Gave them another try because it's close to home. Ordered a plain cheese pizza. No change since the last time we tried. Pizza is ok, the crust was really good. Cheese is less than good quality, sauce is bland. We didn't have time to go to our regular place. due to having company come over. Love the sizes they offer, but not the quality. 3 is fair in regards to taste and quality. I like my pizza hot, so after my husband arrived I heated it in the oven for a few. The cheese bubbled but didn't become "gooey ", it just became a little hardened, classic sign of lower quality cheese, also the cheese was very salty. Anthony's has wonderful reviews, so I'd recommend giving them a try. I've had very good to very bad pizza this one was OK, not a fave. We will stick to Ferro's they still hold the crown in town for us.
Food: 3
Ken Brown
Everything was excellent! Great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Anthony's Salad
Brent Morgan
Horrible owner. He put his hands on me and kept our $30 bill with no food. Do not go here!!!. There are so many great Italian restaurants locally, drop this one.
Food: 3
Jon Gillerstein
Should have had them bake well pizza. Forgot to ask. My
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Lawrence Silver
I tried to order a pizza and told the girl that the last time we got our pizza there was very little sauce on it. I was told by the girl to hold on and the manager accused me of wanting to get a free pizza. I told him I just wanted to order a pizza and that I wanted to let them know I wanted sauce on my pizza. The manager was rude and arrogant . He lost a customer and they can’t afford to do that.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Michele Sweeney
Worst pizza I ever had. We picked up and brought it home. The pizza had no sauce, very little cheese and pepperoni. I suppose I should feel lucky that it wasn’t burnt but it was a driest most cardboard tasting pizza I have ever had in my life. I expected a lot more especially for $20 for a pizza.I have been here many times will never go again.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Random Googler
Website sucks. No prices. Your welcome.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
patrick timmons
JESUS LOVES THIS RESTAURANT. One of the best if not the best Italian Restaurants I have ever eaten at. Reminds me of Naples, Italy. PEACE! and ENJOY!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Aliano
We had my dads 90 th birthday party there last April with over 30 people a military color guard as well as a complete custom menu to meet our needs , the staff was amazing the atmosphere was great and even other people in the restaurant joined in on the event . We found a new home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caprese Salad
Michael Daniel
Never go here!!!!!! We order an online order last night and it said it was a 30 minute wait to pick up okay cool no problem at all. After 30 minutes we arrived and go to pick our food up. Well we get told it’s a hour and a half wait for our online order meanwhile people are being seated there. I asked the person for my money back they said no we refused. I said why the bleep our you not giving me my money back I’m not waiting a hour and a half for my food at 8pm I’ll go somewhere else. That’s when the owner came out and cussed me out of then put his hands on me waiting to fight and yelling. People seeing this walked out too. I have pictures of his flower cover hands all over my shirt and will be filing a police report too. Again do not support this guy and his business I hope he goes bankrupt horrible person and business
Uncooked pizza. Kids running the restaurant. Got told on the phone when I called in to order the pizza that "We are backed up here, you're going to have to hold on."Well I held on the phone for 7 minutes, they picked up the phone and said" are you being helped"??. I said no I'd like to place an order for a pizza. The response "you going to have to hold on because we're very busy". I told to not put me on hold, because I was already on the phone a total of 10 minutes. I ordered the pizza, showed up 20 minutes later like they told me to do, and the pizza was not ready.This place used to be phenomenal, now not so much. I guess next time I'm going to run to Walmart and get a Tombstone frozen pizza instead.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Angela Haske
Finally found an excellent Italian restaurant! Delicious Pizza, and got meatballs to go. Will definitely be back?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Olivia Begeny
We have been ordering from Anthony’s for years but ran into many issues, such as our order being wrong, taking too long, not getting our online order at all, etc, so we took a break. We then decided it was time to try them again as it’s been close to 6 months. Listen, I only write reviews if something is fantastic or something is dismally wrong, so guess where this is going. I order online and when I go to pick it up, I’m told that they have to remake my pizza because they think they gave it to someone else and to be back in 20 minutes. Just what I want to do on a Friday night, come back out to pick up a pizza. But I do. When I get there they don’t say sorry or issue some sort of credit, which really bothered me. Then I look at the pizza. It’s so severely undercooked that we are going to have to rebake it for it to be edible. I certainly did not want to go back a third time. Again, they said nothing, nor offered me any type of credit. We are done with Anthony’s. They get no more tries from us. I’m livid.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
JudoChop33
Went a little out of the way for this today, and my pie could have been better. I like to say more toss & sauce would have been the key to a good experience. 6 out 10 for a Florida
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
J L
Exceptional food and friendly, efficient service. Down to earth staff. Calamari, bread, bruschetta salad and soups all delicious.
