NY Eastlake Pizza

2525 E Lake Rd S, Palm Harbor
(727) 210-1144

Recent Reviews

Kellen Scott

Pizza was very good, especially the crust. Nice ratio of ingredients. The garlic knots were the best I've had anywhere recently. Taking 1 star off because they got one of our pizzas wrong but it still was good.

zak priestly

Gotta say.. I'm from New jersey and I'm big on pizza down here in Florida. I normally get from another pizza shop strictly. But today they were closed and I decided to try this place. There 18 inch cheese pizza hands down hit the spot. I normally don't like other places "NY style" but this place had got its pizza down. Will definitely be trying again and referring my friends and family. Also I got from uber eats and the pizza came perfect. Will definitely come in soon to try more!!

Jon M.

For a venue in a convenient store, their food is impressive. Quick & easy! Take out or delivery. Just a few tables if you are in a hurry. Get your car wash and enjoy a tasty meal.

George Shalaby

Best NY pizza in town; must try.. A+++ Customer service and test quality!Highly recommend to everyone !!!

Heather Boyd

Great NY style pizza. Called ahead to order and ate it there. They have tables inside and out. We ordered a large extra cheese. Our first time eating there we ordered a large pepperoni with extra cheese. Both times we were very pleased. It is inside the Mobil station, but don’t let that discourage you. The owner is very pleasant and helpful.

Jeannie Kendrick

I really wanted to love this place and write a great review. The man who took my order and served me when I picked it up was friendly and funny. Got 3 different kinds of burgers for us to eat while at the park. Was so confused when we arrived to pick up the order and it was a gas station (What?!?) But that wasn't the main issue. The main issue is that the burgers were terrible. At first we were encouraged by the size (trying to be Smashburger?) but as my friend said "there was nothing good about that burger". There were unidentifiable spices, no condiments, minimal cheese and an odd texture. The fries were okay though. Sounds like the pizza is good though - maybe we should have ordered it.

Caroline Hanna

The best in the Area, tasty pizza, always fresh and fast. Deliveries are super quick! Highly recommended

Drew A.

Great pizza place. I think that if you order too many toppings on a thin pizza you are asking for trouble. When I order their specials (meat lovers, white, etc.) or 2 topping pizza. Perfect! Excellent service! Never had a problem.

J H

Ordered baked Ziti, fried mushrooms and a works pizza with extra sauce, mushrooms were good, Zita was just okay but pizza had no sauce at all. Would not order again.

Linda Rousseau

So far I have only had their pizza and it was the best pizza I have ever had! Definitely going to try other items on the menu.

Anthony N.

Nov 1, 2022 I called in for a cheese steak pitza.Picked it up, went home. At home I opened the pitza. Looked old, I saw 4 little pieces of steak. There was no peppers, no onion one small piece of mushroom. I took a piece, it tasted bad. The cheese had a yellow cast, and had a chess whiz flavor. Put the rest in the fridge. War!ed up a slice the next day, and threw it out. Unedible. I called them and let them what I thought of the bad lpitza.

Cecelia P.

Get "the Works" pizza - It's great! The French fries & salads are delicious, too. Stick to the pizzas.

Joseph Loya

Shout out to them for being open when (Ian) a hurricane come cross southwest Fl - Now for the food great- N fresh. Nice staff. Thank you guys. Got a super tasty pizza and falafel sandwich. ?

Christopher Fertally

Excellent food here anytime I'm in the area I always stop and get a couple slices

Rajmond Keci

Same great crust for every slice makes us like another pizza ny style

Load More