I ordered a vegetarian pizza and a gorgozola salad for 2 people for 60 dollars. The pizza toppings were uncooked and the crust was also undercooked. The salad had little cheese on it, not liked the one they are showing on their website. I am very disappointed and would not order from this place again and also I will tell other people about this experience.
Kevin Lawlor
Just take out so far and everything has been excellent. Just like NY pizza, meatballs superb, salads great.Definitely will try indoor dining
Food: 5
Donna Hewitt
Ordered a one slice white pizza with garlic...garlic was not cooked but just put on the pizza. RAWWow never will eat at this place again.
Linda Lorenz
Right off the bat I have to give this location 5 stars ALL THE WAY! When I review a place I usually don't start off by saying this.. My family and I are from New York and we are very spoiled by New York style pizza. Asaro's has given New York pizza a run for their money! I need to give a big shout out to Maria who is one of the wait staff, she not only remembers us when we are there she also remembers what we like to eat! Some of the items that are a must try... The Gorgonzola salad (awesome).. The eggplant pizza and they have wonderful white pizza for those who love white pizza. Their bread for the table always comes out fresh and warm, it's so good you don't need to put butter on it. Their zuppa di mussels in red sauce are really good for an appetizer. The rigatoni bolognese is a wonderful dinner dish. This location is a MUST TRY!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
steve magr
Best italian restaurant in Sarasota. Real New York italian food. Everything was great on the menu unbelievable. !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Geri Knortz
Pistachio crusted chicken was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Mark Ackerman
Tasty. Broad menu options. Good service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Booker Richardson
My dining experience at Asaro's Bee Ridge Pizzeria Restaurant was a satisfying one overall. The variety of pizzas we tried, including the margherita and chicken bacon ranch, were flavorful and cooked to perfection. Additionally, the large Caesar salad provided a refreshing balance to the meal.While the food certainly met expectations, I do agree that the service could use some improvement. Perhaps a bit more attentiveness and efficiency from the staff would enhance the overall dining experience. Nevertheless, the delicious food definitely makes Asaro's Bee Ridge Pizzeria Restaurant worth a visit, and with some minor adjustments in service, it could become an even more exceptional dining destination.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Meat Lover’S Pizza
adele b.
Amazing pizza every time! Crust is beautiful and yummy. Salads are great as well. We've moved from where we first found Asaro's, but we don't mind making the extra drive to indulge in this excellent pizzeria !
Royalkatrin ..
If you are hangry, do not call this restaurant for delivery service. After the worst day I've had all year I called them for comfort food delivery and they told me it would be 20 minutes. I have been craving pizza for a month, but try my best to stay away. The menu was lurking in my kitchen drawer and I couldn't resist. I ordered a pie and a few special slices to share with friends (while bragging about the place). An hour later no one showed up. Getting hangrier by the minute, I called them back and they told me they don't deliver. Looking at their website it shows they deliver. Not only do they deliver, but they actually had my address saved on file because I had food delivery from them in the past! Biggest letdown and making a crappy night even creepier. Thanks for nothing, I will never order from you again! Which sucks coz you have the best food!!!!
This is hands down the best pizza in the area that I have eaten yet. Been coming here for several years now and it's always been great! Update: still
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Pohlman
Ordered pizza and a pasta for the first time tonight. I asked for a recommendation for the pasta as I was torn between 2, the rigatoni bolognese and stuffed shells. The gentleman on the phone highly suggested rigatoni bolognese, so I went with it! HANDS DOWN THE BEST I have ever had! Sauce was rich and creamy, noodles cooked perfectly. Comes with a slice of their amazing bread and side salad, had no clue! And the PIZZA!!!! Absolutely delicious. A MUST TRY!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Mike Magello
A great Italian pizzeria. Pizza reminds me of NY pizza. Crispy and good flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mini Cannoli, Sicilian Pizza, Pizza
Jayne Feiner
What I’ve come to learn about pizza here is don’t put it a box and travel pizza meant to be eaten straight from the oven. This was the Asaro Special pie and it was amazing. We’ve had pizzas from here before but they were always take out and they just don’t hit the same once they go into a box. This was delicious and will be my go to from now on.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Salah Nasr
I had the best shrimp fra diavlo in a very long time. It is not on the menu, but the chef made it specially for me since they have muceles fra diavlo on the menu. The pasta was cooked perfectly, the shrimp was done right, and the sauce was the best, I wish I lived close by so I could go there every day. Prices are reasonable for what you get, and the service was wonderful.
