We heard that dining at Jimmy Three Fingers was an experience and have been wanting to try it. A friend, who knows the owner, happened to suggest meeting there for dinner. We are so happy that we did! We had reservations for 6:30, you must have them because it is a small place and the owner pretty much does everything himself. At 6:28, he welcomed us inside. It is like having dinner at someone's house. The food was excellent, I had the crab/shrimp cakes, and my husband and friend had the Prime Rib (which you need to order ahead of time). Everything was fresh, tasty and very reasonably priced. We will definitely be going back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Judith Kicia
Jimmy is a great host, chef, waiter., He does it all very well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cheri Bartolucci
We had the best dinner I've had since I moved here 10 years ago, Went with a few friends and everyone was pleased! My girlfriend had the prime rib said it was perfect! Kudos to Jimmy doing it all , restaurants can't find help everywhere and he's the one man band. see you soon!
Robert C.
This is NOT a restaurant. This man is NOT a chef. He serves a roast, things that come out of a crock pot and sandwiches and desserts you would give a 5 year-old.. You may get a few pieces of grilled bread. Whooooa, how interesting... Haha!!. Considering the options that there is to offer locally in the area, people will try anything at this point. But I am recommending you save your time and money. Find a real restaurant with good food, prepared in an actual restaurant grade kitchen and thoughtful service. I think most people are content with just not having to cook dinner, so they give this place a chance. The owner is a lunatic. All of the food ( " his specials " ) that he posts pictures of are from the internet and / or Pintrest. He posts pictures of food he didn't make. He's rude and knows nothing about the hospitality industry. I would love to bring in my industry professionals and give this man a taste of his own medicine. See, we know how this business works. He's a fraud. Spend your time and money elsewhere.
Marlene Woodland
Had potential of being a great meal, but there were 3 seatings today (Valentines Day). We were the last seating, and things were going downhill from the minute we came in. Had to wait for drinks til after the first course. Then salads came and ours was different from everyone else's because they ran out of spinach and almonds and another ingredient. Next we got appetizers that were descent, but can tell were lacking in sauce (escargot). Finally, after grabbing and opening ourselves the second bottle of wine we purchased, our Prime rib came out overdone (cause it was microwaved, we heard it). And our English jacket potatoes were subbed with instant mash ?. When proceeding to take dessert to go, apparently we got the end of the brownies and didn't get the raspberry creme that was advertised as well. Lesson learned. I'm sure the first two seatings Jimmy had got the finest!Update.....Thanks for the professional response. Maybe if you stick with the Menu that you advertise, and not microwave anyone's meat, everything would have been Kosher ?. And don't worry, I will not be back
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Rory Marlowe
A hidden gem!Have driven by Jimmy's more times than I could count. Finally stopped in and had a absolutely wonderful attention to detail lunch.Will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Harloff
Excellent dinnerPrime rib was perfectHighly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gerrie Gantert
I was really hoping for a great meal after reading past reviews however I was a bit disappointed. Food was good not great, we should have passed on the wine. Prime rib was not the best in town. Needed reservations not sure why we were the only couple there.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Susan Nipper
Make a dinner reservation and go hungry! Great food! We always take some home! Nice portions! Great prices! Doesn't disappoint and Jimmy does a great job! Try his soup, awesome!! Prime rib best around my husband says! We've brought a few friends and all want to go again. Every dish has been delicious!
What a great little gem in on the Treasure Coast. Some friends of mine suggested this place for a lunch meeting recently. I would have passed it had I not had the location on my GPS. It's an old(er) home that's been renovated and outfitted as a diner.The local owner is kind and attentive. He told us he bought the place from his parents 17 years ago (I think) and has been running it ever since. It has a true diner feel to it and the prices are great. He indicated he may have to close because the rent is going to skyrocket.I hope that doesn't happen as it has an appeal and charm, along with quality product and service, that you don't find anywhere these days.While I don't live terribly close, when I make a visit to Sebastian, Melbourne, or Palm Bay area I will try to schedule stopping in here for a meal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beth Hartman-Sanchez
Jimmy’s is an amazing experience. The man does everything- chef, host, waiter, dishwasher! Food fantastic (we had prime rib and red snapper)extremely reasonable prices and top notch quality. He is a joy to chat with. Will be a frequent diner. Thanks Jimmy!
Sandy Rogier
Jimmy’s is reservations only but graciously served my husband and I.Food was excellent - old time Florida charm.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Debbie Boucher
Love this restaurant! Great food at a great price!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Moore
Jimmy has the best food and best prices around. You will not be disappointed. Great prime rib , pork chops and shrimp. You will not leave hungry and most likely will need a box
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Fried Shrimp Fries Slaw, Cuban Sandwich, St Louis Cut Ribs, Short Ribs Dinner Yummm
The food was awesome and the building is great!
