Ordered a cauliflower pizza online, paid for it. Went to pick it up 45 minutes later only for the girl at the counter to laugh and say "Oh, we canceled your order because we don't have any more cauliflower crust." Be careful ordering because we were charged and will take 5-7 days for a refund!!
Impress Imika
All will share with you is, "DON'T THINK THE (3)GARLIC KNOTTS COME WITH YOUR PASTA DISH, AS STATED ON THE WEBSITE." Was rudely made aware of this by a male person behind the counter. Pensacola St.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Alan Rind
The pepperoni pizza was a bit too greasy for my taste, otherwise ok.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Max Golden
It was alright, tastes fine, definitely not a Brooklyn pizza tho.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Large 1 Topping Pizza
James Duffy
Best pizza I've had in a while. Extra sauce for the win.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Narvaez
As a New Yorker I was skeptical, but there was a coupon for this place when I moved into my apartment. Their Sicilian pizza had me absolutely floored. I was drooling. Crust was thick and crispy, cheese doesn't come off all in one bite, QUALITY toppings and a GOOD amount of them. Plus they have a different deal for every day of the week AND weekends!!Also, they're the ONLY good pizza place in town that I know of that sells pizza by the slice. And the price is good on everything on their menu. I can't speak for their sandwiches or any other items, but their pizza, garlic knots, and pepperoni rolls are to die for. ❤️?
Using my credit card on Saturday November 18 I placed an order to deliver my granddaughters pizza at approximately 8:20pm. When my granddaughter called me saying she never received the pizza, I immediately called Brooklyn Pizza and spoke with a man who never identified himself to ask why. He initially said a woman named "amaris" (sp) picked up the pizza. I told him that my granddaughter nor her babysitter knew any woman by that name nor did either receive the pizza. Both had been eagerly awaiting the pizza and were sitting outside the apt and never saw the delivery. The man then said, (with a nasty attitude) "ma'am we never got any order. What was the name of the order?" I gave him my name, my daughters name. I then gave him the number of my order which I was looking at. I then asked him again "who is Amaris" because I heard you ask me initially who was a woman named "Amaris" that picked up the pizza he then said with an even nastier attitude,"ma'am I'm telling you nobody here even placed an order you need to find out door dash or whoever placed the order because we don't have a way to track orders." After researching Door Dash told me they could see the order was placed by my husband as a pick up and someone named "Amaris" picked up the order at the restaurant Brooklyn pizza. I then called Brooklyn Pizza again. This time I spoke with a woman. She told me "there are only 2 of us and none of us received the order nor did anyone pick up a pizza." I then asked her who was the other employee who sounded as a male. She then said "oh yes there's a male but he didn't receive an order and he didn't sign for a pizza." She offered to contact Door Dash & call me. After speaking with her, she said Door Dash needed to speak with my husband, and I because there was some misunderstanding. I called Door Dash again and they again said "Please contact your bank because we are showing Brooklyn Pizza made the pizza then wrote that they (Brooklyn Pizza) would deliver the pizza and did but they did not write what apt they left it nor did they state that they actually delivered or who received it. Please call your bank immediately." We then called Brooklyn Pizza. A man, the same man I spoke to the first time, answered and immediately he was nastier... indifferent as he again repeated "we never received an order...while, "yes we got other orders but none of them using your name...none of the orders we got even sounded like a order you made so I don't know what to tell you. Call Door then." I asked him his name. He then hesitated then said "I'm Edward." I asked his last name. He refused to give his last name. I then asked the name & contact of his supervisor. He said verbatim "I'm not giving you my last name and yeah I'm the manager...I'm the only person on over everybody so they're nobody who can talk about you or what happened so I'm the only one who can do anything." I told him I found that hard to believe and due to how indifferent, nasty and obviously dishonest he has been behaving from the first conversation, he knows he messed up BOTH orders and knew, especially, the second order after Edward knew the unnamed female employee told me how to place the second order from their website brooklynpizzatally.com and did. Now both of those orders $31.78 and $24.10 ORDER # 1E2860B4 Nov 18 7:21pm 22.55 ORDER # 7117A533 7:03pm (pickup) never delivered to my granddaughter. At 11AM Sunday: My granddaughter & babysitter notified me that the neighbors saw the pizza left on the ground in front of the apt door of a vacant apt. sometime after 9pm Saturday. They did not remember seeing a delivery person. First off, both employees affirmed they had not cooked or seen an order let alone acknowledging they delivered a pizza yet witnesses saw the pizza in a Brooklyn Pizza box. Today at 2:41pm I have not heard from Brooklyn Pizza once. I need BOTH charges rever
Jason Bulla
I particularly love the chicken Philly with fries. But, the pizza is some of the best in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Steak & Cheese, Fresh Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Rolls and Pizza, Garlic Bread, Large 1 Topping Pizza
RiRi Luv
Anybody that’s had Brooklyn Pizza, knows that this is not it! This might be OK for Florida standards, but definitely not for New York standards! Crust is super thin almost like cardboard! Chicken Parmesan sandwich was so horrible. The breading was over cooked and hard. Definitely not Italian breadcrumbs. Just super thick no flavor batter and way too much of it. Waitress had a serious attitude problem also! I drove over an hour to get to this place and spent over $50 and everything was trash! Very disappointed the cheese knots and the music was the best part! Sorry never again!
