The Rustic Oven

551 17th St W, Palmetto
(941) 405-3067

Recent Reviews

Lei Murray

I found your Rustic Oven Breads about 1 year ago. You bake without sugar and the breads are healthy and amazing!! My favorite is Sourdough.Keep up the great work, with your help you just may save us from Brain Diabetes (ALZHEIMER )Heat Disease and many other diseases. I thank you, my family thanks you and I cannot market your product enough!

Sarah Madera

Both of our pizzas and the garlic knots were delicious and the S'mores dessert was out of this world! We will definitely be repeat customers!

Jordan Bradford

Wife Talked me into a new place tonight, Boy was she right ( for once lol)ok ok shes right more than not but besides the Point!Pizza was amazingTHE MAC BOWL OMG!!And the Apple Pizza no brainer there

JJ FERRIS

Was looking for a pizza place tonight and came across their family special and thought why not?We gave it a try and WERE NOT DISSAPOINTED!Cant WAIT to go back!Will also be coming to their Grand Opening

Jordan Brower

I can say that Chris at Rustic Pizza Oven has my and my family's business for as long as hes still making pizza! Everything we’ve had has been absolutely excellent. We just had the Stuffed Pizza and ho le chit was it good! The ingredients always taste fresh and the mozzarella is real!I cant recommend this place enough!Even his homemade Garlic Pickles are phenomenal and im not even a pickle guy. Got home an hour ago and the wifes already half through the jar

Kyle Broadhurst

delicious food. best pizza in town for sure!

Amy S.

Was happy to try this local pizza place a couple weeks ago. We had carry-out. My daughter and I ordered pizza and a salad. I loved everything. The pizza crust and sauce were great. We had the rustic salad and it was a great mix. We will definitely go again.

Rhonda Knight Ramirez

Never disappointed with any of our orders. The stromboli is superb. Pizza is awesome. Definitely coming back for more.

Melody Faeizi

I passed this place on 2 separate occasions. today I made it a mission to find and stop here. Right next to the railroad tracks. I am so glad I stopped in. Got the Rustic Pizza. it was sooo good. My husband was upset we didn't get another. There is only 2 of us. this place is a hidden gem and we will be back to try more.

Brandon

Amazing food and very friendly owner

brian allyn

Toppings were pretty decent, but crust is so thin and doughy. Whole family did not like either pizza we got. If you like really thin, doughy crust, you may like it. A lot of black stuff on pizza bottom and top of pizza.

Jeremy Minor

Ordered two pizzas and both were delicious. Definitely will be back again.

Cassie M.

We ordered deliver early in the day for a 5:30pm delivery. They don't charge a delivery fee but they put an automatic 20% tip on the bill which I'm ok with. The driver arrived on time and the food was hot. The pizza was great. Exactly what I had envisioned and expected from a wood fired pizza. Thin crust with crispy edges. I would give it 4.5 stars The cheesesteak mac & cheese was ok. My husband thought it was too salty. I thought it had more of a beef stroganoff taste. I'm intrested in trying the mac & cheese by itself to see how cheesy it is. I'd say this dish is more like a 3 star dish. The last thing we ordered was a large chocolate chip cookie. I guess if you order it in the restaurant it comes in a cast-iron dish. I'd have to say this was our least favorite thing we ordered. The outside was pretty burnt and the inside was still very doughy. Now I like an under baked cookie, but this did not hit the mark. I would give this dish 2 Stars.All in all the pizza was good enough that I'd definitely give it another try , if only for the pizza.

Magdalena Jackiewicz

It took them 30 mins to bring out the food he said it will be 15 the pizza had no flavor to it smells like rotten cheese

Steven Hilberg

This place is fantastic! Best pizza I’ve had since moving to Florida 4 years ago. Brisket sandwich and steak sandwich also amazing! Great service, highly recommend!!!

Load More