We got a 14" 5 topping. It was very nice. Crispy crust and fresh toppings. It's a hole in the wall... but well worth the trek. You can taste the passion of the pizza maker.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diana Deming
Went in on a whim. Great food, great service, and very cozy atmosphere. The food is made to order and it's fresh n tasty. Looking for REAL Italian, Sorbellos is quaint and authentic. Support LOCAL!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Ziti
Maureen Tobin
I am from New york and this is the Best Pizza I have had in 30 years in Florida !! Im going back tomorrow for Meatballs!! Nothing fancy 28 years in business the owner is from italy ..I am over the moon to find this place!!!
Unsanitary practices, dark lighting, bland pasta dishes, no kids menu, wrong orders and expensive for the quality.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Chris Benjamin
I ordered this through DoorDash today 2/23/24
I spent 48.50 for 2 meals and was very disappointed in the amount of oil in the dish and 3 raviolis for $19 bucks. A child’s portion of what is supposed to be chicken Marsala with angel hair pasta. This is not how you want your restaurant represented. I heard nothing but good things about this place but this was terrible.
Susan Wolfe
The food was so delicious ? I will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Robertson
Twice I tried to order dinner on door dash only to be told they're closed, although they were listed as open at the time on Google. So on Friday night 2/9 we went in person, we took an Uber and was dropped off so we could eat and get some wine. We walked in and it was completely empty. We noticed 4 or 5 dirty tables with dishes and cups etc. Suddenly a young guy walks out of the back, he was disheveled looking with uncombed hair and wrinkly street clothes. He sat us and went to get us some water. When he came back we told him we had changed our mind and we're leaving. This was on a Friday at dinner time. This is a good location. When this place closes soon, hopefully a good restaurant will take it's place.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Gwendolyn Thompson
My first time, had the Sarah's Special Excellent. We'll be returning ty Sarah.
I found a gem! Tucked away in a little strip mall off Blanding is a place called Sorbellos Authentic Sicillian...Basically, I went there just to get a pizza to go but took Sarah up on Her wine suggestion. Both the pizza and wine were delicious, but the conversation I had with Sara was priceless. I went there on a Saturday afternoon, and there really weren't too many people there, so I was taken care of right away. I realize that by writing this review, there will probably be more people there on my next visit, but, to me, it will be well worth a little longer wait to try some more of Sara's cooking. ThankYou Sara for the food, the wine, and especially the conversation!
I'm torn on this place. Visited tonight for first time, ordered tortellini, pizza, and carbonara. The food was excellent; simple salad, garlic knots (needed some salt in the dough), and all 3 mains. What left me wanting was the service, there was only 3 staff in the restaurant including the elderly lady cooking, but that was enough as there was only 1 other table occupied when we entered. The young guy that served us looked dirty and unkempt and seemed not to care about his job. We were one of 2 tables occupied at prime dinner time on Saturday. Probably worse than the service was the condition of the restaurant, maybe the dirtiest place in orange park to eat - from the chairs to the tables to the floor to the ceiling and the disgusting, nasty bathrooms this place didn't look to have been cleaned or have any attention given to the physical condition of the restaurant in a very, very long time. The food was so good, but hard to get past the bad service and nasty surroundings
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti Alla Carbonara
Michele McCollum
Absolutely the most enjoyable dinner we have had in quite a while!! It's a mom and grandson- restaurant. I can't begin to tell you how tasty this was. The portions are amazing. They make everything from scratch, and it's obvious by the taste of the food. It's a shame there is no sign that you can see from the street. I just happened to use Google maps, because we met a friend halfway for a visit. I'm so glad we did. I'll definitely be back again and again and again........
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, House
adamnerd182
GOOD: The Pizza was delicious. Slight char on the bottom, nice thick crust.BAD: The garlic knots were just not good. Dry and barely warm. I’m glad they were cheap.UGLY: Very slow. This was a Wednesday night. Maybe 10 people in the entire place. Although staff were polite, everything was ran really slow paced.Overall, the pizza was great and I’d be willing to try their other dishes.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
John
Mind blown every time I eat here. consider myself genuinely lucky to live close to this place. I would make the pilgrimage if I didn't. Astonished this place is in a strip mall in a nondescript, questionable, mostly forgettable part of planet earth. It's the stuff Anthony Bourdain (huge fan...R.I.P) became world famous extolling. You may as well be in Sicily when you eat here. And even in Sicily it would stand out. I could go on. And on. Everything is made fresh and from scratch. So they don't always have everything...which...makes...perfect sense.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Acton
Beautiful interior and atmosphere. The food was excellent. We've been neck many times!
