialty Calzone, Fetuchinni Alfredo with Chicken and Broccoli, Baked Ziti, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Italian, Chicken Parmigiana Sub, Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Chicken Parmigiana, Italian Sub, Italian Express
I've come here for years. It's definitely some of the best NY pizza around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Huge fan of this place! We have ordered pizza delivery a few times now and every time it has been hot and super tasty! Their spinach roll is surprisingly great! Delivery is fairly quick and without issue. Highly recommend giving them a try.
We always order the pizza (well done) + wings hot garlic extra sauce on the side (well done)+ 2liter deal and it's always very good! Also tried the Stromboli last time and it was great as well!
I eat here often as It's one of two restaurants in the same plaza where I work, just a walk across the parking lot at The Sharing Center. They definitely get a lot of business from us. Interior? It could use an update. Think mom and pop cafe. Nothing fancy. Order at counter, take out or sit and a server will take your order. A small interior with I'd say about 8 tables/ booths. The food? I'd give possibly 3.5 stars. What I've liked? They have great salads. I've tried their antipasto salad and Ceasar salad. Both generous in portion on the lunch special and filled with fresh yummy ingredients. $6.99 for their lunch special on weekdays and includes a soda. Their pizza? I've found ordering their two slice special is reheated and a bit more greasy vs. Ordering a whole pie. Thin N.Y. style crust. It's still pretty good. I ordered a side of marinara as I like to dip my crusts in it. Good. A little sweet, but yum. I've tried their meatball sub a few times and their steak and cheese. I'd go with the meatball. My co workers often order their wings, chicken fingers, and cheesesticks...yet to try, but popular. Service? It's always great. Relaxed and friendly. If you're in the neighborhood and want a non fast food option made with more love. Try here! Not fancy, inexpensive and enough to fill your belly!
Nice pizza joint, kind staff, & I was blown away by their garlic knots!!! Literally the best I’ve had in Florida!!! The pizza is New York certified: crispy & delicious! Nice fresh toppings! Swing by you won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
This place is a gem. High quality ingredients, friendly staff, reasonable prices , best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a 14" Pepperoni, wings, and garlic knots.All three were perfect and price was extremely fair.Will definitely be ordering here again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My son always orders the wings there lower in salt intake than other places. They can use happier people to service the public though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Wings
So I've ordered twice asking for the two slice deal for pick up. I have asked for extra cheese with my toppings stating I would like to pay for the extra cheese. I'm told no problem. I get there and the excuse is the pizza already comes with extraa cheese. To the owner of this establishment. If the customer asks for an item and is willing to pay. Give them what they want. Jeez.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
This was the WORST PIZZA and salad ever! The salad was just the core of lettace with ham slapped on top. The sausage on the pizza tasted like leather. Threw away the entire $32.00 pizza. DO NOT EAT at this restaurant
Restaurantji Recommends
We enjoyed the pizza. We give it four stars - tasty, flaky crust, appropriate portioning of cheese and pepperoni. Bonus points for not being greasy - on top of or under the pizza. We ordered a side of marinara to dip our crust in and that was actually really good.Breadsticks only get one star because we asked for the bread pictured on their menu - which was confirmed to be their breadsticks, but what we received was not what was pictured. It was like little Caesar’s crazy bread, but less tasty and did not match the description on the ordering website or the picture on paper menu.Overall, would eat again. You can dine in or take out. Looks like there was someone doing delivery too.
WOW!!!!!! The best Alfredo I've ever had, and I've had a LOT of Alfredo. It was such a treat to find this place. It has to be the best kept Italian secret in all of Florida. The people were super nice. The food was truly amazing. If I'm ever within an hour of Longwood again I promise you I will be stopping again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Italian
Great little pizza place. Fair pricing. Pizza tastes very good.
Great pizza and pasta plus the prices are very reasonable and the combo options are great as well!!!
I’ve been ordering take out and deliver from New York Italian Express for about 5 years now about 8-10 times a year or more and I’ve never been disappointed. Unless they are really busy (which they always let you know beforehand if they are very busy) then they’ll tell me my delivery order should arrive in about 45 minutes. Which my delivery usually arrives about 10 to 15 minutes earlier. 30-35 minutes, which is always appreciated. My orders have always been nice and hot (not too hot), just right. Not only is their New York style pizza amazing, but all of the pasta dinners are amazing as well and they are very reasonably priced with sone pretty good deals on discounts for family combos. You absolutely cannot go wrong with the Combo Dinner (lasagna ravioli manicotti and stuffed shells) from the Baked Entrées section and they allow you to switch it up if you’d like. Meaning if you’d like extra manicotti to substitute for having the stuffed shells or any of the other four options (which I usually substitute the stuffed shells with extra manicotti because their manicotti is just so good). Their manicotti really is truly amazing. Sooo good. They’re always very polite about it and extremely helpful. I love that it is a small locally owned family business that does their own delivery and not DoorDash or ubereats that rip people off with all the extra fees. You’re definitely saving money by much lower fees from New York Italian Express using their own employees for delivery. I really hope New York Italian Express sticks around for many years to come and I really hope they don’t cave in to doing delivery’s through grub hub, DoorDash or any of those other rip off huge corporate delivery services that always tack on $10+ or more with a bunch of bullsh*t extra fees. NY Italian Express is perfect the way it is now, please don’t change a thing. Haha ??I plan on staying a loyal customer for a long time as well as referring friends and family to NY Italian Express so they to can enjoy some amazing Italian pasta and baked dinners as well as their amazing New York style pizza. Next time I’ll snap some photos before eating. Until then, I look forward to enjoying another amazing meal via delivery or pickup after a long stressful day and I’m not in the mood to cook. Always fast, efficient and I’ve never been disappointed in the least bit by their amazing food.
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Specialty Calzone, Fetuchinni Alfredo with Chicken and Broccoli, Baked Ziti, Large Pepperoni Pizza, Italian, Chicken Parmigiana Sub, Spaghetti with Meat Sauce, Chicken Parmigiana, Italian Sub, Italian Express