Papa Johns Pizza

4315 Hwy 17, Orange Park
(904) 278-7272

Recent Reviews

kordobez

From the service to the food and the waiting time I give then 5 stars.. Girl at the counter very friendly, professional and fast. About 6 months ago did not had good experience here but today it changes my mind again and will definitely come back..Didn’t take pictures of the food today… I wasn’t in a hurry to eat lol.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesesticks, Create Your Own Pizza

Bear

2 hours for a pizza delivery is unacceptable. Cold pizza yay.....

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Derek Cashaw

My wife purchased me a garlic crust pizza to watch the game Tuesday night and I have been sick with stomach pains and knots ever since. The poor quality of ingredients especially the cheese OMG public assistance quality! Gotta be cats milk or some tied to the fence cow. I can't comment on the atmosphere or service as it was ordered online and I just picked it up. I was hot just really poor ingredients!

Food: 2

Robert Bowers

I got the Philly cheese steak sandwiches,they are GOOD !

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Bolander

People are super friendly at this location.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Poppers, The Works Pizza, John

Susan Carroll Heuler

tried the Papa Bowl. Seemed like a great deal I could even ask for extra Spinach, wow. But said "bowl" which is actually square was only half full. I took a photo

Robert Hazelwood

The philly cheese steak pizza is crazy good. You would not think it would work on a pizza but this is really flavorful. There is a perfect amount of veggies and meat to cheese and the sauce is great. Try one they are good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William L.

Went back to back days. Last night the pizza was subpar. Today, it's pretty decent. There is a dorky employee there I absolutely love.

StevenLikesFood

I've ordered from this specific Papa Johns location 20+ times. I have always ordered carry-out so I cannot speak to their delivery but this is my go-to pizza spot. The pizza is almost always very cheesy, I'm always happy with the quantity of toppings, always hot, and always super fast. These people must put the pizza in the oven as soon as I place my order. I've ordered from here 20+ times and I'll order from here again.

Krystal With A K!!

This review is in regards to the new pizza bowl... It was a little dry, meaning it needed a bit more sauce. But not bad. Try checking out Marco's pizza bowls for further inspiration!!

Paladin Kang

So so delicious!! I can recommend this restaurant!!

Jon C.

Just bad all around. We love Papa J but this is the third strike for this location. It took 90 minutes for delivery (not for the first time) and the pizza looked deformed as if it wasn’t properly cook. Can’t really review the taste since we had to throw a lot of it out.

Nicholas Wolford

2020: I mean, it's papa johns.. It's good pizza, great wings.. This location is kinda weird though.. Seems like when it says they are out for delivery (I'm like 600 yards from them) it takes 45 minutes.And the whole sticker (no contact covid) that shows it hasn't been touched or opened, they only use every so often. I love papa johns, but this location is sketchy to say the least. Not sure how I feel to be honest.2021: Year later, still OK pizza, but their service is terrible.. Takes twice as long to deliver.. The app says my food is being prepared 30 minutes before it even leaves, then another 15. Delivery charge $5, doesn't go to the driver, tipped $5 for total of $24 one pizza that's $14.. ??I love Papa John's, but this location doesn't take your time or money into consideration.

Dawn Goethe

Always been a big fan but seems lately crust on regular pizza has thinned out; just dont seem to be like they used to be.

Theodore Reavis Jr

Manager didn't tell the driver come to the back where I work at had to repeat myself the address

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Load More