Absolutely the best pizza ever!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We got a 14" 5 topping. It was very nice. Crispy crust and fresh toppings. It's a hole in the wall... but well worth the trek. You can taste the passion of the pizza maker.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went in on a whim. Great food, great service, and very cozy atmosphere. The food is made to order and it's fresh n tasty. Looking for REAL Italian, Sorbellos is quaint and authentic. Support LOCAL!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Ziti
I am from New york and this is the Best Pizza I have had in 30 years in Florida !! Im going back tomorrow for Meatballs!! Nothing fancy 28 years in business the owner is from italy ..I am over the moon to find this place!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Cheese Pizza
Unsanitary practices, dark lighting, bland pasta dishes, no kids menu, wrong orders and expensive for the quality.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
I ordered this through DoorDash today 2/23/24 I spent 48.50 for 2 meals and was very disappointed in the amount of oil in the dish and 3 raviolis for $19 bucks. A child’s portion of what is supposed to be chicken Marsala with angel hair pasta. This is not how you want your restaurant represented. I heard nothing but good things about this place but this was terrible.
The food was so delicious ? I will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Twice I tried to order dinner on door dash only to be told they're closed, although they were listed as open at the time on Google. So on Friday night 2/9 we went in person, we took an Uber and was dropped off so we could eat and get some wine. We walked in and it was completely empty. We noticed 4 or 5 dirty tables with dishes and cups etc. Suddenly a young guy walks out of the back, he was disheveled looking with uncombed hair and wrinkly street clothes. He sat us and went to get us some water. When he came back we told him we had changed our mind and we're leaving. This was on a Friday at dinner time. This is a good location. When this place closes soon, hopefully a good restaurant will take it's place.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
My first time, had the Sarah's Special Excellent. We'll be returning ty Sarah.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bruschetta Siciliana, Chicken Parmigiana, Lasagna
I found a gem! Tucked away in a little strip mall off Blanding is a place called Sorbellos Authentic Sicillian...Basically, I went there just to get a pizza to go but took Sarah up on Her wine suggestion. Both the pizza and wine were delicious, but the conversation I had with Sara was priceless. I went there on a Saturday afternoon, and there really weren't too many people there, so I was taken care of right away. I realize that by writing this review, there will probably be more people there on my next visit, but, to me, it will be well worth a little longer wait to try some more of Sara's cooking. ThankYou Sara for the food, the wine, and especially the conversation!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I'm torn on this place. Visited tonight for first time, ordered tortellini, pizza, and carbonara. The food was excellent; simple salad, garlic knots (needed some salt in the dough), and all 3 mains. What left me wanting was the service, there was only 3 staff in the restaurant including the elderly lady cooking, but that was enough as there was only 1 other table occupied when we entered. The young guy that served us looked dirty and unkempt and seemed not to care about his job. We were one of 2 tables occupied at prime dinner time on Saturday. Probably worse than the service was the condition of the restaurant, maybe the dirtiest place in orange park to eat - from the chairs to the tables to the floor to the ceiling and the disgusting, nasty bathrooms this place didn't look to have been cleaned or have any attention given to the physical condition of the restaurant in a very, very long time. The food was so good, but hard to get past the bad service and nasty surroundings
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti Alla Carbonara
Absolutely the most enjoyable dinner we have had in quite a while!! It's a mom and grandson- restaurant. I can't begin to tell you how tasty this was. The portions are amazing. They make everything from scratch, and it's obvious by the taste of the food. It's a shame there is no sign that you can see from the street. I just happened to use Google maps, because we met a friend halfway for a visit. I'm so glad we did. I'll definitely be back again and again and again........
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, House
GOOD: The Pizza was delicious. Slight char on the bottom, nice thick crust.BAD: The garlic knots were just not good. Dry and barely warm. I’m glad they were cheap.UGLY: Very slow. This was a Wednesday night. Maybe 10 people in the entire place. Although staff were polite, everything was ran really slow paced.Overall, the pizza was great and I’d be willing to try their other dishes.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Mind blown every time I eat here. consider myself genuinely lucky to live close to this place. I would make the pilgrimage if I didn't. Astonished this place is in a strip mall in a nondescript, questionable, mostly forgettable part of planet earth. It's the stuff Anthony Bourdain (huge fan...R.I.P) became world famous extolling. You may as well be in Sicily when you eat here. And even in Sicily it would stand out. I could go on. And on. Everything is made fresh and from scratch. So they don't always have everything...which...makes...perfect sense.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful interior and atmosphere. The food was excellent. We've been neck many times!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Fettuccine Alfredo