We heard that dining at Jimmy Three Fingers was an experience and have been wanting to try it. A friend, who knows the owner, happened to suggest meeting there for dinner. We are so happy that we did! We had reservations for 6:30, you must have them because it is a small place and the owner pretty much does everything himself. At 6:28, he welcomed us inside. It is like having dinner at someone's house. The food was excellent, I had the crab/shrimp cakes, and my husband and friend had the Prime Rib (which you need to order ahead of time). Everything was fresh, tasty and very reasonably priced. We will definitely be going back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jimmy is a great host, chef, waiter., He does it all very well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had the best dinner I've had since I moved here 10 years ago, Went with a few friends and everyone was pleased! My girlfriend had the prime rib said it was perfect! Kudos to Jimmy doing it all , restaurants can't find help everywhere and he's the one man band. see you soon!
This is NOT a restaurant. This man is NOT a chef. He serves a roast, things that come out of a crock pot and sandwiches and desserts you would give a 5 year-old.. You may get a few pieces of grilled bread. Whooooa, how interesting... Haha!!. Considering the options that there is to offer locally in the area, people will try anything at this point. But I am recommending you save your time and money. Find a real restaurant with good food, prepared in an actual restaurant grade kitchen and thoughtful service. I think most people are content with just not having to cook dinner, so they give this place a chance. The owner is a lunatic. All of the food ( " his specials " ) that he posts pictures of are from the internet and / or Pintrest. He posts pictures of food he didn't make. He's rude and knows nothing about the hospitality industry. I would love to bring in my industry professionals and give this man a taste of his own medicine. See, we know how this business works. He's a fraud. Spend your time and money elsewhere.
Had potential of being a great meal, but there were 3 seatings today (Valentines Day). We were the last seating, and things were going downhill from the minute we came in. Had to wait for drinks til after the first course. Then salads came and ours was different from everyone else's because they ran out of spinach and almonds and another ingredient. Next we got appetizers that were descent, but can tell were lacking in sauce (escargot). Finally, after grabbing and opening ourselves the second bottle of wine we purchased, our Prime rib came out overdone (cause it was microwaved, we heard it). And our English jacket potatoes were subbed with instant mash ?. When proceeding to take dessert to go, apparently we got the end of the brownies and didn't get the raspberry creme that was advertised as well. Lesson learned. I'm sure the first two seatings Jimmy had got the finest!Update.....Thanks for the professional response. Maybe if you stick with the Menu that you advertise, and not microwave anyone's meat, everything would have been Kosher ?. And don't worry, I will not be back
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
A hidden gem!Have driven by Jimmy's more times than I could count. Finally stopped in and had a absolutely wonderful attention to detail lunch.Will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent dinnerPrime rib was perfectHighly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was really hoping for a great meal after reading past reviews however I was a bit disappointed. Food was good not great, we should have passed on the wine. Prime rib was not the best in town. Needed reservations not sure why we were the only couple there.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Make a dinner reservation and go hungry! Great food! We always take some home! Nice portions! Great prices! Doesn't disappoint and Jimmy does a great job! Try his soup, awesome!! Prime rib best around my husband says! We've brought a few friends and all want to go again. Every dish has been delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
What a great little gem in on the Treasure Coast. Some friends of mine suggested this place for a lunch meeting recently. I would have passed it had I not had the location on my GPS. It's an old(er) home that's been renovated and outfitted as a diner.The local owner is kind and attentive. He told us he bought the place from his parents 17 years ago (I think) and has been running it ever since. It has a true diner feel to it and the prices are great. He indicated he may have to close because the rent is going to skyrocket.I hope that doesn't happen as it has an appeal and charm, along with quality product and service, that you don't find anywhere these days.While I don't live terribly close, when I make a visit to Sebastian, Melbourne, or Palm Bay area I will try to schedule stopping in here for a meal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jimmy’s is an amazing experience. The man does everything- chef, host, waiter, dishwasher! Food fantastic (we had prime rib and red snapper)extremely reasonable prices and top notch quality. He is a joy to chat with. Will be a frequent diner. Thanks Jimmy!
Jimmy’s is reservations only but graciously served my husband and I.Food was excellent - old time Florida charm.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Love this restaurant! Great food at a great price!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jimmy has the best food and best prices around. You will not be disappointed. Great prime rib , pork chops and shrimp. You will not leave hungry and most likely will need a box
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jumbo Fried Shrimp Fries Slaw, Cuban Sandwich, St Louis Cut Ribs, Short Ribs Dinner Yummm