I was so excited when I heard Milano reopened. They were my mainstay through the pandemic, usually getting take out several times a month. Yesterday I got take out,, spending $80. Didn't realize they had messed up my order and did have time to return. I ordered an antipasto salad for 2 got a Greek salad instead. Ordered 2 calories 1 of which was supposed to have salami and anchovies instead it had salami and artichokes. Both calzones had little filling inside. Lastly ordered 2 gyros they were the worst, no seasoning just meat on a tasteless pita. This was not the Milano's I knew and loved and I will be reluctant to return anytime soon.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Tressa Hall
I love Milanos EXCEPT for the fact that their pasta has never been drained well. Spaghetti sits in water. Very unappealing. I hope that is better in the new location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jaxi Jay
Pizza was fantastic! I'll be going back to try every menu item!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dedrick King Douglas
Best pizza in tallahassee. I am glad they are back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren S
I've loved their pizza since college (16 plus years). I was sad when it closed BUT super happy when I found it has a new location! Yummy lunch
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Bentley
I am so glad they're back! The new location is still a bit more towards take-out and does not have the same atmosphere as the old, but we ate in and enjoyed our visit. The staff was attentive and the pizza was as good as I remembered (and that is saying something for me being raised in NY). Next time, I look forward to ordering a dinner of chicken marsala, my favorite from their old location. Welcome Back Milano's, you were missed.Vegetarian options: Has many vegetarian options, not vegan.Dietary restrictions: They don't serve pork.Parking: In a busy shopping center.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marian L.
As of August 2021, this sweet little pizzeria has closed. The building is being renovated to house the Tallahassee Police Department. The scoop is they are seeking a new location in midtown, so keep an eye out!
Anthony on the Trail
Best pizza in town. Been going here for years and never disappointed
Kim Blanchet
Nice place, good service, good food. Service was excellent. Clean interior.
Sha'ron Stoneyy
This food was so amazing. I was going to go to Olive garden but I'm glad I didn't. This place is so much better
If you like REAL NY/NJ pizza, then GO HERE!!! This is truly the BEST pizza in Tallahassee. I’ve tried them all. This is it.
Lizzy Troy
I would give zero stars if I could. We put our order in at 9pm on Doordash on 5/11/2021. 10 minutes before 10pm, they close the store and cancel our order with absolutely no warning, and we don't even know if we will receive a refund! We called the store as soon as we realized this, but not only were they closed and not answering the phone, but the voicemail was full, so we couldn't even leave a message for management. We will call tomorrow to make sure something is done about this. As of now, super unprofessional. NOT A HAPPY CUSTOMER!
Stephanie Esparza
I ordered the fettuccine alfredo, and had a taste of heaven. Everything tasted scrumptious! Wonderful local food! ☺️
Lesley Conrad
Locally owned, lovely small, quiet spot with delicious Chicken Marsala, Eggplant Florentine, fresh, warm, homemade rolls and good wine. Perfect comfort food for this afternoon with the softly falling springtime rain. Most enjoyable.
N M
So good and fresh! The stuffed shells are awesome! The waitress Meagan (not sure if I spelled it correctly) is the absolute best!!!
I was so excited when I heard Milano reopened. They were my mainstay through the pandemic, usually getting take out several times a month. Yesterday I got take out,, spending $80. Didn't realize they had messed up my order and did have time to return. I ordered an antipasto salad for 2 got a Greek salad instead. Ordered 2 calories 1 of which was supposed to have salami and anchovies instead it had salami and artichokes. Both calzones had little filling inside. Lastly ordered 2 gyros they were the worst, no seasoning just meat on a tasteless pita. This was not the Milano's I knew and loved and I will be reluctant to return anytime soon.
Food: 2
Service: 1
I love Milanos EXCEPT for the fact that their pasta has never been drained well. Spaghetti sits in water. Very unappealing. I hope that is better in the new location.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Pizza was fantastic! I'll be going back to try every menu item!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in tallahassee. I am glad they are back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've loved their pizza since college (16 plus years). I was sad when it closed BUT super happy when I found it has a new location! Yummy lunch
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am so glad they're back! The new location is still a bit more towards take-out and does not have the same atmosphere as the old, but we ate in and enjoyed our visit. The staff was attentive and the pizza was as good as I remembered (and that is saying something for me being raised in NY). Next time, I look forward to ordering a dinner of chicken marsala, my favorite from their old location. Welcome Back Milano's, you were missed.Vegetarian options: Has many vegetarian options, not vegan.Dietary restrictions: They don't serve pork.Parking: In a busy shopping center.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
As of August 2021, this sweet little pizzeria has closed. The building is being renovated to house the Tallahassee Police Department. The scoop is they are seeking a new location in midtown, so keep an eye out!
Best pizza in town. Been going here for years and never disappointed
Nice place, good service, good food. Service was excellent. Clean interior.
This food was so amazing. I was going to go to Olive garden but I'm glad I didn't. This place is so much better
Restaurantji Recommends
If you like REAL NY/NJ pizza, then GO HERE!!! This is truly the BEST pizza in Tallahassee. I’ve tried them all. This is it.
I would give zero stars if I could. We put our order in at 9pm on Doordash on 5/11/2021. 10 minutes before 10pm, they close the store and cancel our order with absolutely no warning, and we don't even know if we will receive a refund! We called the store as soon as we realized this, but not only were they closed and not answering the phone, but the voicemail was full, so we couldn't even leave a message for management. We will call tomorrow to make sure something is done about this. As of now, super unprofessional. NOT A HAPPY CUSTOMER!
I ordered the fettuccine alfredo, and had a taste of heaven. Everything tasted scrumptious! Wonderful local food! ☺️
Locally owned, lovely small, quiet spot with delicious Chicken Marsala, Eggplant Florentine, fresh, warm, homemade rolls and good wine. Perfect comfort food for this afternoon with the softly falling springtime rain. Most enjoyable.
So good and fresh! The stuffed shells are awesome! The waitress Meagan (not sure if I spelled it correctly) is the absolute best!!!