47 Best Pizza Restaurants near Neptune Beach

“This was my first time trying Renna’s pizza and I’ll definitely be back to the Neptune beach location. I ordered an extra large buffalo chicken pizza and a medium pepperoni pizza both were done in about 20 minutes. Tuesday guy at the register was very friendly and the place was clean. They also have a reward card. The pizza was amazing.“

“The pizza is a treasure from my kids' childhood. We loved to ride our bikes to the original location at the corner of Atlantic and East Coast .Parking: It's a difficult bike ride for children and families because crossing A1A at Atlantic is tricky.“

“LOVE!!!!! My husband and I tried this place tonight. We were hesitant because it didn’t look busy. Upon entering we saw some families inside. We ordered a large half deluxe half pepperoni. It was the best pizza we’ve had in Jacksonville by far. Another family told us they drive 30 minutes to eat here. We were on this side of town but live 35 minutes away. We will definitely be back. This will be a new favorite place for us.“

“As a vegan, it is hard to find places with vegan pizza options and gluten-free crusts. Wild Pie checked all of the boxes and the pizza "themes" were absolutely delicious! We had the Saucy Sausage and Peppers and the Power to the Pesto. My dining companions are both meat eaters and they loved the flavors and said they would never be able to tell that it was vegan, so it's a great place to bring your non-vegan friends. In addition to the wealth of pizzas, they also had about half a dozen plant-based appetizer choices and several salads. Even the drink options, canned and from the fresh brewed containers, were all healthy and delicious. I went back again a few weeks later and had the seasonal "Let's Taco-Bout it" and it was amazing!“

“Most excellent place. I have dined here multiple times and it has always always been great. Also, if you’re a cream soda fan,like I am, they have it in 2 flavors- pineapple and vanilla. Try the spaghetti pie- you’ll be back for another. Smiles galore with your dining experience.“

“This is gotta be the absolute best pizza that I ever ate. I grew up 58 years in Pennsylvania and tried pizza from New Jersey ,New York ,Pittsburg and everywhere in between. My wife and I moved down to Jacksonville a year and a half ago and found this quaint little establishment and they serve the best pizza that we ever ate. We also had The Stromboli and a calzone and were equally epic. If you’re in the area, you have to make a point to stop very friendly owners. Just got a meat lovers pizza tonight and had a slice. It’s a six out of five.“

“If you are a local place to get a good pizza, sub, or even a beer!!!! If you are from out of town don’t wonder where. Run to D&LP you won’t believe how great their pizza, wings, subs etc are. Easily the best there is in Jax!!! 10 stars from UPS Tim.“

“15 minutes before closing, we were greeted as if it was the opening for the day. This was our first time visiting Vito’s Pizza and the young ladies who waited on us answered all of our questions, made recommendations enthusiastically and were very attentive to our needs. Vito personally came over to welcome us and express his appreciation for choosing his restaurant for dinner. Vito’s Pizza has been open for 8 years and I am angry with myself for not trying them out sooner. This will definitely not be my last visit and I surely will be telling my family and friends to check them out.“

“What a shocker . We had delivery first time from Poppy’s and the food was spectacular. We ordered $150 worth and everything was very tasty . The Risotto is the only dish that needed a littleMore flavor was the risotto. ?. But again , food was amazing !“

“The food and drinks here are unbelievable. The crème brûlée has a unique look I didn’t expect but one of the best tasting I’ve ever had, if not the best. I had the Plastic Rainbows drink which is described as a raspberry Berliner weisse, which is sour but not too sweet. Great for anyone who loves fruity flavors but not too much sweetness. The roasted garlic and Brie flatbread comes with chili infused honey and fig chutney and it seems like a dish that belongs in a five star restaurant. The roasted garlic is so smooth and buttery and the honey is such a unique flavor. The pizza is some of the best I’ve ever had in this country. The staff who work here are unbelievably friendly, they treated me like I was an old friend. This is my new favorite spot.“

“We went in for lunch today, everything was excellent. We’ve ordered and picked up before but never ate in restaurant. My husband had garlic knots, he loved them. We split a small cheese pizza (I’m from Long Island NY - that’s how you know a great Pizza) which was excellent! We will return for sure!“

