Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks

360 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park
(407) 636-5333

Recent Reviews

joey larosa

Grandma slice was fabulous!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Antonella's Calzone, Sicilian

Brenda Mulberry

This place saved my lunch! Was gonna go to Ethos Vegan Kitchen and drove all the way from Cocoa Beach to go BUT the Health Department closed them down! SO it just happens that this lovely little Italian Pizzeria was right in the same parking lot. We all had something great. They had a Cauliflower pizza crust and Vegan cheese with all kinds of veggies!!! So Yummy I’d drive back just to have it again. Staff was great. Inside and outside dining. A little bit small area but very nice and clean.Vegetarian options: Vegan cheese and lots of veggies for pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Greek Salad

gil martinez

It has a vibe, old school pizzeria thing, like the smell of baked dough seeping through the walls for years. Not the sterile brick and mortar pizza chain, it's the real deal! Cozy pizza joint thank reminds me of NYC!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Garlic Knots, Greek Salad

Shane P.

Never had a bad meal here. Service is quick and attentive and the menu offers a variety or lunch/dinner specials. Try the Pasta Fagioli soup, calzones, and meatballs. You won't be sorry! And love the owner, Antonella. She's friendly and genuinely cares about her customers.

Craig DeLongy

Ordered thru door dash and my order was delivered incomplete. Antonella’s told me to contact Door Dash. Not their problem!!! DD said contact the pizzeria WARNING ABOUT ANTONELLA’s Losing a customer over $23.00. Not smart

Service: 1

David Beck

Fantastic pizza and Stromboli. Best pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joanette Corpening

I am not from this area but I chose this place simply based on the reviews. Id give The food 1 star because it is pretty flavorless. I did not enjoy it at all and it left an after taste in my mouth. The best thing about my experience was the friendly helpful young lady standing out in the cold at the desk to help customers with their orders. 5 stars to her. It was cold outside but she was smiling and seemed eager to service customers. Sorry but I won’t be back

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 5

Antonio A.

The food is excellent. Service is great. The restaurant is simple in its style but always clean and organized.

Jacqueline A.

The service was on point the minute we walked though the door! We where a party of 10 and they accommodated us and made us feel welcomed! I am visiting from nyc my family that moved to winter park visiting from NYC and we know our pizza and italian food. So of course we are picky! The food was great and delish and fresh! The owner of this place is from NY as well! The place was friendly and comfy! Tasty flavors from nyc right here!!! Highly recommend this place!! oh and great prices!!

Sarah Charters

Pizza was delicious and the gluten free crust was crazy good.Staff was so kind and reassured that the pizza was gluten free and I’d 100% come back for more.Greek salad was great too.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Greek Salad

Crowned Neptune

Te best gluten free pizza and pasta I’ve ever had ! if it was closer to where I live I wouldn’t go anywhere else for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandy R.

Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for lunch! Great find! Great variety of lunch specials through 4pm. I opted for the 1/2 hero (Italian cold cut, but you can choose from several heroes) and small Caesar salad. This special is #4 on the lunch menu; it's called "Twice As Nice". The salad was a generous portion for a side salad and tasted good. The hero was HUGE! Probably an 8" sub, packed with Italian meats and cheese. I had to eat it open face, with a knife and fork as it was too big to close to bite into. The pizza looked good! I think I'll try that next time. This place is small. Only 4 tables inside, and just a couple outside. If you want to dine in, visit during off hours or he prepared yo wait for a table - Butnthe wait will be well worth it! Highly recommend!

Sydney Crawford

True tri-state pizza

Dava P.

We were in the area and looking for an affordable bite to eat. My boyfriend was in the mood for pizza, and Antonella's Pizzeria came up when I searched pizza. So why not, we love trying new places, and the reviews seemed pretty good. They had good lunch specials, so we both rolled with the 2 slices & salad special. They had many other lunch special choices as well. I'm sure we will be back to try out a pasta ones most likely in the future. The salad was bigger than expected but fresh and good. I upgraded my slices for tomatoe & spinach, it was hood i just felt they overdid it on the toppings. Overall, we enjoyed the food. There were not many seating spots but we chose to sit on their patio since it was so hot inside. They stay busy tho I will say, they had a lot of pickup orders and uber eats it looked like. I say if you're in the area, give it a shot, and we will be back.

Kevin Ruehlen

So good and amazing pricing! The lunch special has amazing values my favorite is the chicken parm on the garlic knot. Tried the cannoli today and it was amazing. Every server Ive had here is very kind.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Cannoli, Garlic Knots

Load More