Newberry Pizza

120 SW 250th St, Newberry
(352) 472-4446

Recent Reviews

Joey Baggadonitz

This place is dirty and run down. Use to be 5 star pizza now Newberry pizza. Went in to order and just immediately left.

Cindy Steanhouse

Overpriced. Gave us someone else's pizzas.. disorganized. Pizza was ok. Disappointed

Joey Scirocco

After waiting 2 hours for a pizza and canceling it after 2 and a half hours because "they could not get a hold of there driver" I highly suggest villagios (its walk in only but atleast they are honest) in newberry compaired to this establishment.

Karen Nelson

The pizza was very good. The dining area was very casual, but the service was good.

Diana Nieves

Pizza and calzones are very, very good and flavorful, But I've been there 3 times in he last week and appear to be closed.

Amber Tillman

Amazing delicious food from a great local restaurant. Delicious pizza with very fluffy crust. We also ordered a salad that was only $6 and could feed at least two people. Highly recommend.

Hope Williams

This was the best gluten free pizza I have ever had! The crust was fairly floppy, but it's either floppy or burnt when it comes to gluten free crusts. Amazing pizza!!

Joyce Feagle

We came here for the first time tonight. The pizza was great. I have a gluten intolerant and they have cauliflower pizza crust. I had the double cheeseburger pizza and it was awesome! We had thier house red wine and it was pretty good too. My husband and son had the garlic knots and all the meats pizza. We will definitely be back. They have a pool table and juke box in the dinning room which made our dinning experience even better. We will definitely be back!

Stephanie Bolen

Love the pizza! I like the supreme but usually pick my toppings. Lasagna is amazing. They could use some new decor inside but the kids enjoy the pool table and games.

Dashry

ok pizza but since a year or2 ago orders have been taking hours used to be 45 minutes today we orders 2 large pizzas and 1 small 3 hours later they tell us they sent it to the wrong address

Kristen R.

I'd been just about everywhere around I found and drove past Newberry Pizza. Nothing fancy but it was good pizza and had some options. I don't know if it's the same number but they have new owners. Wings and pizza for sure recommend. Occasionally hidden lasagna special that is amazing. Worth a shot and they deliver all over the city.

Rich Whiteman

Ive always like to support local businesses but the experience ive had the last two times i will be using another pizza place for corporate or personnel experiences from now on the bi-racial gentlemen that works there is possibly the rudist individual that i have ever delt with i truly feel sorry for the owners of this establishment as the staff they currently have are definitely not working out

Adam Knight

Take your taste buds to Villagios’s Pizza next door and get better food. Newberry pizza failed their inspections and from the posts they create it sound like they failed basic elementary school grammar.

Brooks Thomas

I’ve been going to Newberry Pizza the past 3 years. They were my favorite pizza spot, but recently they have took a downfall. Each of the past 2 Fridays I have ordered pepperoni pizza with extra cheese. Each Friday and each pizza definitely not have extra cheese on them. I have seen their pizzas way thicker with extra cheese on them. Thanks Newberry Pizza for the time we had, but I will not be coming back.

stefanie giampaolo

pizza is AMAZING. always so fresh and delicious. all of the workers including the owners are extremely friendly and overall it’s a great experience. highly recommend if you’re looking for pizza in the newberry area!!

Load More