I have never had this hybrid of ice cream and Italian ice before and I really enjoyed it. It's a very tasty & interesting concept and flavor. Lots of flavors to choose from, the peanut butter chocolate was very very good.I'll be back for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice, Chocolate Chip, Cookies & Cream
Marcella M.
I really liked this location! The workers were so polite, they even came out to check on the people sitting outside to make sure we were good and didn't need anything. The inside and outside was super clean. Of course great ice cream! That's what Jeremiah's is all about. They actually had a few new combinations I haven't seen before and I had the Oreo combination. It was really good! I would definitely go back to this location for the great service and great ice cream.
Juliette L.
The whole family loves Jeremiah's! Myself, my husband and our pup! Yes, they do pup cups, vanilla ice cream or peanut butter Italian ice. Every flavor is delicious, but cookies and cream is my favorite!
Callie E.
The Jeremiah's staff is absolutely incredible. They were so nice and explained the menu so thoroughly and I brought my whole family! We enjoyed every moment of it! The music was great, and a bunch of other families were enjoying their desserts and laughing it was such a good vibe. Highly recommend this Jeremiah's. Laura, Riley, and Aiden were excellent and efficient with their service and made our experience even better! Keep up the good work Jeremiah's Maitland
brad mathews
Nice young ladies explained the choices and even gave us taste samples. It was really good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Toni Randolph
What's not to love about ice cream. Right?! ?Great Service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John M.
Jeremiah's Italian Ice is a great option for a nice little dessert. The staff is friendly and it has a cool vibe (no.pun intended, well, maybe a little pun intended). I am a fan of Italian ice and this is one of the better options. I would definitely recommend this particular Jeremiah's Italian Ice and I will give it five stars overall.
Debra S.
Took grandkids there. Server went out of way to be helpful. Cones huge and tasty. Ate in small seating area which was washable and perfect.
Jordan C.
Jeremiah's is consistent and my family and I have been enjoying their new "favorites" items. The add ons made it that much better. The team is friendly at this location and I appreciate their patience when my kids can't make up their minds. It is also nice that you have the option to stay and eat your nice cold treat inside before it melts just walking to your car (11months out of the year, thanks Florida)
An ordinary ice cream parlor with expected flavors. Suitable for a straightforward dessert.
Fairooz Haque
I had a pick up order (Gelati quart) set for 8:45 pm and it was ready when we arrived a few minutes early. Was impressed since it was a busy Friday night. Would definitely return to this location.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frances C.
This is a very busy place on a hot day! But their Italian ices and Gelatos are absolutely amazing! I bring home a quart or two, when I visit the doctor office near here! I love to be able to sample a new flavor whenever I go there, and the servers are always willing to do that! This location is kept nice and clean too! There was a long line last time that I was there, but it moved pretty quickly! Everything is always fresh and delicious! Thanks so much for reading and have a nice day!
MrsBeenAroundTown Reviewer
Edit: I happened to scroll through the reviews and I’m in disbelief! I’ve been coming here for over 6 years and I’ve never had any kind of rudeness with anyone. You can tell the owner cares about their employees and customers.Just want to shout out Anna for being the sweetest server ever! She went above and beyond for all her customers!
Melissa Padilla
Simply one of my favorite ice creams in the area! The great selection of flavors, toppings, and add ons are awesome! The sizes of the items are really good, too. The service is fast, accurate, and friendly. My favorite item so far is the gelati (combination of Italian ice and ice cream) it's a must to try in any combination that you want! You can choose a great selection of ice cream or Italian ice flavor, toppings, and ad ons that will make your dessert flavorful and will make you craving more! My favorite gelati is coconut, and my favorite ice cream flavor is vanilla, but, like I said before, you can make your own with several options of all.The ice cream is so creamy, and the Italian ice it's sooo refreshing that only one visit can't be enough! And one of the really good things to say is that it lasts longer without melts and stays cool for more time!.I really love this place!I really recommend this place 100% if you are looking for a great dessert on any day of the week!