Gave them another try because it's close to home. Ordered a plain cheese pizza. No change since the last time we tried. Pizza is ok, the crust was really good. Cheese is less than good quality, sauce is bland. We didn't have time to go to our regular place. due to having company come over. Love the sizes they offer, but not the quality. 3 is fair in regards to taste and quality. I like my pizza hot, so after my husband arrived I heated it in the oven for a few. The cheese bubbled but didn't become "gooey ", it just became a little hardened, classic sign of lower quality cheese, also the cheese was very salty. Anthony's has wonderful reviews, so I'd recommend giving them a try. I've had very good to very bad pizza this one was OK, not a fave. We will stick to Ferro's they still hold the crown in town for us.
Food: 3
Everything was excellent! Great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Anthony's Salad
Horrible owner. He put his hands on me and kept our $30 bill with no food. Do not go here!!!. There are so many great Italian restaurants locally, drop this one.
Food: 3
Should have had them bake well pizza. Forgot to ask. My
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I tried to order a pizza and told the girl that the last time we got our pizza there was very little sauce on it. I was told by the girl to hold on and the manager accused me of wanting to get a free pizza. I told him I just wanted to order a pizza and that I wanted to let them know I wanted sauce on my pizza. The manager was rude and arrogant . He lost a customer and they can’t afford to do that.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Worst pizza I ever had. We picked up and brought it home. The pizza had no sauce, very little cheese and pepperoni. I suppose I should feel lucky that it wasn’t burnt but it was a driest most cardboard tasting pizza I have ever had in my life. I expected a lot more especially for $20 for a pizza.I have been here many times will never go again.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Website sucks. No prices. Your welcome.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
JESUS LOVES THIS RESTAURANT. One of the best if not the best Italian Restaurants I have ever eaten at. Reminds me of Naples, Italy. PEACE! and ENJOY!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had my dads 90 th birthday party there last April with over 30 people a military color guard as well as a complete custom menu to meet our needs , the staff was amazing the atmosphere was great and even other people in the restaurant joined in on the event . We found a new home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caprese Salad
Never go here!!!!!! We order an online order last night and it said it was a 30 minute wait to pick up okay cool no problem at all. After 30 minutes we arrived and go to pick our food up. Well we get told it’s a hour and a half wait for our online order meanwhile people are being seated there. I asked the person for my money back they said no we refused. I said why the bleep our you not giving me my money back I’m not waiting a hour and a half for my food at 8pm I’ll go somewhere else. That’s when the owner came out and cussed me out of then put his hands on me waiting to fight and yelling. People seeing this walked out too. I have pictures of his flower cover hands all over my shirt and will be filing a police report too. Again do not support this guy and his business I hope he goes bankrupt horrible person and business
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Uncooked pizza. Kids running the restaurant. Got told on the phone when I called in to order the pizza that "We are backed up here, you're going to have to hold on."Well I held on the phone for 7 minutes, they picked up the phone and said" are you being helped"??. I said no I'd like to place an order for a pizza. The response "you going to have to hold on because we're very busy". I told to not put me on hold, because I was already on the phone a total of 10 minutes. I ordered the pizza, showed up 20 minutes later like they told me to do, and the pizza was not ready.This place used to be phenomenal, now not so much. I guess next time I'm going to run to Walmart and get a Tombstone frozen pizza instead.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Finally found an excellent Italian restaurant! Delicious Pizza, and got meatballs to go. Will definitely be back?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been ordering from Anthony’s for years but ran into many issues, such as our order being wrong, taking too long, not getting our online order at all, etc, so we took a break. We then decided it was time to try them again as it’s been close to 6 months. Listen, I only write reviews if something is fantastic or something is dismally wrong, so guess where this is going. I order online and when I go to pick it up, I’m told that they have to remake my pizza because they think they gave it to someone else and to be back in 20 minutes. Just what I want to do on a Friday night, come back out to pick up a pizza. But I do. When I get there they don’t say sorry or issue some sort of credit, which really bothered me. Then I look at the pizza. It’s so severely undercooked that we are going to have to rebake it for it to be edible. I certainly did not want to go back a third time. Again, they said nothing, nor offered me any type of credit. We are done with Anthony’s. They get no more tries from us. I’m livid.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Went a little out of the way for this today, and my pie could have been better. I like to say more toss & sauce would have been the key to a good experience. 6 out 10 for a Florida
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Exceptional food and friendly, efficient service. Down to earth staff. Calamari, bread, bruschetta salad and soups all delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Marinara Sauce