“Glad we stopped in here. Visited for the first time Saturday night and had a great experience. Reese was our waiter and we couldn't have asked for a better one.Very good at communicating with us throughout the night and was knowledgeable when it came to wine. Seems to really care about making the customers have a good experience.I would definitely recommend this restaurant to friends.Thank you !“

“This is a small restaurant in a strip mall but don't let that influence you. This is a nice place serving up fresh authentic foods. We had the lasagna and the homemade sauce was great. Also had the carbonara and it was good as well. Please note the actual menu may differ from the one online but they have a good selection. We also got lucky and it was free dessert Thursday. Don't miss that. The service was great too.“

“Came here for office parties, all the food was premade and fresh right around when the party started!Vegetarian options: Veggie friendly and make anything you want - and open to dietary needs!!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free, and can individually customize your meal based on your needs!Parking: Easy to find, and spaciousKid-friendliness: Very understanding and flexible for whatever your kids need.“

“Atmosphere! The setting and the knowledgeable/hospitable staff. Stopped for a quick bite and hours later we were still having a great conversation with Sydney at the bar. As a Bourbon lover, this place was perfect and the staff made you feel like it was your home away from home. Job well done!“

“One of the very few places left that have decent prices for the quality and quantity they serve. I'm good for a Greek salad once a week from this place It's enough for 2 people. The gyros and pizza are amazing as well.I've never been disappointed here.“

“We were in the Opening of the Beach parade and stopped in for a little lunch. We ordered two pizzas and WOW were they great! Thin with a generous amount of sauce cooked on an imported fire pizza oven! Quick service and tasty food! The wings looked incredible as well! Florida Man “

“This location is customer-oriented. If something isn't right, they want to know so they can make it right. I love the availability of toppings to make my own pizza. It's definitely my favorite pizza spot!Try the new meatballs, they will make you want to go back every day.The pesto sauce and white sauce are amazing together. I can't wait to try the cheese bread.“

“I was able to visit a few years ago but I didn't leave a review. I'll come back to edit on my next visit. The food was so good! We ordered so many menu items. We did share the whole fried fish ? and we enjoyed it. I'll be back to update with pictures soon.“

“Just like the northeast! So good, thank you. My only notes are to add marinara to the garlic knots (I'd pay extra) and take the cherries off those delicious cannoli, they can stand on their own. I'm impressed by the seasonings and oils on the grandma pizza as well as how the cannoli was done, not too early so they don't get soggy. Very nice job.I'll be back! :)“

“The best service! Great pizza and yummy ranch dipping sauce. I love that you can buy pizza by the slice. They also have desserts, and cool tables with game boards on them. Another cool thing they do is small personal pizzas that kids can put together themselves at their table. Fun spot at a great location! Ice cream place right next door, and beach across the street.“

“A very cool place to get some good food. I had the chicken parm sub and it was absolutely delicious. The staff there are all very laid back and friendly. I got my meal to go but they do have a relatively small dining area and bar seating as well as a patio outdoors. Very fun place to eat or even enjoy a night out with some drinks and good food.“

“My families new favorite pizza place. Their $25 deal with two pizzas, breadsticks, and a soda is fantastic. It is also the only place I have seen around here with old world style pepperoni (the small pepperoni that crisps up). Every time I have gone there my order has been ready to go on time and the staff is very friendly. I can’t say enough good things about Marco’s. I recommend it to everyone.Parking: If you are just picking up your pizza, they have 10 minute parking right in front of the store so that you can get in and get out with ease.“

“Fabulous! Maybe the best pizza I've had in 5 years. Slices are rare these days but Biggie's are, well, BIG! Nice thin crust, NY style pizza. They also have the thicker Sicilian style, I just haven't tried that. I got a pepperoni slice and a Buffalo chicken slice. The Buffalo was out of this world. Def gonna be my fave. Wife had 2 different veggies. Loved it all“

