The best key lime pie ever!! So glad we found this on my find me gluten free app. My celiac husband was extremely happy.Owner so very friendly and personal.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free key lime pie
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Key Lime Pie
Mademoiselle MT
Overrated and a bit Expensive.I tried the key lime pie on a stick from the Sarasota Farmers Market because I saw many people eating them. Satisfactory but I was expecting it to be better based on the $6 price tag!! Here’s why - I thought because it was frozen treat that the key lime pie itself would have the cold frozen popsicle style, needing a good bite but instead it seemed and tasted room temperature with just layer of frozen chocolate.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Roger Willroth
Best Key Lime Pie, we always get a pie when visiting
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Faye B.
The pie sampler was a great way to test the flavors! Banana creme and original key lime were the winners!!
Gerry Broecker
The best key lime pie I've ever had !
Food: 5
Melinda Rutherford
Cute lil shop. Has been in Sarasota for many years. We got the keyline raspberry pie. OMG so so good. We got the variety pack to try the other flavors. Will update the post once we try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Raspberry Key Lime Pie, Chocolate Silk Pie, Chocolate Key Lime, Chocolate Silk, Tropical Fruit Key Lime Pie
M W
Outstanding! They had many choices but I went with the classic key lime pie. I also enjoyed the frozen key lime pie dipped in chocolate on a stick.
Jim Sachtjen
It's been years since I had one of their pies when they were on Swift Rd. I thought they were out of business and while searching Google maps for something I saw the Bee Ridge store. To say they're awesome still falls short. There goes my waistline.
Bob Pressley
Ditto! The best key lime pie we have ever had… A+
Linda N.
Best food and best service! Love this company!!! Delicious fudge and pies. The young gentleman who is one of the owners of this family owned company could not be a more nice and kind person.
Key Lime Pie is really good and their pie on a stick is really good.
Naara P
I was visiting FL for my dads bday last week He loves Key Lime Pie. Many people told me to get a pie here because of how good it is and I am so happy I did. My father loved it. I don’t even like Key Lime Pie, but I loved this one! Their banana pie is amazing also! You will not regret purchasing from this company. My family and I were so pleased!
N G
I was visiting FL for my dads bday last week He loves Key Lime Pie. Many people told me to get a pie here because of how good it is and I am so happy I did. My father loved it. I don’t even like Key Lime Pie, but I loved this one! Their banana pie is amazing also! You will not regret purchasing from this company. My family and I were so pleased!
Danielle Hays
The best pies! Everytime Ivisit my parents and Grandmother in Punta Gorda, the first thing they look for is if I brought a coconut and chocolate pie! They say they have never had a coconut pie that has so much real coconut actually in the pie! Theyrave about it! Saturdays at the Bradenton market day is an easy place to pick them up!
Alex M.
Delicious pie!!! I would say the coconut one was by far my favorite! And the peanut butter one was also really good.People raved about the key lime pie there but I think I have had better other places. It is good but I wouldn't say it's the best I've had. Would certainly go back and get other flavors of pie to try them for sure
The best key lime pie ever!! So glad we found this on my find me gluten free app. My celiac husband was extremely happy.Owner so very friendly and personal.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free key lime pie
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Key Lime Pie
Overrated and a bit Expensive.I tried the key lime pie on a stick from the Sarasota Farmers Market because I saw many people eating them. Satisfactory but I was expecting it to be better based on the $6 price tag!! Here’s why - I thought because it was frozen treat that the key lime pie itself would have the cold frozen popsicle style, needing a good bite but instead it seemed and tasted room temperature with just layer of frozen chocolate.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Best Key Lime Pie, we always get a pie when visiting
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pie sampler was a great way to test the flavors! Banana creme and original key lime were the winners!!
The best key lime pie I've ever had !
Food: 5
Cute lil shop. Has been in Sarasota for many years. We got the keyline raspberry pie. OMG so so good. We got the variety pack to try the other flavors. Will update the post once we try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Raspberry Key Lime Pie, Chocolate Silk Pie, Chocolate Key Lime, Chocolate Silk, Tropical Fruit Key Lime Pie
Outstanding! They had many choices but I went with the classic key lime pie. I also enjoyed the frozen key lime pie dipped in chocolate on a stick.
It's been years since I had one of their pies when they were on Swift Rd. I thought they were out of business and while searching Google maps for something I saw the Bee Ridge store. To say they're awesome still falls short. There goes my waistline.
Ditto! The best key lime pie we have ever had… A+
Best food and best service! Love this company!!! Delicious fudge and pies. The young gentleman who is one of the owners of this family owned company could not be a more nice and kind person.
Restaurantji Recommends
Key Lime Pie is really good and their pie on a stick is really good.
I was visiting FL for my dads bday last week He loves Key Lime Pie. Many people told me to get a pie here because of how good it is and I am so happy I did. My father loved it. I don’t even like Key Lime Pie, but I loved this one! Their banana pie is amazing also! You will not regret purchasing from this company. My family and I were so pleased!
I was visiting FL for my dads bday last week He loves Key Lime Pie. Many people told me to get a pie here because of how good it is and I am so happy I did. My father loved it. I don’t even like Key Lime Pie, but I loved this one! Their banana pie is amazing also! You will not regret purchasing from this company. My family and I were so pleased!
The best pies! Everytime Ivisit my parents and Grandmother in Punta Gorda, the first thing they look for is if I brought a coconut and chocolate pie! They say they have never had a coconut pie that has so much real coconut actually in the pie! Theyrave about it! Saturdays at the Bradenton market day is an easy place to pick them up!
Delicious pie!!! I would say the coconut one was by far my favorite! And the peanut butter one was also really good.People raved about the key lime pie there but I think I have had better other places. It is good but I wouldn't say it's the best I've had. Would certainly go back and get other flavors of pie to try them for sure