Brooklyn South

1437 Central Ave, St. Petersburg
(727) 914-4967

Recent Reviews

M C

Excellent Cuban sandwich. We will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Liza Grant

Great soup and mac n cheese. A tasty selection of cheeses meats and accompaniments for sale.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mac & Cheese, Cheese & Charcuterie

Paula Pack

I love this place so much. I’ve been going here for years. And I always get the same thing… The turkey fig sandwich.It’s a really tiny spot with only a few tables inside and a few outside. Great location, amazing food, and just great vibes with the people working inside. You can’t go wrong with anything hereThe only downside is, they’re not always open and that’s really disappointing when you’re in the mood for something special and they are closed lol

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Turkey Fig

Brandon House

Had one of the best Cubans I've ever had here. Small lil mom n pop sandwich shop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 1437 Cuban Sandwich, Mac & Cheese

Miori I.

Food and service were great! In town for WWE Royal Rumble weekend. Looking for a quick bite before the show. Walked the strip, the deli aspect of the restaurant caught our attention. Fresh deli meats and cheeses available. Drinks, including beer and wine available in the side fridge. Indoor and outdoor seating. We ordered the Cuban (so good) and the Turkey Melt. It came melty and extremely flavorful. The pressed bread was the star of the show though. Warm and fluffy inside with the most satisfying light crunch on the outside. We devoured our sandwiches within minutes. Huge con: a large amount of bugs congregating on and around the inside bar table top. More than I was comfortable with. We opted to move to an outdoor table when the bugs repeatedly landed on my hand. I hope it was due to the humidity and is not a regular occurence. I would still give them another chance because food and service were stellar!

Jessica Beem

This is a group of very hardworking people who strive to put out the best food possible. Spectacular small business in St. Pete to support!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Turkey Fig Sandwich

Brittany Smith

One of the best sandwiches I’ve had in st Pete!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mackenzie M.

Have you ever had a sandwich you legit couldn't stop eating because it's so gangster? This is that place.

Louis A.

Unpleasant experience. 14 dollars for a lower mid tier turkey sandwich with extremely unappetizingly spicy cheese. Owner recommended this dish to me and did not mention once it was spicy. At a few bites and threw it out and walked out. Will not be back.

William S.

A few fingers in the photo - just for some additional context on size (these sandwiches are a small step above snack size). But more concerning is the filling between the bread: there's barely any. Honestly I don't know if I should be mad or thankful about the lack of meat. Why? Well the ciabatta roll was 10x better than the sandwich itself, despite the sandwich costing ~$13. The beef was bleh (tasted like leftovers). Hard pass. Not only is this place objectively poor value but compared to all that St Pete has to offer it's just plain bad. Maybe there are better menu options, and I'm willing to revisit to give another chance...but I'm going to need a breather from this place until such time I'm willing to venture in again. ALTERNATIVE: Bodega - heads & toes above this place and way large portions plus higher quality ingredients.

Patrick R.

Not sure how this place has such great reviews. I got the Italian. They give you like 3 slices of deli meat and charge a premium…. The bread is pretty good, it is decent quality but the value is not there at all tbh. If you’ve ever been to a good deli in Brooklyn you’ll know this shouldn’t be called Brooklyn South.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Hana

Great customer service! They were so nice to me. My sandwich was delicious I can’t wait to try more options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Turkey Fig Sandwich

John G.

One of our favorite sandwiches, cheese, and wine shop in a small store front. A few tables inside and some outside. It's hard to choose from the list because they are so good sounding and unique. This time I had the grilled 3 cheese with bacon and tomatoes. The other was the Ruben. One of the best things about the sandwiches is the bread. Fantastic!

Mark P.

Stopped here for lunch while on vacation in St. Pete. Had the Italian. It was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. If I lived in St. Pete, I'd stop here 4 times a week for lunch.

Emily Nabut

We love Brooklyn South, it has some of the best sandwiches in all of St. Pete. The crispy Ciabatta bread is pressed to perfection and the combination of flavors never disappoint. Some of our favorite sandwiches are the Italian, Rosemary Chicken, Turkey Melt and the Spaniard.Great staff as well, indoor and outdoor seating.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More