1st time visitors! This place was amazing! Tasted just like the pizza I had in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Prosciutto E Arugula
Frank B
Pizza was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
John Crie P.
I can't express just how remarkable Isabella's truly is. It's not merely a restaurant; it's a sanctuary where every dish is crafted with care, every interaction is steeped in warmth, and every moment feels like a genuine connection. Recently, we held an intimate going-away gathering for a cherished family member, and Isabella's played a pivotal role in making it unforgettable. Drawing from our deep-rooted love for food cultivated during our years in Pordenone, Italy, we placed our trust in Isabella's to deliver an experience worthy of our heartfelt celebration. And they exceeded our expectations in every way. Despite the logistical challenge of delivery through a third-party service, Isabella's didn't just deliver pizzas; they delivered an abundance of love and thoughtfulness. After leaving a special note via the delivery app, I called to convey the significance of the occasion and to ask if they could make it extra special. What happened next touched our hearts in ways we never expected. Isabella's took the time to infuse each pizza box with personalized messages, each one a testament to the deep connection they forge with their patrons. These heartfelt gestures not only moved our family member to tears but also served as a source of comfort and strength as they embarked on a new chapter in life. For that moment of pure kindness and the profound sense of love, appreciation, and community they foster, my family and I will be forever grateful to Isabella's. In all my years, I've never encountered a restaurant that embodies such unwavering dedication to its patrons and the community it serves. Amore Mio, S.
Shannon S.
Ask me how a brick oven pizza came out ice cold cheese wasn't even melted. Also a margarita pizza would have basil on it. People wouldn't talk to you look at you like you have 50 heads because you bring a child into the vicinities like they wasn't a child at one point God bless this generation service sucked wouldn't even talk to you wouldn't recommend.
Ashley S.
This is the best "take-out" pizza here in town. The owners are Italian with gourmet pizza a speciality from them. The Diavola is my absolute favorite. I add extra soppressata with onion, mushroom, and, or spinach. I rotate between the combination of toppings. The crust is thin. I fold my slices--that's how big they are. I ALWAYS have a Boylan or two to go. This soda is pure cane sugar . The last I need to try is their gelato,
Zeberlean Jaworski
Hay lắm ạ
xịn lắm nhaaa
Jack C.
Best pizza I've had in tallahassee thus far. I am from NY so my standards are way too high, but this was pretty good for Tallahassee. I've been more than once so if it was good enough to have more than once I recommend it. staff was also very kind and knowledgeable about pizza making
Sharon Perkins
Tallahassee, FL. Great pizza with a thin wood fired crust. The sausage had great fennel flavor, the red sauce was light, all fresh and really good. My husband said, “The pizzas great. It’s better but I can’t figure out why.”Another review mentioned it was close to what he’d had in Italy.My salad with prosciutto di Parma, Kalamata olives, marinated artichoke hearts and spring mix was also fresh and delicious; however because the prosciutto was not cut it was difficult to chew. Don’t order this if you’re trying to impress a date because you’ll be forced to take huge bites.Vibe is perfect for Collegetown.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brooke Nosovitsky
Stopped here 40 minutes before close and had nothing short of 10/10 pizza. If you are a fan of the brick-oven, thin crust that folds over on the best cheese pull in town, this is the spot. Only knock was that there was no parm on the table and the ranch was incredibly thick, almost like mayonnaise. 3/10. But don’t let that hold you back from the pizza.
Great tasting pizza with fresh ingredients and baked in the oven to perection!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Randy
Best pizza in Tallahassee and it's not even close. Cooked in their authentic wood fired oven, you will not find better. I was in Italy this summer and the pizza here was as good if not better than I had there. Try the Capricciosa pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lola Merrimack
I guess the pizza here is more comparable to “authentic” pizza than the Americanized taste most people are used to. I’ve ordered from here 2 different times and both have been pretty average but not very flavorful, a little lackluster. On a positive note, pizza and toppings seem very fresh.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Kasee A.
Folks I just had the WORST experience with a pizza place. I'd place an order for a margarita pie and was given a plain cheese pizza that looked like somebody had put holes in it with their fingers! I had also ordered a calzone on the side that was pepperoni mushroom, and all of the calzone was burnt on the bottom and mushy in the center- it wasn't edible. I called the store to speak with a manager and was promptly told: I watched my employe make your pie and it's right. I interjected: I'm sorry but no, I was given a cheese pie NOT a margarita and also not a fully cooked calzone- I'm very disappointed with my order. Manager; you should look online, that's how the pizza is made and THEN I was hung up on!! I was completely in shock! Like ... I'm not looking for a free meal just the meal that I ordered. I made the attempt to call back only for it to go straight to voicemail *which was full* and of course I couldn't leave a message. WOW WOW I'm just floored and speechless. I'll never go here again and would NOT recommend this tacky place.
