The Cookie Cottage

335 Gillespie Ave, Sarasota
(941) 552-6914

Recent Reviews

Natalie Snyder

Beautiful cookies, we ordered for a showerAnd they tasted wonderful and were loved by all the guestShe does an outstanding

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shawna Smith

I had a great time decorating Christmas cookies!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Sarah Gaudette Coulter

We had so much fun at The Cookie Cottage decorating sugar cookies for Christmas. They even had a gluten free option! The frostings were a range of beautiful colors and were easy to use. Our cookies turned out great! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Cesar Rico

Great fun B-day party idea!!

Sarah Wilson

My daughter had her birthday here. The owner was very kind and helpful. She was great with the kids. The cookies and cupcakes were delicious. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelly B.

had special cow cookies made for niece's birthday. the attention to detail was amazing!!! highly recommend for special occasions. cookies taste great too

Yesenia H.

Took my son and nephew to drop in cookie decorating and they were not disappointed! She only had two car themed cookie kits but they were perfect for my boys. They decorated an apron, washed hands and then decorated cookies. Supplies were ready to go and easy to use for both my 8 and 16 year old boys. If you are looking for specific theme, call ahead a day or two.

Jen S.

Don't go in the cottage. Owner is rude and frazzled, there are no cookies to be purchased. She should keep the door locked.

angie repel

We had the pleasure of choosing Cookie Cottage to provide sugar cookies as favors for our wedding, and we couldn't have been happier with our decision. Cookie Cottage's sweet delights not only delighted our taste buds but also added a charming and personalized touch to our special day.From the moment we saw the beautifully decorated sugar cookies from Cookie Cottage, we knew they would be the perfect wedding favors. The attention to detail in each cookie was impeccable. From delicate icing designs to intricate patterns, the cookies were a visual delight. Cookie Cottage's talent for creating stunning and customized designs truly impressed us, as they flawlessly captured the essence of our wedding theme and colors.But it wasn't just the appearance of the cookies that impressed us—the taste was equally delightful. Each bite was a burst of sweet, buttery goodness. The sugar cookies were perfectly baked, with a soft and chewy texture that melted in our mouths. The flavors were well-balanced, and the icing on top added an extra layer of sweetness without overpowering the cookie itself. It was evident that Cookie Cottage uses high-quality ingredients, as the cookies tasted fresh and homemade.The level of customization and personalization offered by Cookie Cottage was exceptional. They worked closely with us to understand our preferences and incorporated our wedding colors, monogram, and special requests into the cookie designs. The result was a beautiful assortment of cookies that truly reflected our unique style and added a personalized touch to our wedding favors. Our guests were delighted by the thoughtfulness and attention to detail.In addition to the delightful cookies, we were impressed with the professionalism and exceptional customer service provided by Cookie Cottage. They were responsive, accommodating, and attentive to our needs throughout the entire process. They worked within our timeline and ensured that the cookies were delivered on time, perfectly packaged, and ready to be displayed at our wedding. The care and attention they put into each order were evident, making the experience stress-free and enjoyable.Cookie Cottage's sugar cookies were more than just favors—they were a conversation piece and a sweet reminder of our special day. Our guests raved about the taste and presentation of the cookies, and many even asked for contact information to order cookies for their own events. The cookies from Cookie Cottage truly made our wedding memorable and left a lasting impression on our guests.We highly recommend Cookie Cottage to anyone in need of delicious and beautifully decorated sugar cookies for their wedding or any special occasion. Their creativity, attention to detail, and dedication to customer satisfaction make them stand out. Thank you, Cookie Cottage, for the sweet delights that added an extra touch of joy and sweetness to our wedding celebration.

Jacqueline Kozel

Cool place to do a birthday party or a kids craft day. Decorate cookies, cup cakes an apron

Alexis Van Cort

I love this spot. Joined a group of ladies for a class to decorate Christmas cookies. Cathy the instructor was patient & so much fun. A definite much try experience for anytime any age.

Sue Lytle

Awesome service and tasty product. I tried several local places looking for custom cookies for an event, and The Cookie Cottage is the best hands down. Owner is very personable and so nice. If you are looking for great custom cupcakes or cookies, look no further than The Cookie Cottage. You will not be disappointed! Highly recommend.

Suzanne Lytle

Great experience. Quality, tasty and professional product at great prices. Owner is very pleasant provides top notch customer service. 5 stars.

Peggy Newman

We had so much fun and enjoyed our time decorating our own Apron and Cookie Kits. Cathy is a great host and so helpful. We loved the whole experience!

Sally Klinger

What a cool place. My 10 year old grandson recently took a “class” and he loved it. The next week he was back for a stop in and decorate time. Very unique.

Load More