Horrible experience at this place. The employees are very rude and use inappropriate profanity out loud. Food is extremely BURNT please don’t waste your time or money. The environment inside is filthy and one of the bakers were digging in their nose with no gloves on serving pizzas. Horrible experience I will never go back.
Rick P.
Closed. No communication to staff ahead of time, so they show up to work as planned only to find things locked up. Now they say they may reopen. Yeah good luck with that. Mediocre food to begin with, and anyone who treats their staff like that will NEVER get my business.
Paul D.
I worked at a Barnaby's in 1973-1974 in Ft Lauderdale. We decided to drive up here and go to the only Barnabys still open in Florida for the nostalgia and to have lunch. The only reason this place gets 3 stars is because of that. Sit down, fill out the order form and take it up to be informed that we couldn't get chicken or anything fried. OK, back to table to fill out new form. Order sandwiches with just a pickle. Take it up to pay and are told they could do fries. So changed it to include fries and slaw and told there is no slaw. This is at 2PM ! Then go over to order drinks. The guy serving drinks is about as disinterested in the customers as he could possibly be My order comes out and my wife's order, a meatball sub, isn't there? This is while I see the people behind the beef bar just hanging out at the cashier. Tables were a mess the whole time. The only guy I saw who really looked like they cared and was working was the pizza maker. This is not a Barbabys even though it has the name. It appears to me that after 50 years the owner doesn't care anymore. They should shut it down and close if they can't operate at Barnabys standards
Ebony Smith
I used to like going here, but tonight was awful. First off the employees were walking around in the food area eating. I asked for my wings to be fried hard, they wasn't. I ordered 3 mini pizzas and they all were very salty and seemed to cook to long. Will not be going back any time soon. Need some serious adjustments.
Rhett Sean Daniels MSc
i came here for the beer-based pizza crust (which was great), but i ended up gettinf buffalo wings.in the last twenty years i forgot what good buffalo wings were... i hate places with "big" wings that seem chewy or raw,these were perfect! the best! i am so glad i came 15minutes out of my way from traveling on I-10 from Florida to California - and you should too!!!!these are,hands down,the best wings i have ever had and i will plan my next trip acrossthe country so that i can come here.dont know why four stars... insane gemhere.somehow i still ate most the pizza... and i am still craving more wings!!!!i will dream of these....
John Cone
Staff makes you feel welcome and are very helpful.Pizza was delicious.
Barbara & Jonathan Adkins
I know that costs have gone up (3 pizzas $65) but it’s a shame that the quality has suffered and correctness of the order is hardly ever right anymore. My wife really wanted me to order Pizza Hut but I insisted on Barnabys. What a MISTAKE! Sadly I have endured my last time suffering through an overpriced meal with even worse quality. There are better options these days in Tallahassee for pizza than Barnabys.Maddios, MoMo’s and even Pizza Hut blow this place away. Goodbye to a Tallahassee landmark!
Carl Warren Weathington
Barnaby's pizza is a rare find anymore. A old wood interior pizza restaurant. They have been in Tallahassee for years. I feel the food used to be better though. The old guy isn't there nagging the employees to make it the exact same every time. And that is what you used to get. But I never know if there will be to much sauce it but enough and that kind of thing but they still make a great pizza.
Brenda Olsen
Have been a huge Barnaby’s fan and customer for almost 50 years. Tonight, for the first time, we were very disappointed with the quality of the pizza. Hardly any susage on them and the flavor in the sauce has changed. The staff were less than professional and using foul language. It wil likely be my last time driving across town for what use to be a favorite. What happened to you Barnaby’s???
Chris Turner
Well I just made my last visit to what once was one of our families favorite pizza and wings place. Twice now since the “new hours” implementation, I walked in to place an order and was told that they weren’t taking any orders, even though it was 25 minutes before the closing time! All employees had a look of disgust on their faces that I could even ask. By the way it was 7:35 PM!
The cleanliness of the place has always been suspect. The quality of the food has gone downhill. Now the staff is just atrocious, rude, and overwhelmed. We were told that wings or fried chicken would be a 45 minute wait. No burgers. All that's left on that garbage menu is spaghetti and pizza.
Noah Prevost
Still the best pizza in town abd maybe in the country. Better than anything I've ever had in New York.
cvaria EX
So good! I was extremely happy with all that I ordered. Great place
Kris Maier
I'm not exactly sure what happened to the pizza at Barnaby's, but the last 2 times we have picked up, it has been pretty bad. We didn't ask for extra cheese, but the pizza had about 1/2 and inch of semi-warm cheese. As for the topping (pepperoni) it wasn't evenly distributed. I'm sad to say, I won't be going back, unless I hear something good from a reliable source. Also, the employees were arguing with each other in front of all the customers.