“My wife and I went to Milanos at the Beach for our Wedding dinner today. The food was absolutely amazing. Vinny our waiter was extremely informative about the entrées he is a food connoisseur and was able to assist With choosing courses that catered around our tastebuds individually. Thank you Vennie for making our wedding dinner A rememberable experience. Thank you for being you and everything that you do for everyone.“

“Where do I even start… This facility is run like a three star Michelin restaurant. From the moment you walk in until the moment you leave you feel like family. And when you’re here you’re family. Speaking of family our server Alexa treated our party like family. She was providing eccentric Dom Toretto family vibes. RIP Paul “

“Our first time here tonight and it will not be our last!! Our waiter was so attentive!!! The white pizza was so delicious, we added several items and it was so worth it!!! Very clean and at atmosphere was very relaxing... Thank You for our first visit for us to have an amazing night out!!“

“I have been looking all over Jacksonville for good pizza and I’ve found it at Vinny’s!! The crust is a little floppier than I’d like, (should’ve ordered well done) but that sauce is out of this world, the crust flavor, fantastic, all around GREAT NY style pizza.Barstool Pizza Rating:Easy 8.8 / 10“

“The best NY style I have had in Florida. We got 2 XL pies, mozz sticks, and garlic knots.. everything is high quality NY taste. The sauce is very reminiscent of NY where we are from. Definitely choose this for your pizza if you are in town!“

“I've been eating at Phillies for somewhere near 2 decades. I will say John the bartender really sets the bar high for service and is a huge reason we keep coming back in the recent years despite it becoming more and more expensive to eat out. Love Phillies, awesome cheesesteaks, cant wait to try their massive pizza. WE MISS THE WAFFLE FRIES!“

“Good pizza overall. The reason I gave 4 stars is because I usually order a half pepperoni, half cheese pizza for my daughter and I to share. A few times it has been wrong, either all cheese no pepperoni or regular pepperoni and cheese. It's nothing I'd make a big deal about, but after delivery and tip, I'd expect better for about $30. We still order here fairly often. Good sauce and good ingredients, just communication issues.“

“Food is always great! They just started offering baked foods, including their new personal pizzas!They are delicious, reasonably priced, and the perfect size for lunch! I highly recommend you try them. The staff is super kind and helpful. They have a new prep counter where they make the pizza in front of you, which is pretty nice!I got a personal pizza with creamy garlic sauce, mushrooms, pepperoni and olives. It came out hot and delicious!“

“Love the pizza and the family, we've been going here for years! Moved to the area in 2008 and order it at least two times a month for the past 16 years! Supported them during the covid shenanigans and glad they survived. There are only a few select pizza places we go to in Jax, this is definitely one of them!“

“The pizza was GREAT. Good dough and good cheese. But customer service was significantly lacking, I felt like I was bothering the only attendant I saw there. No greeting no thank you and I saw him wiping his nose before cutting another pizza there…The atmosphere wasn’t inviting, tables weren’t set up only the menu was cool so….first time there, maybe going back but the first experience left a sour taste even though the pizza was worth it ?Dietary restrictions: Cauliflower dough and veggie pizza available“

“The pizza is quite simply the best. Their marinara sauce is amazing. However, the parking situation at this particular Domino's is tricky. A helpful male version of Karen came in while I was checking out. He proceeded to criticize me, a stranger, for how I was parked. I knew it wasn't great, but I didn't know where to park. I just grabbed my pizza and got out of there before the male Karen had a nervous breakdown. I don't do confrontations and this was not an enjoyable experience.“

“This place was in front of our Air BnB place and wanted to try it. So glad my kids and I ordered from here. The pizzas we ordered were amazing! The photos look like they’re the same pizza but they taste deliciously different, only complaint was parts of the crust was a lil burnt. Glad to be able to try this place out. We literally just walked to pick up our order, glad we did because the place was packed. Highly recommend from a visitor.“

“Atmosphere is wonderful and food is amazing. Given the amount of inflation has been on restaurant prices, the prices here were very reasonable (and better than the other Italian Restaurants we've visited).Kid-friendliness: Staff was very friendly to may slightly hyper kids and allowed us to be in a booth to help keep them contained. My 7 year old left feeling a million bucks and my toddler had a new best friend. lol“

