Pizza is great however automatic 20% tip for a party of 4 means somewhat lacking service. Get the takeout pizza, calzone was great! Everyone was friendly but I was mad thirsty and couldn't get another coke.Parking: Free parking forget about itKid-friendliness: They love kids here the rowdier the better
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, White, New York Cheesesteak Pizza, Wings, House, Traditional or Extra Thin, Rollatini, New York, Italian, White Pizza, Eggplant Rollatini, Cannoli, Nypp, Nypp Stromboli, L & B Spumoni Garden Sicilian, Clam Sauce, Nonno's Chicken Rollatini
Melissa Shorey
Don’t bring kids here, they add a mandatory 20% tip. Food was nothing special, but $14 for soda and $30 for a basic pizza are over rated.
Anne-Marie
Stuart was our server..excellent service and food was beyond the extremes of fresh and tasty original homemade lasagna..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CJ Nappi
Was told about the pizza and tried it but as usual down here it was over rated and this place over priced. 30 years born and raised growing up in pizzerias in NJ/NY… tastes nothing like it lol and it’s cheaper up north. There regular food is great tho
Stacie Feuer
Stuart is the best waiter there he’s very attentive, doesn’t rush you and is always around if you need something. Very polite and makes you feel at home.
NYPP did an awesome job catering a party for me. The food was delicious and the staff was so friendly with helping me pick out the best items to help feed a crowd. I received lots of rave reviews from my guests. Thank you to the staff and the manager, Max, who was so kind. I wouldn't hesitate to cater with NYPP again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe LoBosco
Great service and a great time! Michelle was amazing and does a great job taking care of her customers!!! Looking forward to coming back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shine Bright
The pizza is pretty good all the time. But they don’t do a good job if you ask for any changes. We ordered the eggplant rolatini, and asked for “light on the sauce.” It came with absolutely no sauce and it just tasted like eggplant covered in salt.
Service: 1
Justin Romano
Michelle provided the greatest experience I have had in years!!!!!! I will be a regular as long as she is there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debra
I can't say enough how wonderful NYPP is. Our food was delicious as always but the staff is so kind and honest. I left my Gucci bag that was a Valentine's present and they safely put it away in their office overnight. The waiter from the night before remembered me and took time to look within the restaurant. I believe it may have been the manager that looked in the office. They were just as concerned with finding the bag as I was. Wonderful to see a restaurant with such honest and hard working employees.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White, Wings, House, New York, Italian, Nypp
Accommodating . Great menuKid-friendliness: Staff fun and friendly for kids. Crayons and pages.Wheelchair accessibility: Big doors , good space around tables, multiple entrances.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Italian, Garlic Bread
Ronald Casterline
I think its best pizza in Naples! My go to pizza place! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathalie Villeneuve
We were there on February 29th, 2024. Party of 6. When we made the reservation by phone, they requested a deposit of 10$ per person for a total of 60$. My brother-in-law gave them his credit card number and was charged 60$. When the time comes to pay, they bring 1 bill and I gave my credit card. The waiter comes back and tells me that my credit card was declined. My sister gives her credit card and pays the bill. Later, I went to see my credit card statement and surprisingly, the amount went through. I immediately called the restaurant and they told me that they would reimburse me. Well, till this day they didn't. My brother-in-law's deposit was not reimbursed either. We went in person today and they (with the original bill and the credit card slip from my sister) and they say that they don't see the transactions (deposit and amount declined but went through). So we paid...$194.04 twice PLUS $60.00. SOMEONE MUST HAVE PUT ALOT OF MONEY IN HIS POCKET THAT NIGHT. I will never, ever go there. Service was good and food also.UPDATE MARCH 13, 2024: we will go to see you in your restaurant and bring all proofs. Thank youUPDATE MARCH 18, 2024: I was reimbursed $ 194,04 on my credit card. My brother-in-law did not yet get reimbursed for the $ 60.00 reservation fee. Thank you.
Food: 5
Kim Muro
We just experienced one of our finest dining experiences from the time we walked in without a reservation the hostess was very friendly and accommodating. We were lucky to be seated immediately. It was a table for two outside by the entrance but was ok. Our waiter Andy was outstanding very polite and a great server. The food was amazing. The bread was delicious pasta was cooked to perfection. We will be back soon.