Best pizza in Tallahassee. Authentic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto E Arugula
1st time visitors! This place was amazing! Tasted just like the pizza I had in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Prosciutto E Arugula
Pizza was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza
I can't express just how remarkable Isabella's truly is. It's not merely a restaurant; it's a sanctuary where every dish is crafted with care, every interaction is steeped in warmth, and every moment feels like a genuine connection. Recently, we held an intimate going-away gathering for a cherished family member, and Isabella's played a pivotal role in making it unforgettable. Drawing from our deep-rooted love for food cultivated during our years in Pordenone, Italy, we placed our trust in Isabella's to deliver an experience worthy of our heartfelt celebration. And they exceeded our expectations in every way. Despite the logistical challenge of delivery through a third-party service, Isabella's didn't just deliver pizzas; they delivered an abundance of love and thoughtfulness. After leaving a special note via the delivery app, I called to convey the significance of the occasion and to ask if they could make it extra special. What happened next touched our hearts in ways we never expected. Isabella's took the time to infuse each pizza box with personalized messages, each one a testament to the deep connection they forge with their patrons. These heartfelt gestures not only moved our family member to tears but also served as a source of comfort and strength as they embarked on a new chapter in life. For that moment of pure kindness and the profound sense of love, appreciation, and community they foster, my family and I will be forever grateful to Isabella's. In all my years, I've never encountered a restaurant that embodies such unwavering dedication to its patrons and the community it serves. Amore Mio, S.
Ask me how a brick oven pizza came out ice cold cheese wasn't even melted. Also a margarita pizza would have basil on it. People wouldn't talk to you look at you like you have 50 heads because you bring a child into the vicinities like they wasn't a child at one point God bless this generation service sucked wouldn't even talk to you wouldn't recommend.
This is the best "take-out" pizza here in town. The owners are Italian with gourmet pizza a speciality from them. The Diavola is my absolute favorite. I add extra soppressata with onion, mushroom, and, or spinach. I rotate between the combination of toppings. The crust is thin. I fold my slices--that's how big they are. I ALWAYS have a Boylan or two to go. This soda is pure cane sugar . The last I need to try is their gelato,
Hay lắm ạ xịn lắm nhaaa
Best pizza I've had in tallahassee thus far. I am from NY so my standards are way too high, but this was pretty good for Tallahassee. I've been more than once so if it was good enough to have more than once I recommend it. staff was also very kind and knowledgeable about pizza making
Tallahassee, FL. Great pizza with a thin wood fired crust. The sausage had great fennel flavor, the red sauce was light, all fresh and really good. My husband said, “The pizzas great. It’s better but I can’t figure out why.”Another review mentioned it was close to what he’d had in Italy.My salad with prosciutto di Parma, Kalamata olives, marinated artichoke hearts and spring mix was also fresh and delicious; however because the prosciutto was not cut it was difficult to chew. Don’t order this if you’re trying to impress a date because you’ll be forced to take huge bites.Vibe is perfect for Collegetown.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped here 40 minutes before close and had nothing short of 10/10 pizza. If you are a fan of the brick-oven, thin crust that folds over on the best cheese pull in town, this is the spot. Only knock was that there was no parm on the table and the ranch was incredibly thick, almost like mayonnaise. 3/10. But don’t let that hold you back from the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great Pizza!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza
Great tasting pizza with fresh ingredients and baked in the oven to perection!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best pizza in Tallahassee and it's not even close. Cooked in their authentic wood fired oven, you will not find better. I was in Italy this summer and the pizza here was as good if not better than I had there. Try the Capricciosa pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I guess the pizza here is more comparable to “authentic” pizza than the Americanized taste most people are used to. I’ve ordered from here 2 different times and both have been pretty average but not very flavorful, a little lackluster. On a positive note, pizza and toppings seem very fresh.
Food: 3
Service: 3
Folks I just had the WORST experience with a pizza place. I'd place an order for a margarita pie and was given a plain cheese pizza that looked like somebody had put holes in it with their fingers! I had also ordered a calzone on the side that was pepperoni mushroom, and all of the calzone was burnt on the bottom and mushy in the center- it wasn't edible. I called the store to speak with a manager and was promptly told: I watched my employe make your pie and it's right. I interjected: I'm sorry but no, I was given a cheese pie NOT a margarita and also not a fully cooked calzone- I'm very disappointed with my order. Manager; you should look online, that's how the pizza is made and THEN I was hung up on!! I was completely in shock! Like ... I'm not looking for a free meal just the meal that I ordered. I made the attempt to call back only for it to go straight to voicemail *which was full* and of course I couldn't leave a message. WOW WOW I'm just floored and speechless. I'll never go here again and would NOT recommend this tacky place.