“My husband recently surprised me with a reservation at Prati for a birthday dinner with my best friends. The staff worked closely with him to ensure the surprise went smoothly, and treated us like gold. Every experience my husband and I have had at Prati has been positive, and this time exceeded expectations. From the genuine kindness of the staff to the always incredible food (plus special birthday dessert), this was a magical night I will always cherish. Thank you to everyone at Prati!“

“LocationMayport Navy Base-near clubParkingHuge lotAtmosphereUpscale military base bowling allySeatingfor Spinz tables on either side. Good for groups, couples, singlesServiceImmediate and friendlyMenuWide selection of appetizers, burgers, wings, salad, pizzas, fountain beverages, beer/wineWe had the fish sandwich and patty melt. The fish sandwich was fried with lettuce, tomato, sauce, on a grain yummy bun. The patty melt came on texas toast with bacon/grilled onion. Super good and fillingSpecials-daily and for groups/schools, ect. SummaryAwesome food, great service, check the specials. Love this chill place!“

“Domo Domino’s is a standard in this city is far is good pizzas concerned you could be rude by the other guys but you’re always coming home to Domino’s because you know what you get service food and just all-around feel good food keep up the good workParking: You got a place to park your whipWheelchair accessibility: Very wheelchair accessible definitely concerned about our plate as wheelchair warriors“

“We had a table of 5, and everyone enjoyed their lunch! We had the salmon and burgers; loved the brocolli and steak fries. It's a self service place and we ate outside, hence the 4 stars in that area. I think all of us will be back if we come back to the area.“

“I ordered from Uber Eats and the app was being wonky. I called and they answered RIGHT AWAY! (A lost art, right?) A very polite gentleman, Gazmir, checked on my order, confirmed it was correct and noticed we didn’t have drinks. Because we were 1st time customers, he sent some for free. Our pizza was hot and very New York style. Beyond impressed!! Great pizza, outstanding service!!“

“Best customer service ever.!! Melissa was truly amazing.. I wish I could have her as an employee because she was super fast, accurate and yelling orders back as I was telling her.. she super sweet to.. although someone in front of me was a real racist jerk and the manager was right there and did nothing.. shame on you for not standing up for your employees.!! But big shout out to Melissa for being the absolute best.!! Thank you you so much for making my experience amazing.!!“

“We had one of the best servers I have ever had. Joshua S was amazing. He has one of the best personalities! He really knows how to connect with his customers and he also understands how to build a genuine connection! It’s nice to still find servers like him in the restaurant industry! He not only made our experience amazing but took the time to connect with my son for his early 17th birthday! Hope to get him again as our server the next time we come! The food is always amazing so Josh was an added bonus!!!!“

“Dear Fiver Star Team at St. Johns Location, I wanted to take a moment to express my sincere appreciation for the great service I received from your team at Five Star Pizza. From the moment I placed my order, I was impressed with the level of professionalism and courtesy displayed by your staff. The pizza was delivered promptly and was piping hot, just the way I like it. THANK YOU!!!!“

“We haven't' been to this Al's Pizza in years. Today we had a hankering for pizza so we visited during the slow hours of the day (around 5 PM ish). We ordered a 14" meat pizza, and it came out very good. Very flavorful, fresh, and hot, We had their house wine in a Merlot (just ok, but for $6.00 hard to beat). Caroline the server was great. Our only complaint was we were sitting by the windows and the window seals were filthy with crumbs, dust and hair, hard to look at (so we didn't) - other areas seemed clean. Please pay attention to cleaning details. Food and service was good, so give them a try.“

“Order here two times now. The pizza was so fresh we kept forgetting to take good pictures for reviews. We just opened it up and ate it then realized I didn't do this place justice. All my orders have also been difficult, doing half and half pizzas from deluxe and they made them correct. The crust is so light and fresh too. The only pictures I have are from my husband car to make sure the order was right. I'm a pizza addict and when I order fast food and eat something I really want I like it to be good. Marco did us right, even when they forgot something as simple as butter garlic crust they fixed it right away.“