I ordered a vegetarian pizza and a gorgozola salad for 2 people for 60 dollars. The pizza toppings were uncooked and the crust was also undercooked. The salad had little cheese on it, not liked the one they are showing on their website. I am very disappointed and would not order from this place again and also I will tell other people about this experience.
Just take out so far and everything has been excellent. Just like NY pizza, meatballs superb, salads great.Definitely will try indoor dining
Food: 5
Ordered a one slice white pizza with garlic...garlic was not cooked but just put on the pizza. RAWWow never will eat at this place again.
Right off the bat I have to give this location 5 stars ALL THE WAY! When I review a place I usually don't start off by saying this.. My family and I are from New York and we are very spoiled by New York style pizza. Asaro's has given New York pizza a run for their money! I need to give a big shout out to Maria who is one of the wait staff, she not only remembers us when we are there she also remembers what we like to eat! Some of the items that are a must try... The Gorgonzola salad (awesome).. The eggplant pizza and they have wonderful white pizza for those who love white pizza. Their bread for the table always comes out fresh and warm, it's so good you don't need to put butter on it. Their zuppa di mussels in red sauce are really good for an appetizer. The rigatoni bolognese is a wonderful dinner dish. This location is a MUST TRY!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best italian restaurant in Sarasota. Real New York italian food. Everything was great on the menu unbelievable. !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pistachio crusted chicken was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tasty. Broad menu options. Good service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
My dining experience at Asaro's Bee Ridge Pizzeria Restaurant was a satisfying one overall. The variety of pizzas we tried, including the margherita and chicken bacon ranch, were flavorful and cooked to perfection. Additionally, the large Caesar salad provided a refreshing balance to the meal.While the food certainly met expectations, I do agree that the service could use some improvement. Perhaps a bit more attentiveness and efficiency from the staff would enhance the overall dining experience. Nevertheless, the delicious food definitely makes Asaro's Bee Ridge Pizzeria Restaurant worth a visit, and with some minor adjustments in service, it could become an even more exceptional dining destination.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Meat Lover’S Pizza
Amazing pizza every time! Crust is beautiful and yummy. Salads are great as well. We've moved from where we first found Asaro's, but we don't mind making the extra drive to indulge in this excellent pizzeria !
If you are hangry, do not call this restaurant for delivery service. After the worst day I've had all year I called them for comfort food delivery and they told me it would be 20 minutes. I have been craving pizza for a month, but try my best to stay away. The menu was lurking in my kitchen drawer and I couldn't resist. I ordered a pie and a few special slices to share with friends (while bragging about the place). An hour later no one showed up. Getting hangrier by the minute, I called them back and they told me they don't deliver. Looking at their website it shows they deliver. Not only do they deliver, but they actually had my address saved on file because I had food delivery from them in the past! Biggest letdown and making a crappy night even creepier. Thanks for nothing, I will never order from you again! Which sucks coz you have the best food!!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
This is hands down the best pizza in the area that I have eaten yet. Been coming here for several years now and it's always been great! Update: still
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered pizza and a pasta for the first time tonight. I asked for a recommendation for the pasta as I was torn between 2, the rigatoni bolognese and stuffed shells. The gentleman on the phone highly suggested rigatoni bolognese, so I went with it! HANDS DOWN THE BEST I have ever had! Sauce was rich and creamy, noodles cooked perfectly. Comes with a slice of their amazing bread and side salad, had no clue! And the PIZZA!!!! Absolutely delicious. A MUST TRY!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
A great Italian pizzeria. Pizza reminds me of NY pizza. Crispy and good flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mini Cannoli, Sicilian Pizza, Pizza
What I’ve come to learn about pizza here is don’t put it a box and travel pizza meant to be eaten straight from the oven. This was the Asaro Special pie and it was amazing. We’ve had pizzas from here before but they were always take out and they just don’t hit the same once they go into a box. This was delicious and will be my go to from now on.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
I had the best shrimp fra diavlo in a very long time. It is not on the menu, but the chef made it specially for me since they have muceles fra diavlo on the menu. The pasta was cooked perfectly, the shrimp was done right, and the sauce was the best, I wish I lived close by so I could go there every day. Prices are reasonable for what you get, and the service was wonderful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5