Five Star Pizza

2730 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota
(941) 371-3333

Recent Reviews

P R.

THE BEST PIZZA and customer service. Our favorite is supreme with extra sauce! The get it right every time.

Google user

Philly steak pizza and the veggie pizza were good. The crust was good. We also got a chef salad and spinach \\u0026 cranberry with grilled chicken.

Lois Stogdill

Philly steak pizza and the veggie pizza were good. The crust was good. We also got a chef salad and spinach & cranberry with grilled chicken.

Melissa L.

Absolutely delicious, reasonable priced, pizza place! Called ahead and ordered carry out. Was ready quickly and staff was friendly! Best Christmas Eve dinner

Bryan P.

There's nothing bad about this place. The pizzas are big, the price is great, the taste is surprisingly really good. I was definitely pleased. It's not going to be the best pizza you've ever had but for the price and fast and very kind service it's worth every penny. Will go back again.

dong561

We have ordered from 5 star the pizza were good for couple months .Delivered The pizza I ordered on 9/9/22 Terrible .. Had to put slices on paper towels before we could eat .

John W.

My new favorite pizza place. Pizza was very good. Delivered early which is why i am commenting. When i ordered i didn't expect it to come early so i went up to pick up my children from school. Pizza delivery guy calls and i explain what has happened and apologized for his inconvenience. To my astonishment he suggested he would bring it up (about a mile away) to me in my vehicle. I was shocked he was very nice and accommodating and i received it on the side of the road versus how this would have went if it was dominoes ( been there). I have no words to describe how impressed i was with five start and the delivery guy. Give that man a raise he deserves it. Loyal customer from here on out.

Ed Payne

Excellent pizza they delivered a couple years ago at 230am. Pizza and wings were fabulous!

Cara Hobbs

I’m from NC and asked the produce guy at Publix where I should order my pizza from. He recommended Five Star to me. I ordered online (which I love) for a future delivery (2 hours later). I accidentally put in the wrong house number when I ordered. The driver (was also the manager) called me to make sure the pizza got to me. I was grateful they didn’t just take it back and say forget it bc I had already paid. The pizza and salad were delicious and the customer service was amazing! Just wanted to share a positive experience in these crazy times for restaurants!

DopaMax

The fried chicken bites were not crunchy and honestly had the texture of being frozen then reheated.The garlic parmesan wings, while clearly the highest quality item, were unfortunately ruined by too little spice and too much oil.The pizza wasn't bad. But the dough could've used some classic slight burn. So it was a bit boring in my opinion. But probably the best thing in the order.The most positive thing I can say is that the $10 gift card made the amount of food competitively priced. The pizza is truly enormous.

Christina Budzinski

Always order from door dash comes in 15 minutes pizza is hot and slaps. If you’re drunk you’ll eat the whole pizza

Stacy Black

Order all the time. Best pizza in Florida

Natasha Raines

Worst $22 I've ever spent. Hardly any cheese, burnt and inedible. I would like my money back

Joe P.

We flew in pretty late and on the way to our hotel 5 star pizza was one of few food places open. Staff was friendly and made it easy to order over the phone. We ordered a pizza, garlic bread, and their chicken wings. Very delicious. Would visit again.

Sarah C.

We did take out from Five Star for the first time. Totally impressed with the online ordering system as well as the quality of the pizza. Good ingredients and super tasty pizza. Some pizzas are painfully salty, such that they leave me feeling like I need to drink 4 gallons of water. Not so here! The right balance of savory that doesn't overwhelm but also isn't bland. I'd order here again!

Load More