Be sure to that you allot at least an hour and a half of your time to reasonably enjoy this experience. We loved every minute of but had to rush through the experience as we had plans afterwards. Our waiter was extremely accommodating and made our time enjoyable!
Traveljax
Arrived early for reservation and quickly seated us. Server was great. We upgraded our meal to included lobster and filet, everything was good. Was my husband's birthday and I noted that in the reservation but it wasn't acknowledged, no big deal, but why ask if it's not acknowledged. Overall it was good, but pricey. We have been numerous times so was expected, but $175 for dinner with no alcohol is a lot.
Misty Criteser-Pecunies
Amazing service and great food
Birthday
I booked Melting Pot for my birthday because I haven't been there in years and was hoping for a nostalgic visit where I could show my best friend and boyfriend what fondue was all about (they've never been). Unfortunately, we all ended up a bit disappointed as to how the evening unfolded. It began with us arriving 5 mins before our reservation (5:30pm) and then not being sat for 20 mins even though there was only on other set of people come in after us for a table that had a reservation and they sat them immediately. After being sat, we weren't greeted for another 10mins. The server was sweet and kind and was doing her best, she let us know she was newer to the crew and we were trying to be as patient as possible, but there seemed to be some sort of flaw in the system. We were hungry and ready to go and after about 2hours we finally had the dinner portion of the meal, which meant we still had to cook it... and at that point we didn't have time or wanted to wait on dessert. I'm well aware fondue does take a considerable amount of time because you must cook your own food, but it just seemed like it took an exceptionally long time between courses. The server graciously gave us a free dessert card so we can come back and get the dessert portion of our meal that was didn't stay for. There didn't seem to be a manager or at least anyone I could tell was a manager helping them out to ease the process. Overall we were pretty bummed out by the whole thing.
The price on the open table app said $34 a person and I got charged $50 a person. Something needs updated or someone needs to figure out what prices really are! The waitress was asking us what we wanted for our meal like dippin cheese and the cooking pots. Never said once anything was an up charge. Then she didn't come back around so I can ask her why bill was $16 more a person and I had 4 people.
Wednesday Otting
Have never had a rough experience at Melting Pot until tonight. We waited 20 mins at our table without anyone coming to greet us or take a drink order. I had to go to the hostess stand (the 2 girls were sitting almost on the ground watching videos on their phones) to ask if someone was coming over. Once we put our drink order and food in, we waited 15 minutes without any drinks or even water. We had to ask another waiter if we could get water. The waitress never offered or even realized we got it from someone else. It took almost 3 hours from start to finish. We were the last people in the restaurant by the time we got the check and left. We’ve been going for almost 20 years and have never had service like this. Our waitress was nice but didn’t seem ready to take on so many tables or larger groups. She said she had been there for 2 months. It was also SUPER hot inside. I understand all the steam and hot plates but it felt like a sauna.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Kristee Crawford
Came here tonight to celebrate our two year anniversary. When we made reservations, they asked if there was any special occasion but yet we weren't told happy anniversary or anything. That was a little weird.For some reason Pete the bartender was assigned tables; in addition to making all the drinks for the entire restaurant and serving the people at the bar. He did a remarkable job multi-tasking under pressure. The drinks were fantastic and so was his attitude, but I think its messed up that management was putting so much work on one person, and although he handled it impressively, I would not want to be in his shoes. The restaurant was filled and everyone was ordering drinks including us. Pete had a great attitude, but not everyone was as patient as we were. Exceptional workers should not be rewarded with extra work. We had a great dinner but it took three hours to complete. If management is reading this please give Pete our love and recognition, and maybe even a raise. Thanks for the experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tabitha Moyer
We had a lovely time here and had such a wonderful experience. Jake was the best server we could have hoped for! He paced everything right and allowed us to have time to enjoy each meal! The food was spectacular! Some of the best food is here and we know we can count on it! Will be returning and requesting jake! Added bonus was the select parking spots for the restaurant!Parking: Free parking for the restaurant in a parking garage with the sign!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Classic, Original Chocolate Fondue
ErikaM
The Melting Pot is one of our favorite places for a special date night. We always order the Big Night Out and especially love the cheese course and salads! The cocktails are good too and the service is always super. Thanks for a nice evening.
CharB
Our server James made it a great experience!! Dessert was the best course as far as taste but the interactive nature of the dinner and our server made it a top notch birthday experience!!
STEEL - 1948 Main St
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Nutritionists, Vitamins & Supplements
Danielle
Our experience at the Melting Pot in Sarasota was fabulous! My boyfriend and I went to celebrate Valentine's Day and our server, Jake was wonderful. He made sure we understood every course and was quick to bring out the food and refresh our drinks whenever needed. Each course tasted amazing and our favorite part was definitely the chocolate fondue at the end. We will definitely be coming back to this location!
Sally Waterman
Kelsey was amazing! We will be requesting her when we come back! Food was amazing as usual!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frank Charmley
great staff!pricing is too high for what you get.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Our server excellent and knowledgeable about menu selections. While we enjoyed the cheese portion of the meal, we did not like the main entree portion as every protein that we cooked tasted the same. We are glad we tried it but do not think this concept is for us.
Eaters
Fun, delicious, and different! This turned out to be a great treat leading up to a comedy show next door at McCurdy's. What a fun night for us! The price for two was actually in line with what we've been paying elsewhere and even includes dessert. Our waitress was so helpful and lovely: she explained where to look on the menu for cooking times and really gave us the rundown so we could operate like pros. It made each course more fun. The booth was so private and romantic (hubby could actually hear for a change). Might have been nice to have warmer lighting. The variety of food was terrific - I even ate a vegetarian dinner. Food quality was great. Overall it's a great place! Give it a try!
