Papa Johns Pizza

4255 US-1 STE 15, St. Augustine
(904) 808-7272

Recent Reviews

Jim adkins

Another Great pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Crust, Pepperoni Pizza

Ash

Wow. What a disappointing order. Not only were most of the sauces missing that I paid for, but the buffalo wings looked like someone whispered the word buffalo while walking by instead of putting it on the wings. The Oreo rounds were horrible and again, had a WHISPER of Oreo. The jalapeño papa bites, wow. Supposed to be stuffed with all this yumminess. Instead, I got dough wrapped around ONE jalapeño ? it was almost comical. I will not be ordering from this papa John’s again. Worse pizza, NO ingredients, papa John’s.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

George Gati

I have tried Papa John's pizza is several states. It had always been good. So it was at this franchise's old location. However, the pizza we picked up from the new location was simply under-baked. Ate a couple of slices from it, threw the rest of it out.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

David Martinez

They gave my little 7 years old a free personal pizza, cause of his good grades in school! They made my son very happy ? and me too! Thank you pizza man! You know who you are! God bless you and your family!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Justin Falls

They have a horrible insurance service it’s always some guy that can really speak any English and don’t even know what the specials are half the time besides that the food is great Papa John’s don’t have much of an

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 3

Cj Freeman

Pizza was great. I just had to travel farther than I wanted. I had to reheat the pizza once I got home.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Perry Mc

Ordered the new sausage cheese filled stuffed crust pizza. It was the worst pizza ever. Didn’t have sauce on 2/3 of the pizza. Could have put all the sausage in the palm of my hand. Shaq should/would be embarrassed if he had seen this pizza. Will never order this again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Jason Hoffnagle

Late, undercooked, and cold. Sadly, this Papa John's is not what we are used to from PJs. Delivery was 1hr 27min vs 40-43min when ordered. All three pizzas were cold and undercooked, which is gross.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mike Onell

Ordered a pizza online. Got there and they said it wasn’t ready. So I waited 1/2 hour for them to tell me that they didn’t even have the order. I found a price for a pizza tonight online and decided to call them to make sure they got the order. I was told they don’t price match from there own website!!!! Are you kidding me? I think I will avoid this place in the future. 0-2 from the papa

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Suzan a.

I ordered over 100.00 worth of stuff from them, but it is the worst pizza and desserts ever. I won't go to papa Johns anymore! The stuff dessert was mostly dough, no filling at all and why do we have to pay for condiments? You barely put any why frosting on the desserts, so that tells me your company's doesn't care about your customers coming back or giving great review's either. You expect customer's to pay 100.00 for pizza, but where's our quality? Our special discounts for people who give you business. The other big problem with all your charges for delivery, now there's tax, delivery fee, for what?, especially if the driver doesn't get it, there not business vehicles you have to fix, plus we have to tip your driver's, ordering pizza is getting to the point of not ordering anymore. But please tell us what is the delivery fee for? I doubt you'll respond!

Brian Thomas

They have the worse delivery service they will say 30.ins but take 2

Food: 5

John Brubaker

I used to work at Papa John's and they hand toss the dough! I think it should stay in the oven for another 60 seconds, but it was fast and the service was friendly with my delivery driver.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julie

The man who is always there around lunch time during the week is amazing!! My food is always hot, fresh, and so yummy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I Johnson

Best pizza in town. Always great service.The lasagna is incredible.

Michael Firman

Domino's Large 3 topping? 8.99$Papa John's Large 3 topping? 21.98$The pizza wasn't that good. Ingredients not appropriately placed. Order a 3 topping and on one slice there was 2 pineapples. Just not good pizza for the money.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Load More