We love their pizza. The cheese is super gooey and tastes great. It is our favorite and even though we moved from Riverview, we still drive there.
jonathan l.
The worst Stromboli, I ever ordered in my life. It was very greasy and had to throw the whole thing away. The only reason I'll give it one star is because this website forces you to leave a rating or not It would be zero stars.
Cristina S.
Been delivering to my house for literally YEARS with no issues. Go to order again & suddenly they no longer deliver. Manager picks and chooses when she's the manager and when she's just taking orders on the phone. Service and attitude is the absolute worst.
Service: 1
Jack H.
I have ordered the same pie for delivery every week for 6 years. Yes prices went up but they just changed the app to order from. No notice so points gained on the toast app for them evaporated. My usual order went from $31 to $40 over nite. Yeah I get inflation but no you're out of bounds. Good luck to you and your soon to be closing. Oh and quality has gone down as well lately imo.
Michelle B
Always the friendly atmosphere. With great quality of dough, sauce and cheese freshly made by hand with the best ingredients.
They close early just because they are tired of working so maybe call before going ??♀️
John M.
New York New York Pizza is a decent enough place to head towards if you are craving pizza and are in the Riverview, Florida area. The ambiance here is pretty much what you expect from a pizzeria. Kind of no-frills, but (at least for me), that's fine. For a pizzeria, the emphasis should be on the pizza and not some hoity-toity atmosphere. The pizza here is definitely pretty good. I am originally from New Jersey and pretty much took it for granted that great pizza was pretty much on every corner. When I moved down here to Florida back in 2001 (kind of shocking to realize that I have been down here well over twenty years, that's more than two decades), I was both shocked and more than a little dismayed to find that great pizza or even was not available on every corner. In fact, good pizza was something that you had to search for and when you found it, it was indeed a reason to celebrate, and what better way to celebrate than with a slice of pizza in hand. All in all, I would definitely recommend here.
Sean camacho
The service here could do better. Upon walking in the tables block you from further entering or dining in. I was told to wait. The cashier walked away on a phone call. I couldn't see the pizza slices in the window from the entrance. 6 employee were on their phones would look at me then get back in their phones. After noticing 3 others walk in get service from what looked like a chef behind the counter area. I left with out even ordering food . The atmosphere seemed like everyone was busy with their own thing.All I wanted to get was 2 slices to dine in and 3 extra large pizza Togo. ?♂️
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Doug Hughes
Ordered take out, I will say, that's probably the best pizza I've had in quite some time. Chicken wings in Hot Garlic were delicious.Take out only, lots of employees to get service, friendly. Amazing little pizza shop.
Good pizza and wings. Just always a hour plus wait.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tanita Montgomery
The best white pizzas by far. The lemon pepper wings are a rub instead of a heavy sauce which makes them really delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dwight M.
Stopped in for lasagne and it came with salad, and they even ask what dressing you want. They tie the bag up so you grab and go. Get home, no salad! I mean it was one thing! And they weren't even busy! That's what you get. Higher wages and lower service!
John Raises
Excellent New York style pizza! Chewy, thin crust, great cheese and toppings. We had pepperoni and a buffalo chicken pizza which everybody loved.
Best pizza in Riverview.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian, Pizza
We love their pizza. The cheese is super gooey and tastes great. It is our favorite and even though we moved from Riverview, we still drive there.
The worst Stromboli, I ever ordered in my life. It was very greasy and had to throw the whole thing away. The only reason I'll give it one star is because this website forces you to leave a rating or not It would be zero stars.
Been delivering to my house for literally YEARS with no issues. Go to order again & suddenly they no longer deliver. Manager picks and chooses when she's the manager and when she's just taking orders on the phone. Service and attitude is the absolute worst.
Service: 1
I have ordered the same pie for delivery every week for 6 years. Yes prices went up but they just changed the app to order from. No notice so points gained on the toast app for them evaporated. My usual order went from $31 to $40 over nite. Yeah I get inflation but no you're out of bounds. Good luck to you and your soon to be closing. Oh and quality has gone down as well lately imo.
Always the friendly atmosphere. With great quality of dough, sauce and cheese freshly made by hand with the best ingredients.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Florentine Pizza, Pizza
They close early just because they are tired of working so maybe call before going ??♀️
New York New York Pizza is a decent enough place to head towards if you are craving pizza and are in the Riverview, Florida area. The ambiance here is pretty much what you expect from a pizzeria. Kind of no-frills, but (at least for me), that's fine. For a pizzeria, the emphasis should be on the pizza and not some hoity-toity atmosphere. The pizza here is definitely pretty good. I am originally from New Jersey and pretty much took it for granted that great pizza was pretty much on every corner. When I moved down here to Florida back in 2001 (kind of shocking to realize that I have been down here well over twenty years, that's more than two decades), I was both shocked and more than a little dismayed to find that great pizza or even was not available on every corner. In fact, good pizza was something that you had to search for and when you found it, it was indeed a reason to celebrate, and what better way to celebrate than with a slice of pizza in hand. All in all, I would definitely recommend here.
The service here could do better. Upon walking in the tables block you from further entering or dining in. I was told to wait. The cashier walked away on a phone call. I couldn't see the pizza slices in the window from the entrance. 6 employee were on their phones would look at me then get back in their phones. After noticing 3 others walk in get service from what looked like a chef behind the counter area. I left with out even ordering food . The atmosphere seemed like everyone was busy with their own thing.All I wanted to get was 2 slices to dine in and 3 extra large pizza Togo. ?♂️
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ordered take out, I will say, that's probably the best pizza I've had in quite some time. Chicken wings in Hot Garlic were delicious.Take out only, lots of employees to get service, friendly. Amazing little pizza shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Good pizza and wings. Just always a hour plus wait.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The best white pizzas by far. The lemon pepper wings are a rub instead of a heavy sauce which makes them really delicious.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in for lasagne and it came with salad, and they even ask what dressing you want. They tie the bag up so you grab and go. Get home, no salad! I mean it was one thing! And they weren't even busy! That's what you get. Higher wages and lower service!
Excellent New York style pizza! Chewy, thin crust, great cheese and toppings. We had pepperoni and a buffalo chicken pizza which everybody loved.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
30 mins later still not complete with my
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1