Nerys Mispel
Food is so good I love it I think the decor is a bit lacking but other wise its all good.
Horrible experience at this place. The employees are very rude and use inappropriate profanity out loud. Food is extremely BURNT please don’t waste your time or money. The environment inside is filthy and one of the bakers were digging in their nose with no gloves on serving pizzas. Horrible experience I will never go back.
Closed. No communication to staff ahead of time, so they show up to work as planned only to find things locked up. Now they say they may reopen. Yeah good luck with that. Mediocre food to begin with, and anyone who treats their staff like that will NEVER get my business.
I worked at a Barnaby's in 1973-1974 in Ft Lauderdale. We decided to drive up here and go to the only Barnabys still open in Florida for the nostalgia and to have lunch. The only reason this place gets 3 stars is because of that. Sit down, fill out the order form and take it up to be informed that we couldn't get chicken or anything fried. OK, back to table to fill out new form. Order sandwiches with just a pickle. Take it up to pay and are told they could do fries. So changed it to include fries and slaw and told there is no slaw. This is at 2PM ! Then go over to order drinks. The guy serving drinks is about as disinterested in the customers as he could possibly be My order comes out and my wife's order, a meatball sub, isn't there? This is while I see the people behind the beef bar just hanging out at the cashier. Tables were a mess the whole time. The only guy I saw who really looked like they cared and was working was the pizza maker. This is not a Barbabys even though it has the name. It appears to me that after 50 years the owner doesn't care anymore. They should shut it down and close if they can't operate at Barnabys standards
I used to like going here, but tonight was awful. First off the employees were walking around in the food area eating. I asked for my wings to be fried hard, they wasn't. I ordered 3 mini pizzas and they all were very salty and seemed to cook to long. Will not be going back any time soon. Need some serious adjustments.
i came here for the beer-based pizza crust (which was great), but i ended up gettinf buffalo wings.in the last twenty years i forgot what good buffalo wings were... i hate places with "big" wings that seem chewy or raw,these were perfect! the best! i am so glad i came 15minutes out of my way from traveling on I-10 from Florida to California - and you should too!!!!these are,hands down,the best wings i have ever had and i will plan my next trip acrossthe country so that i can come here.dont know why four stars... insane gemhere.somehow i still ate most the pizza... and i am still craving more wings!!!!i will dream of these....
Staff makes you feel welcome and are very helpful.Pizza was delicious.
I know that costs have gone up (3 pizzas $65) but it’s a shame that the quality has suffered and correctness of the order is hardly ever right anymore. My wife really wanted me to order Pizza Hut but I insisted on Barnabys. What a MISTAKE! Sadly I have endured my last time suffering through an overpriced meal with even worse quality. There are better options these days in Tallahassee for pizza than Barnabys.Maddios, MoMo’s and even Pizza Hut blow this place away. Goodbye to a Tallahassee landmark!
Barnaby's pizza is a rare find anymore. A old wood interior pizza restaurant. They have been in Tallahassee for years. I feel the food used to be better though. The old guy isn't there nagging the employees to make it the exact same every time. And that is what you used to get. But I never know if there will be to much sauce it but enough and that kind of thing but they still make a great pizza.
Have been a huge Barnaby’s fan and customer for almost 50 years. Tonight, for the first time, we were very disappointed with the quality of the pizza. Hardly any susage on them and the flavor in the sauce has changed. The staff were less than professional and using foul language. It wil likely be my last time driving across town for what use to be a favorite. What happened to you Barnaby’s???
Well I just made my last visit to what once was one of our families favorite pizza and wings place. Twice now since the “new hours” implementation, I walked in to place an order and was told that they weren’t taking any orders, even though it was 25 minutes before the closing time! All employees had a look of disgust on their faces that I could even ask. By the way it was 7:35 PM!
Restaurantji Recommends
The cleanliness of the place has always been suspect. The quality of the food has gone downhill. Now the staff is just atrocious, rude, and overwhelmed. We were told that wings or fried chicken would be a 45 minute wait. No burgers. All that's left on that garbage menu is spaghetti and pizza.
Still the best pizza in town abd maybe in the country. Better than anything I've ever had in New York.
So good! I was extremely happy with all that I ordered. Great place
I'm not exactly sure what happened to the pizza at Barnaby's, but the last 2 times we have picked up, it has been pretty bad. We didn't ask for extra cheese, but the pizza had about 1/2 and inch of semi-warm cheese. As for the topping (pepperoni) it wasn't evenly distributed. I'm sad to say, I won't be going back, unless I hear something good from a reliable source. Also, the employees were arguing with each other in front of all the customers.
Food is so good I love it I think the decor is a bit lacking but other wise its all good.