Pizza is great however automatic 20% tip for a party of 4 means somewhat lacking service. Get the takeout pizza, calzone was great! Everyone was friendly but I was mad thirsty and couldn't get another coke.Parking: Free parking forget about itKid-friendliness: They love kids here the rowdier the better
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, White, New York Cheesesteak Pizza, Wings, House, Traditional or Extra Thin, Rollatini, New York, Italian, White Pizza, Eggplant Rollatini, Cannoli, Nypp, Nypp Stromboli, L & B Spumoni Garden Sicilian, Clam Sauce, Nonno's Chicken Rollatini
Don’t bring kids here, they add a mandatory 20% tip. Food was nothing special, but $14 for soda and $30 for a basic pizza are over rated.
Stuart was our server..excellent service and food was beyond the extremes of fresh and tasty original homemade lasagna..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was told about the pizza and tried it but as usual down here it was over rated and this place over priced. 30 years born and raised growing up in pizzerias in NJ/NY… tastes nothing like it lol and it’s cheaper up north. There regular food is great tho
Stuart is the best waiter there he’s very attentive, doesn’t rush you and is always around if you need something. Very polite and makes you feel at home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Nypp, Nonno's Chicken Rollatini
NYPP did an awesome job catering a party for me. The food was delicious and the staff was so friendly with helping me pick out the best items to help feed a crowd. I received lots of rave reviews from my guests. Thank you to the staff and the manager, Max, who was so kind. I wouldn't hesitate to cater with NYPP again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service and a great time! Michelle was amazing and does a great job taking care of her customers!!! Looking forward to coming back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is pretty good all the time. But they don’t do a good job if you ask for any changes. We ordered the eggplant rolatini, and asked for “light on the sauce.” It came with absolutely no sauce and it just tasted like eggplant covered in salt.
Service: 1
Michelle provided the greatest experience I have had in years!!!!!! I will be a regular as long as she is there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can't say enough how wonderful NYPP is. Our food was delicious as always but the staff is so kind and honest. I left my Gucci bag that was a Valentine's present and they safely put it away in their office overnight. The waiter from the night before remembered me and took time to look within the restaurant. I believe it may have been the manager that looked in the office. They were just as concerned with finding the bag as I was. Wonderful to see a restaurant with such honest and hard working employees.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White, Wings, House, New York, Italian, Nypp
Restaurantji Recommends
Accommodating . Great menuKid-friendliness: Staff fun and friendly for kids. Crayons and pages.Wheelchair accessibility: Big doors , good space around tables, multiple entrances.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Italian, Garlic Bread
I think its best pizza in Naples! My go to pizza place! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were there on February 29th, 2024. Party of 6. When we made the reservation by phone, they requested a deposit of 10$ per person for a total of 60$. My brother-in-law gave them his credit card number and was charged 60$. When the time comes to pay, they bring 1 bill and I gave my credit card. The waiter comes back and tells me that my credit card was declined. My sister gives her credit card and pays the bill. Later, I went to see my credit card statement and surprisingly, the amount went through. I immediately called the restaurant and they told me that they would reimburse me. Well, till this day they didn't. My brother-in-law's deposit was not reimbursed either. We went in person today and they (with the original bill and the credit card slip from my sister) and they say that they don't see the transactions (deposit and amount declined but went through). So we paid...$194.04 twice PLUS $60.00. SOMEONE MUST HAVE PUT ALOT OF MONEY IN HIS POCKET THAT NIGHT. I will never, ever go there. Service was good and food also.UPDATE MARCH 13, 2024: we will go to see you in your restaurant and bring all proofs. Thank youUPDATE MARCH 18, 2024: I was reimbursed $ 194,04 on my credit card. My brother-in-law did not yet get reimbursed for the $ 60.00 reservation fee. Thank you.
Food: 5
We just experienced one of our finest dining experiences from the time we walked in without a reservation the hostess was very friendly and accommodating. We were lucky to be seated immediately. It was a table for two outside by the entrance but was ok. Our waiter Andy was outstanding very polite and a great server. The food was amazing. The bread was delicious pasta was cooked to perfection. We will be back soon.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
The Best Stuffed Artichokes in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4