This place has changed they had the best pizza now it is horrible !!! They didn’t put any sauce or cheese on the 2 pizzas I ordered 40 bucks for nothing I asked for pineapple pizza had no sauce barely any pineapple. I also ordered white pizza it had no Alfredo sauce it was flat thin no sauce dry dry n a title bit of mozzarella horrible will never go there again. They also changed owners I was told.
Gil Araujo
Man o man I don't know what happened to this place but it's a dump now. Even IF you're lucky to not have found a hair in your pizza or your rolls like I did...you still have to contend with dirty tables, sauces that look open and old a soda machine where all the sodas tasted expired Brownies that look green...and that's on top of the fact that I ordered a pizza and got the wrong one in the wrong size and from an employee that couldn't care less.. im curious what new restaurant will take its place if this trend continues.
Nahir Cardoso
We have always orders with 5th ave Pizzeria. Pizza is amazing but I hope you never have any issue because they will blame Uber eats. Uber eats does NOT MAKE THE PIZZA. The Chocolat pizza came completely burned and when we contacted them, I was told it’s Uber eats fault to contact them. You guys lost a good client.
Bob Alexander
The steak and cheese sandwich was dry and looked artificial.
Kymora Marley
The worker named Nailah has amazing customer service , she was so kind . And has great communication skills ???? 10/10
Tee 9.
I ordered a Philly steak from here today and omg!! Which I only ordered bc they didn't have any pizza slices available. What a waste of 10$! Very miniscule amount of meat, barely there! Also raw onions and raw green peppers, with cheese melted to the bread and not the meat. They need to take this off the menu!! A two year old could make a better sandwich!
Thor Gonzalez
Hah, change the name please, it feels as if nothing is fresh here even if you order a fresh made pizza the dough feels like its been sitting for days before it was even stretched, sure quick order of a slice and a soda is a quick kids meal right? If the poor kid could chew it, only good thing you'll get here is service if there's anyone at the front, only one person seems to run the whole place, the desserts are frozen, baked, and then sat in a box for hours I got a brownie that almost chipped my tooth ?
Chrisi K.
I'm not one to write reviews, but this place is a JOKE. My husband placed an order over the phone and just went to pick it up. As he arrived and went to pay, the front desk girl (on her phone, could care less) told him the credit card machine wasn't working. She called the owner. The owner wanted to write down OUR credit card information to keep, my husband said absolutely not. Then the girl proceeded to nonchalantly tell my husband to leave the pizza since the machine isn't working and "sorry" but too bad type of deal. Pathetic. How about you have an alternative for when your credit card machine isn't working, a back up plan. Instead of making us waste our time. Will never be back. Terrible business.
Cristy M.
We love the pizza here. We have tried several and all are delicious. We especially enjoy the pizzas with catipury. The ingredients on the pizzas are always fresh and very flavorful. We have also enjoyed the guava and brigadeiro pizza. All amazing. Looking forward to my next meal here.
Kat V.
Been down here in So Flo for a long time and never found a place that can truly live up to the claim of NY style Pizza...... this place comes super close!
The presentation and flavours are outstanding! Recommend it to anyone and everyone. The pizza is so authentic and is made the true Italian way. Love this place!
Alexander Robinson
This Pizza tasted great. We got ours delivered to our hotel. It arrives quickly and it was nice and hot. It tasted great and we would definitely order from here next time we're in the area. My kid is picky. But, loved the Calzone. Got two. He had one for dinner and the other for breakfast. Fantastic environment and very friendly service. The menu was fresh and yummy. Will definitely recommend this place to friends. Fair prices and big meals. Keep up the great work.
Diane James
So as of a few days ago per the cashier, 5th Ave in under new management and it’s not for the better. Not only was the cashier not apologetic for trying to charge me $27 for 6 slices of pizza, the pizza was overcooked! It looks like they took cheese and threw it on top of old pizza... I would upload a pic if I could! Also previous owner offered bottled or fountain drinks with the special, this one does not. I guess this is one small business that doesn’t need customers. Oh well on to the next!
