Our group of five all had a wonderful meal, but it was complemented wonderfully by the service. The young gentleman that waited on us was wonderful.
Max Ossé
Good seafood. Great service. Incredible view.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Eric Barndt
Cool place, great views! Wait staff was great, but the food was ok, save the money and go to McDonald's. The fries were nasty...hard, I could eat them. The grilled cheese pork belly was good, but not great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Melissa Czarapata
The very best experience! We had initially had an issue with getting seated but the owner overheard, stepped in and got us seated immediately. The food was wonderful and we will be back. Calamari was some of the best we’ve had. Grouper was delicious. Ask for Cindy! She’s a great waitress
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Captain's Platter
Mike Wright
Finally, a nice restaurant on our trip to PG. We had the filet and portabella dishes. Both were excellent! Tried the Old Fashioned (one smoked) and they were delightful. Finished up with homemade key lime pie, also excellent. Nice views, server/bartender was charming. Why go anywhere else? Oh yeah, because it's a little pricey. YOLO!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Reba F.
We waited 50 minutes for a table. Not worth the wait. Plus, not sure why we waited so long other than they can't get help. There were a ton of empty tables when we made the reservation and when we were seated. The food was ok, not great. I expected an upscale restaurant. This was far from that. The view was good other than the dilapidated walk way and building. Service was lacking and we were served water in plastic cups. When you spend over $80 for lunch and one alcoholic beverage, you expect more. It was way too hot, mediocre service, ok food. We are one and done. We have eaten at every restaurant at Fisherman's village, and for the price, this is our least favorite.
Scott H.
Our first time here after trying all the Fisherman's Village restaurants. Gave it shot but won't be back. Out of some of the beers on their drink menu. Slow, inattentive service. Food was average but not worth the price. One and done.
Robert “Coach” Sperling
One of the best dining experiences you will have in the great state of Florida.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Fish and Chips, Seafood Risotto, Lobster Tail, Captain's Platter
Lissa N.
3/25/24 - our food was good, but the service was even better! We we're seated in Melanie's section and she was great. Melanie patiently waited while one of us pondered the drink menu, she engaged in just the right amount of chitchat, and she instinctively brought extra napkins to the table before we could ask for them. Like I said the food was good, but she was also a big part of creating a pleasant dining experience. We would want Melanie to be our server the next time we dine at The Captain's Table.
Marcia B.
Stopped for a cocktail and some appetizers. Drew was our bartender and server and he did a fabulous job. Very personable great information -knows the menu well Enjoyed our time We will be back
Came in on a special occasion and asked host if an accommodation can be made for the guest of honor. She told us she would check and brought us to our table. We asked our server the same, we wanted an entree from the dinner menu during lunch. She said no, did not ask the kitchen or attempt to accommodate in any way. Drinks took about 15-20 minutes each round, ordering only rum and coke or espresso shots each time. When the food came, it was prepared wrong, recooked and I ate alone, was still not very good. We did finish off our night with a surprise ice-cream for our guest of honor, however she was fairly disappointed with the night overall. Bill was around 250 for our table of 5, although only 2 of us drank. Shame there was not more of an emphasis on guest experience or even general care. It could be a good restaurant. Called and left a message about my experience to the management and never received a call back. It seems they just aren't interested.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
GEORGE VAN BERNUM
Great restaurant to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Captain's Platter
Rudy Galfi
Great food and patio views are great! The restaurant is located at the end of the pier and has the best views.Parking: Get there early to find a good parking spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
jamesb4040
Absolutely impossible to contact this restaurant by phone.
Patrick Wood
There were open tables but they must have been short staffed as the service was very slow. Our food all arrived cold except for one dish. The menu looks great but unfortunately it didn’t deliver.
Our group of five all had a wonderful meal, but it was complemented wonderfully by the service. The young gentleman that waited on us was wonderful.
Good seafood. Great service. Incredible view.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Cool place, great views! Wait staff was great, but the food was ok, save the money and go to McDonald's. The fries were nasty...hard, I could eat them. The grilled cheese pork belly was good, but not great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
The very best experience! We had initially had an issue with getting seated but the owner overheard, stepped in and got us seated immediately. The food was wonderful and we will be back. Calamari was some of the best we’ve had. Grouper was delicious. Ask for Cindy! She’s a great waitress
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calamari, Captain's Platter
Finally, a nice restaurant on our trip to PG. We had the filet and portabella dishes. Both were excellent! Tried the Old Fashioned (one smoked) and they were delightful. Finished up with homemade key lime pie, also excellent. Nice views, server/bartender was charming. Why go anywhere else? Oh yeah, because it's a little pricey. YOLO!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
We waited 50 minutes for a table. Not worth the wait. Plus, not sure why we waited so long other than they can't get help. There were a ton of empty tables when we made the reservation and when we were seated. The food was ok, not great. I expected an upscale restaurant. This was far from that. The view was good other than the dilapidated walk way and building. Service was lacking and we were served water in plastic cups. When you spend over $80 for lunch and one alcoholic beverage, you expect more. It was way too hot, mediocre service, ok food. We are one and done. We have eaten at every restaurant at Fisherman's village, and for the price, this is our least favorite.
Our first time here after trying all the Fisherman's Village restaurants. Gave it shot but won't be back. Out of some of the beers on their drink menu. Slow, inattentive service. Food was average but not worth the price. One and done.
One of the best dining experiences you will have in the great state of Florida.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Fish and Chips, Seafood Risotto, Lobster Tail, Captain's Platter
3/25/24 - our food was good, but the service was even better! We we're seated in Melanie's section and she was great. Melanie patiently waited while one of us pondered the drink menu, she engaged in just the right amount of chitchat, and she instinctively brought extra napkins to the table before we could ask for them. Like I said the food was good, but she was also a big part of creating a pleasant dining experience. We would want Melanie to be our server the next time we dine at The Captain's Table.
Stopped for a cocktail and some appetizers. Drew was our bartender and server and he did a fabulous job. Very personable great information -knows the menu well Enjoyed our time We will be back
Restaurantji Recommends
Came in on a special occasion and asked host if an accommodation can be made for the guest of honor. She told us she would check and brought us to our table. We asked our server the same, we wanted an entree from the dinner menu during lunch. She said no, did not ask the kitchen or attempt to accommodate in any way. Drinks took about 15-20 minutes each round, ordering only rum and coke or espresso shots each time. When the food came, it was prepared wrong, recooked and I ate alone, was still not very good. We did finish off our night with a surprise ice-cream for our guest of honor, however she was fairly disappointed with the night overall. Bill was around 250 for our table of 5, although only 2 of us drank. Shame there was not more of an emphasis on guest experience or even general care. It could be a good restaurant. Called and left a message about my experience to the management and never received a call back. It seems they just aren't interested.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Great restaurant to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Captain's Platter
Great food and patio views are great! The restaurant is located at the end of the pier and has the best views.Parking: Get there early to find a good parking spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
Absolutely impossible to contact this restaurant by phone.
There were open tables but they must have been short staffed as the service was very slow. Our food all arrived cold except for one dish. The menu looks great but unfortunately it didn’t deliver.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1