Always 5 stars from the delicious food to the excellent service! I love brooklyns!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Aubrey Nicklaus
Bought garlic bread and a calzone. Garlic bread was fine, but could have been crunchier. It was a 3 star pass. The pepperoni calzone was all salt and rosemary. Not worth the money and nothing special. Do not order a calzone unless you want a mouthful of salt and rosemary. The sauce wasn’t bad, but tasted basic and was nothing to write home about. Overall, I won’t be ordering from them again. Drunk hungry snack, ok. Want good food, skip this.
Food: 1
Donna Uzzi
Tried for the first time yesterday. Although the flavor was good. They were extremely skimpy with the sauce & mushrooms. Pizza was dry and the lack of oil from the cheese tells me it was not good mozzarella. It was probably the bagged Kraft cheese. I paid an extra $2 for barely any mushrooms. Definitely not authentic Brooklyn Pizza. Will not go back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jeff A.
2nd time ordering from here. Super fast delivery. Pizza is not your run of the mill fast food pizza. It's really good. Best pizza I've had since I've been in Tallahassee
Joel P.
The pizza was delicious. Definitely, New York style! Friendly service and good place to sit down for a bite to eat.
Thin, crispy great tasting cheese pizza NY
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a cauliflower pizza online, paid for it. Went to pick it up 45 minutes later only for the girl at the counter to laugh and say "Oh, we canceled your order because we don't have any more cauliflower crust." Be careful ordering because we were charged and will take 5-7 days for a refund!!
All will share with you is, "DON'T THINK THE (3)GARLIC KNOTTS COME WITH YOUR PASTA DISH, AS STATED ON THE WEBSITE." Was rudely made aware of this by a male person behind the counter. Pensacola St.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
The pepperoni pizza was a bit too greasy for my taste, otherwise ok.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
It was alright, tastes fine, definitely not a Brooklyn pizza tho.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Large 1 Topping Pizza
Best pizza I've had in a while. Extra sauce for the win.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a New Yorker I was skeptical, but there was a coupon for this place when I moved into my apartment. Their Sicilian pizza had me absolutely floored. I was drooling. Crust was thick and crispy, cheese doesn't come off all in one bite, QUALITY toppings and a GOOD amount of them. Plus they have a different deal for every day of the week AND weekends!!Also, they're the ONLY good pizza place in town that I know of that sells pizza by the slice. And the price is good on everything on their menu. I can't speak for their sandwiches or any other items, but their pizza, garlic knots, and pepperoni rolls are to die for. ❤️?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Rolls and Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Rolls 5 pcs, Large 1 Topping Pizza
Using my credit card on Saturday November 18 I placed an order to deliver my granddaughters pizza at approximately 8:20pm. When my granddaughter called me saying she never received the pizza, I immediately called Brooklyn Pizza and spoke with a man who never identified himself to ask why. He initially said a woman named "amaris" (sp) picked up the pizza. I told him that my granddaughter nor her babysitter knew any woman by that name nor did either receive the pizza. Both had been eagerly awaiting the pizza and were sitting outside the apt and never saw the delivery. The man then said, (with a nasty attitude) "ma'am we never got any order. What was the name of the order?" I gave him my name, my daughters name. I then gave him the number of my order which I was looking at. I then asked him again "who is Amaris" because I heard you ask me initially who was a woman named "Amaris" that picked up the pizza he then said with an even nastier attitude,"ma'am I'm telling you nobody here even placed an order you need to find out door dash or whoever placed the order because we don't have a way to track orders." After researching Door Dash told me they could see the order was placed by my husband as a pick up and someone named "Amaris" picked up the order at the restaurant Brooklyn pizza. I then called Brooklyn Pizza again. This time I spoke with a woman. She told me "there are only 2 of us and none of us received the order nor did anyone pick up a pizza." I then asked her