Tortellino Bistro

6584 Superior Ave, Sarasota
(941) 388-7174

Recent Reviews

Patty Willingmyre

The food is awesome, very authentic northern Italian. Great service. We will be back again.

Linda Marie

Very good homemade pasta dishes, owners are the best!

Lisa Bee

Hidden gem. If you like pasta, this is it. Delicious homemade pasta and sauce.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shrimp Alfredo

Katelyn Lansford

Authentic Italian food. Nice little mom and pop place with delicious food. Seriously delicious. We are from Nevada and if we come back to Sarasota we will definitely be coming back here! Homemade everything ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Shrimp Alfredo, Bread Basket

Julio Spinelli

Excelent home made food. Served by owners. Chef is the family head. Perfect and real Italian food. Just careful because only the daughter speaks English. Quite an experience! Great value for your money.Parking: Safe zone and easy to access

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carmen

Attempted to have dinner at this restaurant to celebrate Valentines Day. My husband had made reservations a week ago for two. They gave us the 7 pm slot. We arrived a bit early (15 minutes), and they offered a tiny bistro cocktail table, which could barely hold two dinner plates. We declined and said we'd rather wait for a larger table. We waited outside and came back in at 6:55 pm. when we saw a couple leave and there was an open table. The young lady said we couldn't have that table because it was reserved for four people. I mentioned that we had a reservation for 7 pm. Then the owner walked by and scolded me and waved her hands, stating we were too early. I said we were five minutes early for our 7 pm. reservation. She was very rude, so we decided not to dine at the restaurant. I told the young lady we were not going to stay. We were very disappointed as we were really looking forward to dine at this establishment. We will never return.

Kara Steiner

Incredible authentic Italian cuisine! Highly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeanette V.

Absolutely wonderfully delicious! Homemade! Fresh pasta. Fresh seafood. Fresh desserts from mama's recipe. Make reservations or you will be turned away. It's a small place with a few tables.

Veronica N.

I've been here a couple of times and the food is delicious and authentic. You really do get an Italian feel from the restaurant. It's small, it's family run, and I felt like I was right back in Italy. It has been hard for us to find genuinely good food in the area, but this place is always delicious and always great. The service is great and the chef and his wife are awesome. Definitely stop by here!! You won't regret it :)

Ronald Berg

Best Italian everParking: Parked in front

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lasagna Bolognese, Tagliatelle Bolognese, Tortellini Bolognese, Bread Basket, Lasagne

Rick N.

Such a great place! Traditional and family run. Best Italian I've had outside of Italy. Actually better than most I had in Italy. Everything we had was exceptional. Mussel were exceptional. , lasagna bolognese with spinach pasta, veal Parmesan, tortellini bolognese, etc. so good. A shame I tried other places first. This will always be my first meal anywhere near Sarasota.

Jennifer N.

This was our best Italian meal since Italy and maybe better than some of our meals while there. Family owned and run. Fantastic!!!

Vic R.

Excellent service and authentic Italian cuisine. I had the lasagna. Made to order and it was delicate light and full of flavor. We're coming back!

Dan S.

A can't miss if you are in the area. The service is one of a kind. Make sure you save room for the Lemon Pie!

Mike K.

Place lives up to its ratings. First time there and upon arrival it is small and very quiet. We were coming from Calusa brewery so we were not quiet. Bread was excellent and food was great as was the service. Had the lemon pie dessert and cannoli which were spectacular. Will go back again on next visit.

Load More