Italy's Finest Pizzeria

6014 N 9th Ave, Pensacola
(850) 607-8575

Recent Reviews

Wayne Warren

Just had to have a pizza on their last day of business. It was great and they will be missed. So sad to see ' em close.

Francisca Amaya

Absolutely amazing! 10 stars! The ambiance and service is outstanding and the food is genuinely delicious. We were expecting a regular pizza place but got an amazing Italian restaurant instead. It was a pleasant surprise and we will definitely be coming back for more. Definitely recommend. We had the ziti, parmesan chicken and the new York style pizza.

Tony Peril

Nothing authentic about this place... can't even strain spaghetti inwhich caused sauce to be like water... think alot has to do with nobody wants to work

Nick Lambert

Food was amazing, service was great. Absolutely will be back❣️

Jericho Crawford

5/22/2021 - First time here. Parking lot was full however plenty of seating inside. They also have a patio area. Nice decor. Service quick and friendly. Good fresh food.

Pamela Stone

This is the best pizza in Pensacola. Their Chicago deep dish is awesome. We order from there almost once a week since we moved here from Kentucky. Expensive but worth it.

Solid TC

This place is ok, they're just not producing the quality of the food they are charging for. It's not terrible, but it's not any better than Olive Garden. You want good authentic Italian food, go to Patella's.

Mike Mound

Great place to eat ..the chicken parm sandwich is not what it could be . meatball parm is awesome and pizza is like it is in Jersey excellent .staff is great

Ashley P.

I ordered the calzone it was terrible ! The mozzarella sticks were ok but definitely not something I would expect from an restaurant.

Natasha Betts

My sons and I went to this restaurant yesterday. The server said she would be right with us. She passed us 3 more times before she asked for our drinks. I was attempting to say something and she walked away. The margarita I received was the absolute worst drink I've ever had. The spinach dip was served in a dish that was burned and it was runny like they added too much water. White dish shouldn't look like that. Presentation is everything! My son's beer was hot. Like they had just pulled it out the box and gave it to him. The food was pretty good but overall we won't be going back

Sara Gregory

I wasnt really impressed with the food. We ordered it to go so i cant really speak on the service. Not very pleased i have to hang out in the bar part of the restaurant to order to go either.

Michelle Rathmanson

The best pizza in Florida hands down. Wow. It taste a lot like northern pie.

Marie L

First time trying this place. Its pricey, ordered fried raviolis, and only got 8 small raviolis for $10.00. They were good, but wouldn't order them again for that price. Ordered a Sicilian pizza and it also was pricey but delicious! Haven't had a real Sicilian pizza for many years, and this place got it right...it was perfect! Will definitely be back in the near future. Can't wait to try other items at this place!

Nature With Mike

We ordered the Chicago style stuffed pizza. It was nothing like a stuffed pizza and nothing like the picture on the menu. It had the bottom and top crust with sauce on top but no stuffing whatsoever!! U can see it in picture. Service was slow as well, no refills where provided by server etc etc. Would not return.

Demetria G.

Our first visit. We were intrigued by the advertisement on TV. So we decided to give them a try. Clean, homey feel. The staff was nice. Appetizer of calamari was warm breading was not crispy but good flavor. So it wasn't freshly cooked. I ordered eggplant parmesan. It had a burnt soggy texture. It was barely warm and the pasta had an odd taste. I ordered shrimp alfredo. The shrimp had a "fishy" smell. They were undercooked and were spoiled. My husband had a calzone. He said it was okay but lacked flavor.

Load More