Micah Wall
Fantastic environment and very friendly service. The menu was fresh and yummy. Will definitely recommend this place to friends. Fair prices and big meals. Keep up the great work.
This place has changed they had the best pizza now it is horrible !!! They didn’t put any sauce or cheese on the 2 pizzas I ordered 40 bucks for nothing I asked for pineapple pizza had no sauce barely any pineapple. I also ordered white pizza it had no Alfredo sauce it was flat thin no sauce dry dry n a title bit of mozzarella horrible will never go there again. They also changed owners I was told.
Man o man I don't know what happened to this place but it's a dump now. Even IF you're lucky to not have found a hair in your pizza or your rolls like I did...you still have to contend with dirty tables, sauces that look open and old a soda machine where all the sodas tasted expired Brownies that look green...and that's on top of the fact that I ordered a pizza and got the wrong one in the wrong size and from an employee that couldn't care less.. im curious what new restaurant will take its place if this trend continues.
We have always orders with 5th ave Pizzeria. Pizza is amazing but I hope you never have any issue because they will blame Uber eats. Uber eats does NOT MAKE THE PIZZA. The Chocolat pizza came completely burned and when we contacted them, I was told it’s Uber eats fault to contact them. You guys lost a good client.
The steak and cheese sandwich was dry and looked artificial.
The worker named Nailah has amazing customer service , she was so kind . And has great communication skills ???? 10/10
I ordered a Philly steak from here today and omg!! Which I only ordered bc they didn't have any pizza slices available. What a waste of 10$! Very miniscule amount of meat, barely there! Also raw onions and raw green peppers, with cheese melted to the bread and not the meat. They need to take this off the menu!! A two year old could make a better sandwich!
Hah, change the name please, it feels as if nothing is fresh here even if you order a fresh made pizza the dough feels like its been sitting for days before it was even stretched, sure quick order of a slice and a soda is a quick kids meal right? If the poor kid could chew it, only good thing you'll get here is service if there's anyone at the front, only one person seems to run the whole place, the desserts are frozen, baked, and then sat in a box for hours I got a brownie that almost chipped my tooth ?
I'm not one to write reviews, but this place is a JOKE. My husband placed an order over the phone and just went to pick it up. As he arrived and went to pay, the front desk girl (on her phone, could care less) told him the credit card machine wasn't working. She called the owner. The owner wanted to write down OUR credit card information to keep, my husband said absolutely not. Then the girl proceeded to nonchalantly tell my husband to leave the pizza since the machine isn't working and "sorry" but too bad type of deal. Pathetic. How about you have an alternative for when your credit card machine isn't working, a back up plan. Instead of making us waste our time. Will never be back. Terrible business.
We love the pizza here. We have tried several and all are delicious. We especially enjoy the pizzas with catipury. The ingredients on the pizzas are always fresh and very flavorful. We have also enjoyed the guava and brigadeiro pizza. All amazing. Looking forward to my next meal here.
Been down here in So Flo for a long time and never found a place that can truly live up to the claim of NY style Pizza...... this place comes super close!
Restaurantji Recommends
The presentation and flavours are outstanding! Recommend it to anyone and everyone. The pizza is so authentic and is made the true Italian way. Love this place!
This Pizza tasted great. We got ours delivered to our hotel. It arrives quickly and it was nice and hot. It tasted great and we would definitely order from here next time we're in the area. My kid is picky. But, loved the Calzone. Got two. He had one for dinner and the other for breakfast. Fantastic environment and very friendly service. The menu was fresh and yummy. Will definitely recommend this place to friends. Fair prices and big meals. Keep up the great work.
So as of a few days ago per the cashier, 5th Ave in under new management and it’s not for the better. Not only was the cashier not apologetic for trying to charge me $27 for 6 slices of pizza, the pizza was overcooked! It looks like they took cheese and threw it on top of old pizza... I would upload a pic if I could! Also previous owner offered bottled or fountain drinks with the special, this one does not. I guess this is one small business that doesn’t need customers. Oh well on to the next!
Fantastic environment and very friendly service. The menu was fresh and yummy. Will definitely recommend this place to friends. Fair prices and big meals. Keep up the great work.
Ricassss pizzasss