17 Best Italian Restaurants near Silver Springs

“We camped at Wilderness RV and walked over to check out the cafe and candy store and knew we had to eat. We were there for breakfast but ordered the meatloaf with mashed potatoes and gravy and fried okra. Everything was DELICIOUS! That meatloaf was truly homestyle with onions cooked into the middle. I also ordered the hit chocolate which was amazing too. Not watery but also not overly rich.“

“Never ever go to this restaurant!!! It was our first and last time there and a horrible experience from start to finish. Service was slow as hell and the food sucked. Our order was totally wrong. It took 40 minutes to get some boneless wings and a sub sandwich . And they told us the wings were buy one get one and they charged us for the extra wings . I ordered an Italian sub with no pepperoni and extra ham and salami and mayonnaise. On the menu it said lettuce and tomato on the sub. She brought me a sub with no mayonnaise no salami and pepperoni with onions piled on top of the bun and brown lettuce. My French fries were cold. Mom asked for water with lemon and the server said she had to find lemon and then she had to cut lemon and we didn't get lemon until I asked for it again when we got our food. And the crappy food was overpriced, especially for crappy food! I was about to go back there and cook our food myself . I'm pretty sure I would have done 120% better job . I should have known when there was only two customers in there besides us at High Noon. They had to delete our check and then recharge us which took another 15 minutes. So I left the amount of the check in cash on the table and I left the 69 cent tip. And if you know me you know I would never! do that. I hope she got the hint.“

“Fair Prices and Friendly Staff!!!“

“Best Peruvian dishes I ever tried out delicious , presentation, flavors, I love it“

“My wife and I tried Formaggios for the first time today and loved it. The pizza reminds me of my childhood in Queens New York. Delicious with a crust that snaps when you fold it. We can’t wait to try the other menu items. If they are as good as the pizza then I know we won’t be disappointed. Will be back soon and often.“

“Excellent food. I will certainly be back.“

“My wife and I just went there for Valentines Day 2023, this being our second time. Ordered two Chardonnays, very good wine, I need the name :). I had Mussels in Fra Diavalo sauce that was excellent. Kim had Alfredo with chicken which she said was very good. We both had salads as sides, mine with one of the best Blue Cheese dressings I have ever had in a restaurant! My wife had Ranch and said it was delicious. We topped off the evening by splitting a Tiramisu that was wonderful! Most certainly going back again!!“

“We had pizza and eggplant rollatini which were both excellent. The cheesy garlic bread was delicious! The service was great. I would definitely recommend if you are looking for good Italian food. The guy next to us got the gyro and said it was also wonderful. We will be back.“

“I was there for a men's group dinner from the NOW Church. The pasta labella was superb. Made with a blend of red sauce and cream. Bellecimo!The naked wings were some of the best I've had.I can't wait to return and maybe try the pizza.The restaurant is usually closed on Sunday, but the owner opened up special for us. Also, very friendly.“

“Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. The crust is delicious!“

“Very good bakery and Italian deli items. Family owned and operated.“

“It is by far the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life and I have put away a lot of pizza lol“

“First time having Johnny’s pizza, very tasty and reasonable priced! I’ll definitely be back. Get a side of marinara with your pizza to dip the delicious crust, so good.“

“The gentleman that took our order and so helpful and kind! We ordered to go as we just drove from Michigan and wanna relax in our hotel. They had a tv going on the other side and encouraged us to relax while pizza was being made! We prefer to shop local and we got lucky today! thanks again! ❤️“

“This is a follow up to a review I had written for a less than stellar meal I had received from Carrabas on 3/24/24. Apparently corporate followed up my review on Yelp and requested I contact Carrabas directly which I did. The next day the restaurant manager contacted me to followup They will refund my DoorDash meal and offered a meal for no charge should I want to accept that. I appreciated that they acknowledged my opinion and sought to correct my issue.“

“I had a soup and salad and they were both delicious. Soup was very hot and salad crispy I also ordered a Mojito and it was perfect! Let's just say I am a Mojito snob and very picky. We sat at the bar and the service was amazingly fast,“

“Excellent meatball sub! It was perfect!“