Be sure to that you allot at least an hour and a half of your time to reasonably enjoy this experience. We loved every minute of but had to rush through the experience as we had plans afterwards. Our waiter was extremely accommodating and made our time enjoyable!
Arrived early for reservation and quickly seated us. Server was great. We upgraded our meal to included lobster and filet, everything was good. Was my husband's birthday and I noted that in the reservation but it wasn't acknowledged, no big deal, but why ask if it's not acknowledged. Overall it was good, but pricey. We have been numerous times so was expected, but $175 for dinner with no alcohol is a lot.
Amazing service and great food
I booked Melting Pot for my birthday because I haven't been there in years and was hoping for a nostalgic visit where I could show my best friend and boyfriend what fondue was all about (they've never been). Unfortunately, we all ended up a bit disappointed as to how the evening unfolded. It began with us arriving 5 mins before our reservation (5:30pm) and then not being sat for 20 mins even though there was only on other set of people come in after us for a table that had a reservation and they sat them immediately. After being sat, we weren't greeted for another 10mins. The server was sweet and kind and was doing her best, she let us know she was newer to the crew and we were trying to be as patient as possible, but there seemed to be some sort of flaw in the system. We were hungry and ready to go and after about 2hours we finally had the dinner portion of the meal, which meant we still had to cook it... and at that point we didn't have time or wanted to wait on dessert. I'm well aware fondue does take a considerable amount of time because you must cook your own food, but it just seemed like it took an exceptionally long time between courses. The server graciously gave us a free dessert card so we can come back and get the dessert portion of our meal that was didn't stay for. There didn't seem to be a manager or at least anyone I could tell was a manager helping them out to ease the process. Overall we were pretty bummed out by the whole thing.
The price on the open table app said $34 a person and I got charged $50 a person. Something needs updated or someone needs to figure out what prices really are! The waitress was asking us what we wanted for our meal like dippin cheese and the cooking pots. Never said once anything was an up charge. Then she didn't come back around so I can ask her why bill was $16 more a person and I had 4 people.
Have never had a rough experience at Melting Pot until tonight. We waited 20 mins at our table without anyone coming to greet us or take a drink order. I had to go to the hostess stand (the 2 girls were sitting almost on the ground watching videos on their phones) to ask if someone was coming over. Once we put our drink order and food in, we waited 15 minutes without any drinks or even water. We had to ask another waiter if we could get water. The waitress never offered or even realized we got it from someone else. It took almost 3 hours from start to finish. We were the last people in the restaurant by the time we got the check and left. We’ve been going for almost 20 years and have never had service like this. Our waitress was nice but didn’t seem ready to take on so many tables or larger groups. She said she had been there for 2 months. It was also SUPER hot inside. I understand all the steam and hot plates but it felt like a sauna.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Came here tonight to celebrate our two year anniversary. When we made reservations, they asked if there was any special occasion but yet we weren't told happy anniversary or anything. That was a little weird.For some reason Pete the bartender was assigned tables; in addition to making all the drinks for the entire restaurant and serving the people at the bar. He did a remarkable job multi-tasking under pressure. The drinks were fantastic and so was his attitude, but I think its messed up that management was putting so much work on one person, and although he handled it impressively, I would not want to be in his shoes. The restaurant was filled and everyone was ordering drinks including us. Pete had a great attitude, but not everyone was as patient as we were. Exceptional workers should not be rewarded with extra work. We had a great dinner but it took three hours to complete. If management is reading this please give Pete our love and recognition, and maybe even a raise. Thanks for the experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
We had a lovely time here and had such a wonderful experience. Jake was the best server we could have hoped for! He paced everything right and allowed us to have time to enjoy each meal! The food was spectacular! Some of the best food is here and we know we can count on it! Will be returning and requesting jake! Added bonus was the select parking spots for the restaurant!Parking: Free parking for the restaurant in a parking garage with the sign!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Classic, Original Chocolate Fondue
The Melting Pot is one of our favorite places for a special date night. We always order the Big Night Out and especially love the cheese course and salads! The cocktails are good too and the service is always super. Thanks for a nice evening.
Our server James made it a great experience!! Dessert was the best course as far as taste but the interactive nature of the dinner and our server made it a top notch birthday experience!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Our experience at the Melting Pot in Sarasota was fabulous! My boyfriend and I went to celebrate Valentine's Day and our server, Jake was wonderful. He made sure we understood every course and was quick to bring out the food and refresh our drinks whenever needed. Each course tasted amazing and our favorite part was definitely the chocolate fondue at the end. We will definitely be coming back to this location!
Kelsey was amazing! We will be requesting her when we come back! Food was amazing as usual!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
great staff!pricing is too high for what you get.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Our server excellent and knowledgeable about menu selections. While we enjoyed the cheese portion of the meal, we did not like the main entree portion as every protein that we cooked tasted the same. We are glad we tried it but do not think this concept is for us.
Fun, delicious, and different! This turned out to be a great treat leading up to a comedy show next door at McCurdy's. What a fun night for us! The price for two was actually in line with what we've been paying elsewhere and even includes dessert. Our waitress was so helpful and lovely: she explained where to look on the menu for cooking times and really gave us the rundown so we could operate like pros. It made each course more fun. The booth was so private and romantic (hubby could actually hear for a change). Might have been nice to have warmer lighting. The variety of food was terrific - I even ate a vegetarian dinner. Food quality was great. Overall it's a great place! Give it a try!