who was the other employee who sounded as a male. She then said "oh yes there's a male but he didn't receive an order and he didn't sign for a pizza." She offered to contact Door Dash & call me. After speaking with her, she said Door Dash needed to speak with my husband, and I because there was some misunderstanding. I called Door Dash again and they again said "Please contact your bank because we are showing Brooklyn Pizza made the pizza then wrote that they (Brooklyn Pizza) would deliver the pizza and did but they did not write what apt they left it nor did they state that they actually delivered or who received it. Please call your bank immediately." We then called Brooklyn Pizza. A man, the same man I spoke to the first time, answered and immediately he was nastier... indifferent as he again repeated "we never received an order...while, "yes we got other orders but none of them using your name...none of the orders we got even sounded like a order you made so I don't know what to tell you. Call Door then." I asked him his name. He then hesitated then said "I'm Edward." I asked his last name. He refused to give his last name. I then asked the name & contact of his supervisor. He said verbatim "I'm not giving you my last name and yeah I'm the manager...I'm the only person on over everybody so they're nobody who can talk about you or what happened so I'm the only one who can do anything." I told him I found that hard to believe and due to how indifferent, nasty and obviously dishonest he has been behaving from the first conversation, he knows he messed up BOTH orders and knew, especially, the second order after Edward knew the unnamed female employee told me how to place the second order from their website brooklynpizzatally.com and did. Now both of those orders $31.78 and $24.10 ORDER # 1E2860B4 Nov 18 7:21pm 22.55 ORDER # 7117A533 7:03pm (pickup) never delivered to my granddaughter. At 11AM Sunday: My granddaughter & babysitter notified me that the neighbors saw the pizza left on the ground in front of the apt door of a vacant apt. sometime after 9pm Saturday. They did not remember seeing a delivery person. First off, both employees affirmed they had not cooked or seen an order let alone acknowledging they delivered a pizza yet witnesses saw the pizza in a Brooklyn Pizza box. Today at 2:41pm I have not heard from Brooklyn Pizza once. I need BOTH charges rever
I particularly love the chicken Philly with fries. But, the pizza is some of the best in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Steak & Cheese, Fresh Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Rolls and Pizza, Garlic Bread, Large 1 Topping Pizza
Anybody that’s had Brooklyn Pizza, knows that this is not it! This might be OK for Florida standards, but definitely not for New York standards! Crust is super thin almost like cardboard! Chicken Parmesan sandwich was so horrible. The breading was over cooked and hard. Definitely not Italian breadcrumbs. Just super thick no flavor batter and way too much of it. Waitress had a serious attitude problem also! I drove over an hour to get to this place and spent over $50 and everything was trash! Very disappointed the cheese knots and the music was the best part! Sorry never again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Always 5 stars from the delicious food to the excellent service! I love brooklyns!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Bought garlic bread and a calzone. Garlic bread was fine, but could have been crunchier. It was a 3 star pass. The pepperoni calzone was all salt and rosemary. Not worth the money and nothing special. Do not order a calzone unless you want a mouthful of salt and rosemary. The sauce wasn’t bad, but tasted basic and was nothing to write home about. Overall, I won’t be ordering from them again. Drunk hungry snack, ok. Want good food, skip this.
Food: 1
Tried for the first time yesterday. Although the flavor was good. They were extremely skimpy with the sauce & mushrooms. Pizza was dry and the lack of oil from the cheese tells me it was not good mozzarella. It was probably the bagged Kraft cheese. I paid an extra $2 for barely any mushrooms. Definitely not authentic Brooklyn Pizza. Will not go back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
2nd time ordering from here. Super fast delivery. Pizza is not your run of the mill fast food pizza. It's really good. Best pizza I've had since I've been in Tallahassee
The pizza was delicious. Definitely, New York style! Friendly service and good place to sit down for a bite to eat.