The phones aren't in service for some reason & website is overly complicated with only build your own options. Place is a scam I'd recommend others to avoid.
Matthew Reeves
12:30 on a Tuesday and they are closed,
Ryan Hopwood
I used to live by downtown Benny’s Pizza and I would go regularly and pick up the pizzas. Great menu is good so you have many selections to get if you don’t only want pizza awesome any kind of changes you want to work with you and the food is greatVegetarian options: I would have to say the same thing about dietary restrictions. If you cannot find something on the menu that will accommodate your diet. They have no problem helping just ask and they will make you a salad or anything they can to accommodate you.Dietary restrictions: As far as dietary restrictions, go if you have any issues or any, you know questions or changes that need to be made, I would talk to staff and they have no problem accommodating anyone who is a pain customerParking: It is in a plaza that has stores that are closed at late night, but midday can be some type parking so if you’re a lunch guy, I wouldn’t it might be difficult because of all the business being open but if it’s usually after sundown or after five you have no problemKid-friendliness: It is a great establishment and they welcome everybody, so yes kid friendly yes I would definitely say so. And shouldn’t be any problems like I said if you need anything, just ask staff and they’ll take care of you.Wheelchair accessibility: There was definitely plenty of room for wheelchair access. There shouldn’t be any difficulty and like I said the staff is great so if anybody needs any hands, they should have no problem helping.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: House Philly Steak Grinder, Antipasto
Andrew Menard
This place is permanently closed
Here you have it
Showed up at 2:20 on a Friday afternoon and they were closed.
Christopher Baker
Just ordered from the Slice app (white pizza). Delivery was prompt and the food was hot and fresh. The pizza was excellent from the Crust, to the toppings. I added bacon and seems I got a nice pancetta. Thank you. I think this is my new go-to pizza place. Thank you Benny's
Terrie Fraet
This is not the first time that we've eaten their food, but I had to write a review tonight.We didn't know what to have for dinner so we decided to go with the 18-in pizza special tonight ($13.96), and an antipasto...OMGGGGGGGG.If you are from New York like we are, then you'll understand when I say..... "The first bite made me think I was back in Queens New York at New Park pizza".
Joyce Eggert
The internet prices and the prices charged are different. Internet says a small vegetable and a small Benny’s pizza are $17.95 yet we were billed $18.95. The veggie pizza was soggy and barely tolerable. The Jensen Beach restaurant may be good but the one on Floresta needs to be shut down. I stopped ordering their calzones because they could never get the order right. The pizza prices are fraudulent and soggy pizza is just not worth it. Digiorno frozen pizza is better. Pretty bad that their pizza can be compared this way.
Toni Karam
Just like New York!! My favorite pizza spot. Never disappoints.
Rose Brenenson
First time trying Benny’s so I Placed an order for a plain pizza ,chicken cutlet Parmesan dinner and an eggplant Parmesan sub for delivery. I figured we would try a little bit of the basic things Everything arrived hot and most of all the food was outrageous. Everything was delicious. Thank you can’t wait to try something different next time!!
I ordered a white special pizza and salad. Very delicious..Great service. Thank you Downtown Benny's and Lily!!
Krystal Sims
awesome service and Awesome staff
Fissy Thomas
I’ve ordered a few times, once for my classroom and twice personally. They never disappoint and the BEST white pizza since I first tried one when I lived in NY. Get the extra ricotta, it’s worth it!
Lou Cipriano
We live very close to the Fort Pierce location and decided to try it. I called for pick-up but the person taking my order got confused and decided to have the pizza delivered when I was going to pick it up! When i got to the store i found out that my pizza and antipasto were delivered not to my address but to the wrong address on my street. I was charged $30 for food i never got. The kid taking my order ruined our supper.
Susan Brand
Mike the manager was super friendly and wanted us to be happy! Pizza was delish and we will be using them for delivery from now on! Thank you
The phones aren't in service for some reason & website is overly complicated with only build your own options. Place is a scam I'd recommend others to avoid.
12:30 on a Tuesday and they are closed,
I used to live by downtown Benny’s Pizza and I would go regularly and pick up the pizzas. Great menu is good so you have many selections to get if you don’t only want pizza awesome any kind of changes you want to work with you and the food is greatVegetarian options: I would have to say the same thing about dietary restrictions. If you cannot find something on the menu that will accommodate your diet. They have no problem helping just ask and they will make you a salad or anything they can to accommodate you.Dietary restrictions: As far as dietary restrictions, go if you have any issues or any, you know questions or changes that need to be made, I would talk to staff and they have no problem accommodating anyone who is a pain customerParking: It is in a plaza that has stores that are closed at late night, but midday can be some type parking so if you’re a lunch guy, I wouldn’t it might be difficult because of all the business being open but if it’s usually after sundown or after five you have no problemKid-friendliness: It is a great establishment and they welcome everybody, so yes kid friendly yes I would definitely say so. And shouldn’t be any problems like I said if you need anything, just ask staff and they’ll take care of you.Wheelchair accessibility: There was definitely plenty of room for wheelchair access. There shouldn’t be any difficulty and like I said the staff is great so if anybody needs any hands, they should have no problem helping.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: House Philly Steak Grinder, Antipasto
This place is permanently closed
Showed up at 2:20 on a Friday afternoon and they were closed.
Just ordered from the Slice app (white pizza). Delivery was prompt and the food was hot and fresh. The pizza was excellent from the Crust, to the toppings. I added bacon and seems I got a nice pancetta. Thank you. I think this is my new go-to pizza place. Thank you Benny's
This is not the first time that we've eaten their food, but I had to write a review tonight.We didn't know what to have for dinner so we decided to go with the 18-in pizza special tonight ($13.96), and an antipasto...OMGGGGGGGG.If you are from New York like we are, then you'll understand when I say..... "The first bite made me think I was back in Queens New York at New Park pizza".
The internet prices and the prices charged are different. Internet says a small vegetable and a small Benny’s pizza are $17.95 yet we were billed $18.95. The veggie pizza was soggy and barely tolerable. The Jensen Beach restaurant may be good but the one on Floresta needs to be shut down. I stopped ordering their calzones because they could never get the order right. The pizza prices are fraudulent and soggy pizza is just not worth it. Digiorno frozen pizza is better. Pretty bad that their pizza can be compared this way.
Just like New York!! My favorite pizza spot. Never disappoints.
First time trying Benny’s so I Placed an order for a plain pizza ,chicken cutlet Parmesan dinner and an eggplant Parmesan sub for delivery. I figured we would try a little bit of the basic things Everything arrived hot and most of all the food was outrageous. Everything was delicious. Thank you can’t wait to try something different next time!!
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered a white special pizza and salad. Very delicious..Great service. Thank you Downtown Benny's and Lily!!
awesome service and Awesome staff
I’ve ordered a few times, once for my classroom and twice personally. They never disappoint and the BEST white pizza since I first tried one when I lived in NY. Get the extra ricotta, it’s worth it!
We live very close to the Fort Pierce location and decided to try it. I called for pick-up but the person taking my order got confused and decided to have the pizza delivered when I was going to pick it up! When i got to the store i found out that my pizza and antipasto were delivered not to my address but to the wrong address on my street. I was charged $30 for food i never got. The kid taking my order ruined our supper.
Mike the manager was super friendly and wanted us to be happy! Pizza was delish and we will be using them for delivery from now on! Thank you