Great taste ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have never had this hybrid of ice cream and Italian ice before and I really enjoyed it. It's a very tasty & interesting concept and flavor. Lots of flavors to choose from, the peanut butter chocolate was very very good.I'll be back for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice, Chocolate Chip, Cookies & Cream
I really liked this location! The workers were so polite, they even came out to check on the people sitting outside to make sure we were good and didn't need anything. The inside and outside was super clean. Of course great ice cream! That's what Jeremiah's is all about. They actually had a few new combinations I haven't seen before and I had the Oreo combination. It was really good! I would definitely go back to this location for the great service and great ice cream.
The whole family loves Jeremiah's! Myself, my husband and our pup! Yes, they do pup cups, vanilla ice cream or peanut butter Italian ice. Every flavor is delicious, but cookies and cream is my favorite!
The Jeremiah's staff is absolutely incredible. They were so nice and explained the menu so thoroughly and I brought my whole family! We enjoyed every moment of it! The music was great, and a bunch of other families were enjoying their desserts and laughing it was such a good vibe. Highly recommend this Jeremiah's. Laura, Riley, and Aiden were excellent and efficient with their service and made our experience even better! Keep up the good work Jeremiah's Maitland
Nice young ladies explained the choices and even gave us taste samples. It was really good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What's not to love about ice cream. Right?! ?Great Service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeremiah's Italian Ice is a great option for a nice little dessert. The staff is friendly and it has a cool vibe (no.pun intended, well, maybe a little pun intended). I am a fan of Italian ice and this is one of the better options. I would definitely recommend this particular Jeremiah's Italian Ice and I will give it five stars overall.
Took grandkids there. Server went out of way to be helpful. Cones huge and tasty. Ate in small seating area which was washable and perfect.
Jeremiah's is consistent and my family and I have been enjoying their new "favorites" items. The add ons made it that much better. The team is friendly at this location and I appreciate their patience when my kids can't make up their minds. It is also nice that you have the option to stay and eat your nice cold treat inside before it melts just walking to your car (11months out of the year, thanks Florida)
Restaurantji Recommends
An ordinary ice cream parlor with expected flavors. Suitable for a straightforward dessert.
I had a pick up order (Gelati quart) set for 8:45 pm and it was ready when we arrived a few minutes early. Was impressed since it was a busy Friday night. Would definitely return to this location.
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a very busy place on a hot day! But their Italian ices and Gelatos are absolutely amazing! I bring home a quart or two, when I visit the doctor office near here! I love to be able to sample a new flavor whenever I go there, and the servers are always willing to do that! This location is kept nice and clean too! There was a long line last time that I was there, but it moved pretty quickly! Everything is always fresh and delicious! Thanks so much for reading and have a nice day!
Edit: I happened to scroll through the reviews and I’m in disbelief! I’ve been coming here for over 6 years and I’ve never had any kind of rudeness with anyone. You can tell the owner cares about their employees and customers.Just want to shout out Anna for being the sweetest server ever! She went above and beyond for all her customers!
Simply one of my favorite ice creams in the area! The great selection of flavors, toppings, and add ons are awesome! The sizes of the items are really good, too. The service is fast, accurate, and friendly. My favorite item so far is the gelati (combination of Italian ice and ice cream) it's a must to try in any combination that you want! You can choose a great selection of ice cream or Italian ice flavor, toppings, and ad ons that will make your dessert flavorful and will make you craving more! My favorite gelati is coconut, and my favorite ice cream flavor is vanilla, but, like I said before, you can make your own with several options of all.The ice cream is so creamy, and the Italian ice it's sooo refreshing that only one visit can't be enough! And one of the really good things to say is that it lasts longer without melts and stays cool for more time!.I really love this place!I really recommend this place 100% if you are looking for a great dessert on any day of the week!