Can you say Yummy yum yum make your tongue slap your jaw good!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried, Fish, Seafood
Robbie Spivey
We were excited to go with what we'd seen on the Internet. Ordered an appetizer and server must not have put the order in. It came literally at the same time as the meal and took a long time. Calamari was very tough, stuffed grouper was probably the worst I've ever had, crab cakes were disappointing, collards were very good. Told the server and they gave us $6 off a $80 buck bill. I gave the server that. I think he was new but the service did not deserve a tip. The manager never even spoke to us. Very disappointed and won't be back. Could be a great place and hope it improves! P.S. I have never given a poor review for a restaurant in my life.
nancy tamariz
Diana was the best!!! St. Paddy’s day server ☘️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood
shannon shephard
Riley was a great bartender. She made the best Bloody Mary! We had oysters, fish tacos, crab legs and the cheese grits with grouper. Everything was amazing, definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Hyatt
Service was slow and poorly managed. Waitress turning away and taking personal calls. Restrooms not maintained, and food quality slipping. They won't be open much longer.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Sarah Coven
Rileigh was so great and treated us really well!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood
Wayne Harvey
My wife and I went out for our 52nd wedding anniversary with a desire for good food over fancy surroundings. We weren't disappointed! The fried oysters were some of the best we've tasted. Every piece of food was prepared well. To make things even better, our server, Hannah Smith, the bar manager, was always available and quick with an enjoyable manner. We highly recommend the restaurant to anyone who enjoys seafood.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried, Seafood
Anonymous P.
Normally the food is great. Service is sub par. I called a week before Valentine's Day to book a table knowing that every restaurant in Tallahassee will be booked. Called today, 2-14-24, to find out my reservation was not there. While the associate was being the middle man between me and their manager the associate hung up on me. I'm glad everyone else is doing ok... screw me right?
Anson Maxwell
My wife ordered take-out for her grandmother's 98th birthday using the Facebook app. When we arrived at Tally Fish House to pick up the food, they didn't know the order ever existed. The manager stated that supposedly the owner "turned off the ability to order online".We were going to let them make our order while we waited, because we were extremely late at this point. My wife started to explain to the young lady what we had ordered. This is when the lady told us that the menu no longer had that item and that fried shrimp only comes with one side instead of two (the Facebook order app had an outdated menu). So my wife and I decided that we would just like a refund and we would go to The Wharf instead.Once I asked for the refund, the young lady said she couldn't refund the money because she didn't have a ticket to refund because it's lost somewhere on the internet. We showed her our bank account where $84 was taken out. I asked her to give us cash. She refused but took my wife's information down to give to the owner. If I ever see the money again I'll be surprised.Looks like Hurricanes isn't the only thing about to close down in that shopping center.
Service: 1
Raymond Albritton
Was made to wait outside in the cold. 30 minutes turned into an hour and a half.Two servers, one man kitchen. And that's the good part.
This place sucked. We sat there for 2 hours in an empty restaurant, waiting for a clueless waiter that made no less than 10 errors throughout the whole process. It took 5 attempts to get our checks right. I’m a former server, this guy sucked, this place sucked. Food overpriced, and no attempt to make any of the bad experience better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jacob Geiger
Always a great time, delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. The new crab cakes are awesome! Lizzie was an excellent bartender.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Trigger Fish, Gulf Oysters, Catfish, Key Lime Pie
J T
No complaints, great food and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grouper and Grits, Crab Claws
Kelly B.
We had a late lunch today, our server was tied up with a large party. The hostess, Hannah took great care of us. She made sure everything was perfect, from my margarita to the food! I had the boiled red royal shrimp and a salad. My husband had steamed oysters. Thank you again, Hannah for the excellent service.
Can you say Yummy yum yum make your tongue slap your jaw good!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried, Fish, Seafood
We were excited to go with what we'd seen on the Internet. Ordered an appetizer and server must not have put the order in. It came literally at the same time as the meal and took a long time. Calamari was very tough, stuffed grouper was probably the worst I've ever had, crab cakes were disappointing, collards were very good. Told the server and they gave us $6 off a $80 buck bill. I gave the server that. I think he was new but the service did not deserve a tip. The manager never even spoke to us. Very disappointed and won't be back. Could be a great place and hope it improves! P.S. I have never given a poor review for a restaurant in my life.
Diana was the best!!! St. Paddy’s day server ☘️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood
Riley was a great bartender. She made the best Bloody Mary! We had oysters, fish tacos, crab legs and the cheese grits with grouper. Everything was amazing, definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was slow and poorly managed. Waitress turning away and taking personal calls. Restrooms not maintained, and food quality slipping. They won't be open much longer.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Rileigh was so great and treated us really well!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood
My wife and I went out for our 52nd wedding anniversary with a desire for good food over fancy surroundings. We weren't disappointed! The fried oysters were some of the best we've tasted. Every piece of food was prepared well. To make things even better, our server, Hannah Smith, the bar manager, was always available and quick with an enjoyable manner. We highly recommend the restaurant to anyone who enjoys seafood.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried, Seafood
Normally the food is great. Service is sub par. I called a week before Valentine's Day to book a table knowing that every restaurant in Tallahassee will be booked. Called today, 2-14-24, to find out my reservation was not there. While the associate was being the middle man between me and their manager the associate hung up on me. I'm glad everyone else is doing ok... screw me right?
My wife ordered take-out for her grandmother's 98th birthday using the Facebook app. When we arrived at Tally Fish House to pick up the food, they didn't know the order ever existed. The manager stated that supposedly the owner "turned off the ability to order online".We were going to let them make our order while we waited, because we were extremely late at this point. My wife started to explain to the young lady what we had ordered. This is when the lady told us that the menu no longer had that item and that fried shrimp only comes with one side instead of two (the Facebook order app had an outdated menu). So my wife and I decided that we would just like a refund and we would go to The Wharf instead.Once I asked for the refund, the young lady said she couldn't refund the money because she didn't have a ticket to refund because it's lost somewhere on the internet. We showed her our bank account where $84 was taken out. I asked her to give us cash. She refused but took my wife's information down to give to the owner. If I ever see the money again I'll be surprised.Looks like Hurricanes isn't the only thing about to close down in that shopping center.
Service: 1
Was made to wait outside in the cold. 30 minutes turned into an hour and a half.Two servers, one man kitchen. And that's the good part.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Bottomless bloody Mary's or mimosas. $13Food was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
This place sucked. We sat there for 2 hours in an empty restaurant, waiting for a clueless waiter that made no less than 10 errors throughout the whole process. It took 5 attempts to get our checks right. I’m a former server, this guy sucked, this place sucked. Food overpriced, and no attempt to make any of the bad experience better.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Always a great time, delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. The new crab cakes are awesome! Lizzie was an excellent bartender.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Trigger Fish, Gulf Oysters, Catfish, Key Lime Pie
No complaints, great food and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grouper and Grits, Crab Claws
We had a late lunch today, our server was tied up with a large party. The hostess, Hannah took great care of us. She made sure everything was perfect, from my margarita to the food! I had the boiled red royal shrimp and a salad. My husband had steamed oysters. Thank you again, Hannah for the excellent service.